3 ms·
The idea that we need to find a single escape-goat to blame and throw in jail for every accident is a very antiquated way to think about justice. There are man
by dheera 6y ago
The idea that we need to find a single escape-goat to blame and throw in jail for every accident is a very antiquated way to think about justice.
There are many cases where nobody is at fault, or multiple people are collectively at fault.
I would much prefer we think in terms of overall safety. If human drivers have 30000 deaths a year, and switching to autonomous driving results in 1000 deaths per year, we've made progress as a society. We don't need to hunt down and throw people (or cars) in jail for those 1000 deaths.
We should instead demand that engineers investigate those 1000 deaths and try to find ways to get them as close to 0 as possible. Throwing people in jail is a waste of resources that could be diverted towards achieving better safety. The engineers should be investigating and making improvements, not sitting in a jail cell.
(Of course, if there is intentional negligence that resulted in 1000 deaths when there would normally be 500, that's another story.)
- Polylactic_acid 6y agoFair comment but what about when there are monetary damages that need to be paid. Someone is going to have to pay for the cars and what they crash in to to be repaired. If tesla pushes out an update that causes your car to automatically steer in to another one, are you the owner responsible for paying for both cars to be fixed?
- dheera 6y agoInsurance pays. If it's two autonomous cars, split the bill. The insurance companies should be happy that accidents happen at 1/30 the rate they used to (if we take my numbers above as an example). They can give you an 80% discount on your insurance premium for having an autonomous car, and still net a massive profit when averaged over all their customers over time.
- cgriswald 6y agoYou haven’t answered the question. Who pays for the insurance?
- perl4ever 6y agoWhat happens now, when your car breaks in a way that causes an accident? Obviously this is a thing that happens and it is dealt with somehow. It hasn't happened to me, and I'm not a lawyer, so I can't say for sure offhand. At least in my state, there is no fault coverage everyone has to buy, that covers medical bills up to a certain amount. It does not cover fixing your car. If there is nobody responsible for a collision, maybe the repairs would fall under comprehensive coverage. From what I read, if you hit a deer, it's covered under comprehensive. But if you try to avoid hitting a deer and run into a tree, it's covered under collision. So it seems somewhat arbitrary.
- cgriswald 6y agoThere's at least a magnitude of difference between a driver, who is always in control of the vehicle, suddenly finding that his brakes have failed, and then doing what he can to reduce or minimize the impact of the accident; and a driver who is basically a passenger having to make what is likely to be a last-minute decision to wrench control from an anonymous vehicle. A decision that will be heavily question by the manufacturers' lawyers or insurance companies. If it's not possible to take control, would he have any liability at all?
- perl4ever 6y agoWell, yeah, who knows if the driver of the car that causes the accident would seem responsible. Which is why I wouldn't want to own that kind of car. If they really are that much safer, then I should benefit from them being on the road anyway.
- cgriswald 6y agoI though the same way: It's better if everyone else has one. But I don't think it'll play out that way. You'll benefit from the additional safety. On the other hand, if there is an accident involving you and the other car is a self-driving car, the assumption will be (and the manufacturer's lawyers will argue) that you, the human, are at fault. It might even be the case, but I suspect it'll be more of a guilty-until-proven-innocent situation regardless.
- Xylakant 6y ago> The idea that we need to find a single escape-goat to blame and throw in jail for every accident is a very antiquated way to think about justice. There are many cases where nobody is at fault, or multiple people are collectively at fault. But that’s not what we do. We don’t pick a scapegoat and throw them in jail for every accident. We investigate the role the individuals had in the accident, and only if an individual was clearly at fault, they are fined. Often such trials end up with a shared responsibility where the parties at fault also have to jointly pay for the damages caused. So the question remains: if a car on autopilot crashes, who needs to be investigated? The “driver” who had little to no control over the vehicle at that time? The legal cop-out of “you must be in control at all times” won’t fly with proper self driving.
- dheera 6y ago> who needs to be investigated This shouldn't be about "who". This should be about a team of several hundred engineers who investigate the hell out of that data at work and figure out if it could be prevented the next time, and if so, deploy an update. Courts getting involved for every accident with that engineering effort and taking time out of their dayjobs for a legal investigation would only delay the solution and cause more loss of life. There should be accountability in terms of ensuring that a fair engineering investigation happens, and how to modify the code to make it even better than it already is. It's about which lines of code need to be changed, not about "who" needs to be investigated. It's precisely this "who" thinking that I think we need to get over, especially when machines already do far better than humans at certain tasks. Elevators are pretty much all autonomous these days. When elevator accidents happen do we go tracking down which engineer in the elevator design company is at fault? No, as long as it isn't a case of intentional negligence, we first figure out whether the injured person did something wrong, and if not, the team of engineers at the elevator company work together to try to re-engineer the elevators to be more safe the next time around without pointing fingers within their company. And the result? Elevators are pretty much 99.99999% (or whatever) safe these days.
- IncRnd 6y ago> I would much prefer we think in terms of overall safety. If human drivers have 30000 deaths a year, and switching to autonomous driving results in 1000 deaths per year, we've made progress as a society. We don't need to hunt down and throw people (or cars) in jail for those 1000 deaths. You may prefer that, but the 1,000 people who wouldn't have died otherwise, well they aren't thinking much, anymore. People aren't numbers whose lives and deaths can be shifted around by the vagaries of the status of AP glitch fixes.
- dheera 6y agoYou could say that about anything, really. There is a small number of people who die in plane crashes today. Historically, before planes existed there were a much larger fraction of people who died crossing oceans by ship. The handful of people who die in plane crashes "wouldn't have died otherwise", but I think the majority of people agree that planes are the preferred (in terms of safety) way to get across oceans, and they are more or less the only choice for civilians unless they want to take a luxury cruise. Same thing about cars/trains vs. walking thousands of miles across deserts. Overall more lives are saved, but yes, a small handful of people are going to get hit crossing the road/tracks that wouldn't have gotten hit if cars/trains weren't invented.
- IncRnd 6y agoYes, you can say that about many things, which is why safety is paramount. Not an "overall" safety that kills fewer people, but that no additional people will die. There is responsibility incurrred for kiling 1,000 people who wouldn't have otherwise died. It's really a terrible argument to say, "we killed different people." > The handful of people who die in plane crashes "wouldn't have died otherwise", but I think the majority of people agree that planes are the preferred (in terms of safety) way to get across oceans, and they are more or less the only choice for civilians unless they want to take a luxury cruise. When a person is hit by a falling plane, there will likely be liablity assigned. Similarly, when someone is run over by an AP navigated car, there will be liability assigned, even if it makes the jobs of engineers more difficult. > Same thing about cars/trains vs. walking thousands of miles across deserts. Overall more lives are saved, but yes, a small handful of people are going to get hit crossing the road/tracks that wouldn't have gotten hit if cars/trains weren't invented. Exactly. That is why people and companies are assigned liablity, not just for intentional torts, but for negligence. When people "do things" they are responsible for not creating havoc or destruction, regardless of how helpful their actions otherwise are. If the walls fall off your house, are you going to thank the building contracter for making the safest house around? Because, the way you are talking, you would be happy to pay for a replacement house without holding that "safest builder" responsible - even if people were crushed by the falling roof.