3 ms·
> Only if we did it stupidly. Only if we did it with a weak government. We have an extremely right-wing military (except at the absolute top) and a completely
by pessimizer 6y ago
> Only if we did it stupidly.
Only if we did it with a weak government. We have an extremely right-wing military (except at the absolute top) and a completely right-wing police force. Without a mass movement, a weak left government is defenseless.
> We already have an American ISIL (a militant, fundamentalist, theocratic politico-religious group), and their allies in the formal political system already run the federal executive branch, dominate the federal judiciary, and control one of two houses of the federal legislature.
Call me when after they start beheading people in the street and taking over neighborhoods with armed street militias. We honestly have to make sure that our rhetoric resembles reality at least vaguely. Pretending like a Republican party that is doing the same thing it did under Nixon or Reagan is basically ISIL just makes people stop listening.
We're watching armed rightist incursions into cities right now, ones that are officially becoming armed skirmishes with the police openly suppporting the invaders (and it's mutual.) Imagine what would happen if we laid off half the police force? It doesn't matter whether it's right or not; of course it's right. What matters is that a bunch of unemployed angry right-wingers with no productive skills and murder training will see the government and the people who voted for it as enemies.
Like what woke liberals are literally doing right now, but without the middle-class liberal arts education and heavily armed. Having the Warren Court during a critical period of civil rights struggle has given liberals a tendency to magical thinking - like Q-followers, we're always waiting for the wise executive to move society forward by fiat. When we're at the point where we're expecting the CIA and FBI to take its place and reign in the elected president, we have to accept this strategy is not effective. We have to build power through having specific values and policies, like the right. You can't just tell an armed bully to stop being a bully because you've been elected the representative of the people he bullies. He doesn't have to do what you say.
edit:
> Insofar as a failed political demobilization relates to them, it was the demobilization after the Civil War (which the battle flag of the losing side of that conflict remains one of their key symbols.)
This is what happened after the civil war https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_racial_violence_in_the_United_States#Post%E2%80%93Civil_War_and_Reconstruction_period:_1865%E2%80%931877 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_racial_violence_in_the_Un...
American ISIL.
And to celebrate the victory, statues of Confederate soldiers were erected all over the country. During that time a single-issue antislavery party that had defended the Union in a civil war over slavery (the Republicans) decided to virtually merge with the Democrats on racist policy. Those battle flags flew throughout the lands of a supposedly defeated enemy for at least the next century and a half.