5 ms·
> the really weird thing about this particular four-vector is that it always has a magnitude of exactly the speed of light This isn't weird. The magnitude of a
by pdonis 6y ago
> the really weird thing about this particular four-vector is that it always has a magnitude of exactly the speed of light
This isn't weird. The magnitude of any four-vector is frame invariant in relativity. Lorentz transformations in relativity are the analogue of rotations in ordinary Euclidean space, and have the same property of preserving the magnitudes of vectors.
> All you do by going faster is just mix some of the time component of your four-velocity into the spatial components.
I think this is a misleading way of putting it. In a frame in which you are moving, the time component of your four-velocity is larger than it is in your rest frame, not smaller. So it's not the case that some of the time component in your rest frame got "moved" to a space component.
- dheera 6y agoIt should be stated somewhere here that relativity operates in Minkowski space and not Euclidian 4D space. What this means is that the length of a relativistic four-vector [ct, x, y, z] is sqrt((ct)^2 - (x^2 + y^2 + z^2)). It is not the same as the Euclidian magnitude, i.e. NOT sqrt((ct)^2 + x^2 + y^2 + z^2) The article does mention this, although with slightly confusing wording, but it should be emphasized that Lorentz invariant quantities need to be computed with the Minkowski metric.
- tgvaughan 6y agoJust an aside: exploring the implications of relativity in a Euclidean space is the basis of Greg Egan's "Orthogonal" book series.
- Retric 6y agoThe early versions of Minkowski space used imaginary numbers which you prefer is mostly just notation.
- michaelsbradley 6y agoIt’s possible to formulate SR/GR in Euclidean geometry as well: https://www.euclideanrelativity.com/ https://www.euclideanrelativity.com/
- andi999 6y agoAt first it seems suprising that this invariant is always the same for different objects and setups (that it is the same after Lorentz transformation is the meaning of invariant as you pointed out). So why is it for all objects equal to c. If you think for stationary examples it just means that the eigenzeit has a different pace, so two clocks next to each other going at a different pace. But this is ruled out by another definition, such that clocks are references by light clocks. And now it is also clear why this invariance is c.
- Filligree 6y agoIt's not equal to C, as such. It's a unit vector, and physicists working with relativity habitually set C=1 to make the equations simpler. That being said, it isn't really a vector -- it's just a direction. The "equal to C" bit is a mathematical artifact of both vectors being normalized.
- andi999 6y agoWell, c is the conversion factor between our length and time measurement. For me, I am ok not to measure time in meter, so c can stay.
- pdonis 6y ago> why is it for all objects equal to c Because this 4-vector removes the factor of rest mass, which distinguishes objects. Putting back the rest mass converts 4-velocity to 4-momentum, which does not have the same magnitude for all objects--the magnitude is the rest mass.
- garmaine 6y agoIt's very weird to someone who has never been exposed to this before, who has only ever worked with vectors in a context where they certainly can be of varying magnitudes, like velocity normally is in Newtonian mechanics.
- Filligree 6y agoOr put another way, it's not a vector. It's just a direction.
- jules 6y agoThat's because the four velocity is not really a velocity. The path of a particle through spacetime can be described by a function p(r) = (x(r),y(r),z(r),t(r)) that gives the position (x,y,z,t) as a function of a parameter r. This way the point p(r) traces out some path in spacetime. Now, the same path is described by many different parameterizations. For example, if we pick q(r) = p(2r) that's the same path. The point varies twice as fast with r, but that has no physical meaning. The total path that is traced out in spacetime is still the same path. That is, the set {p(r) | r in [-∞,∞]} is the same as the set {q(r) | r in [-∞,∞]}, and it is only this set that has physical meaning. In fact, we can also pick q(r) = p(r^3 + r) or some other parameter transformation. We might look at the vector p'(r) tangent to the path. The length of this vector depends on the parameterization, but its direction doesn't. So p'(r)/|p'(r)| is a true physical property of the path, but the length |p'(r)| is just an artefact of the parameterization that we chose to describe the path. In order to make the parameterization somewhat more canonical, we usually pick a parameterization where |p'(r)| = c. As it happens, the four velocity is defined to be p'(r) given this choice of parameterization. So the length of the four velocity is c simply by definition. This statement has no physical meaning. The statement "we travel through time with the speed of light" is uninteresting. It tells you nothing about physics. It only tells you something about the conventions we use when we describe paths through spacetime. We could very well have picked the convention |p'(r)| = c/2, and then we'd have the statement "we travel through time with half the speed of light", or even |p'(r)| = 2c, and then we'd "travel through time with double the speed of light". Given any path through spacetime whatsoever, we can pick a parameterization such that it travels through spacetime at the speed of light. So the condition that something travels through spacetime with the speed of light places no constraints on the path that it takes. The statement "we travel through spacetime with the speed of light" makes it sound like there are paths that do travel through spacetime with the speed of light, and there are paths that do not travel through spacetime with the speed of light, and physical particles go along paths of the first kind. This is wrong. There are no paths that do not travel through spacetime at the speed of light, because whether or not it does is a property of the parameterization that we choose to describe the path, not a property of the path itself.
- tgb 6y ago> This isn't weird. The magnitude of any four-vector is frame invariant in relativity. Lorentz transformations in relativity are the analogue of rotations in ordinary Euclidean space, and have the same property of preserving the magnitudes of vectors. The weird part isn't that two observers agree on the vector magnitude. The weird part is that one observer calculates the same value for any two objects. Frame-invariance isn't the relevant property.
- pdonis 6y ago> The weird part is that one observer calculates the same value for any two objects. That's not weird either, because the value being calculated has all object-specific information removed. See my response to andi999 downthread regarding rest mass.
- tgb 6y agoThat's the part that's "weird" in the sense of being very different from the similarly-named concept in classical mechanics of velocity vector magnitude. But moreover, the rest mass isn't the issue here. Momentum in classical mechanics also takes mass into account but doesn't have the "weird" property that two objects of the same rest mass always have the same momentum magnitude.