5 ms·

Worth noting that this power plant was run by an arm of the United States government.

losteric 6y ago
Why is that worth noting? I feel like you're being intentionally ambiguous by leaving unstated implications. Do you believe public operation had an impact on safety? Better or worse, and based on what evidence? If neither, how is your statement relevant to the discussion?
- Aerroon 6y ago
  I don't know why the parent poster brought it up, but it does seem relevant to me. The government isn't going after quick profits, so you can't blame it on that. You might be able to blame profits if it had been a private corporation though.
  - skissane 6y ago
    The public and private sectors are, in principle, equally capable of incompetence; the causes tend to be somewhat different, but the outcome can be the same.
  - TheSpiceIsLife 6y ago
    Profits play a massive factor in why governments tend to be incompetent. What do you think taxes are? They're a wealth transfer without option from everyone else to those in the employ of government. A whole bunch of people are profit from government expenditure, we even have a word for a special type of fraud about government expenditure: pork barelling: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pork_barrel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pork_barrel But, government run operations tend he notorious for incompetence for a few reasons, others have done a better job of detailing: https://www.bing.com/search?q=why+governments+are+notorious+for+incompetence&form=APIPH1&PC=APPL https://www.bing.com/search?q=why+governments+are+notorious+...
ineedasername 6y ago
That is only worth noting if you bring it along with a more detailed account of accident rates by government-owned facilities as compared to privately owned facilities. Until then it's just an anecdotal bit of snark that serves a political world view without the evidence necessary to evaluate it.
kingaillas 6y ago
In 2013, an ammonium nitrate storage facility exploded (1). In 2014, a leaky storage container poisoned a river in West Virginia (2). It's instructive to consider some thought experiments/scenarios: What if... a) Both were run by the government. In this case you'd have people of certain political parties screaming about government incompetence, and how the best solution would be to eliminate regulations and privatize, since competition somehow guarantees better results. b) Foreigners deliberately engineered both situations, an act of terrorism. In which case as certain administrations after 9/11, the US might pick some country that didn't have anything to do with it and go to war. c) Private companies were responsible. This is actually the case and the collective attitude was generally "eh, shit happens, private companies just trying to run a business". Just declare bankruptcy and walk. No real changes made in either case. 1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/West_Fertilizer_Company_explosion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/West_Fertilizer_Company_explos... 2 -
- mixedCase 6y ago
  Your biases are showing. Issues in private businesses drives regulation all the time around the world.
  - r00fus 6y ago
    Not in the US. They pony up, hire lobbyists and get off scot free or with acceptable losses to their profits.
nitrogen 6y ago
Is a federally owned corporation (Tennessee Valley Authority) still considered an "arm" of the government?

Why is that worth noting? I feel like you're being intentionally ambiguous by leaving unstated implications. Do you believe public operation had an impact on safety? Better or worse, and based on what evidence? If neither, how is your statement relevant to the discussion?

Aerroon 6y ago
I don't know why the parent poster brought it up, but it does seem relevant to me. The government isn't going after quick profits, so you can't blame it on that. You might be able to blame profits if it had been a private corporation though.
- skissane 6y ago
  The public and private sectors are, in principle, equally capable of incompetence; the causes tend to be somewhat different, but the outcome can be the same.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y ago
  Profits play a massive factor in why governments tend to be incompetent. What do you think taxes are? They're a wealth transfer without option from everyone else to those in the employ of government. A whole bunch of people are profit from government expenditure, we even have a word for a special type of fraud about government expenditure: pork barelling: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pork_barrel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pork_barrel But, government run operations tend he notorious for incompetence for a few reasons, others have done a better job of detailing: https://www.bing.com/search?q=why+governments+are+notorious+for+incompetence&form=APIPH1&PC=APPL https://www.bing.com/search?q=why+governments+are+notorious+...

ineedasername 6y ago

That is only worth noting if you bring it along with a more detailed account of accident rates by government-owned facilities as compared to privately owned facilities. Until then it's just an anecdotal bit of snark that serves a political world view without the evidence necessary to evaluate it.

kingaillas 6y ago

In 2013, an ammonium nitrate storage facility exploded (1). In 2014, a leaky storage container poisoned a river in West Virginia (2). It's instructive to consider some thought experiments/scenarios: What if... a) Both were run by the government. In this case you'd have people of certain political parties screaming about government incompetence, and how the best solution would be to eliminate regulations and privatize, since competition somehow guarantees better results. b) Foreigners deliberately engineered both situations, an act of terrorism. In which case as certain administrations after 9/11, the US might pick some country that didn't have anything to do with it and go to war. c) Private companies were responsible. This is actually the case and the collective attitude was generally "eh, shit happens, private companies just trying to run a business". Just declare bankruptcy and walk. No real changes made in either case. 1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/West_Fertilizer_Company_explosion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/West_Fertilizer_Company_explos... 2 -

mixedCase 6y ago
Your biases are showing. Issues in private businesses drives regulation all the time around the world.
- r00fus 6y ago
  Not in the US. They pony up, hire lobbyists and get off scot free or with acceptable losses to their profits.

nitrogen 6y ago

Is a federally owned corporation (Tennessee Valley Authority) still considered an "arm" of the government?