5 ms·
That’s great, anti-nuclear energy was definitely one of the anti-science stances standing in the way of progress.
by mensetmanusman 6y ago
That’s great, anti-nuclear energy was definitely one of the anti-science stances standing in the way of progress.
- pradn 6y agoI think many oppose nuclear power because for the same cost, you can build a lot of wind, solar, and hydro instead. I don't know if efficiencies have caught up and all. There's less of a catastrophic risk with these compared to nuclear, at least in people's imaginations. (Hydro dams have been broken in the past though and lead to many deaths.)
- p_l 6y agoExcept that solar or wind power plant will require significant backing from other power sources (hydroelectric outside of microscale is dead due to environmental concerns and costs), usually gas and coal. Energy storage is still very expensive in large scale except for pumped hydro storage, which again, is very problematic to arrange.
- ip26 6y agoWind blows around the clock and solar runs most of the time we are awake. If renewables are super cheap but storage is not viable, can't we simply overbuild?
- erik_seaberg 6y agoSolar drops hours before daily air conditioning demand, but wind might do it. I always thought wind depended heavily on the solar cycle, but apparently Europe found it dips 20% or less at night.
- ip26 6y agoSolar is still delivering 50% of peak as late as 5pm, and peak air conditioning is between 3-7pm. It's not a perfect fit, but mix in some time of use rates and (as previously mentioned) wind and it seems like you could do it. In buildings with decent insulation, cooling load is not hard to time shift.
- bigdubs 6y agoAlso batteries are critical for Solar to be viable generally anyway, but not ideal for sustainability.
- xlc0212 6y agoNo. It cost money and land (environment) to build them.
- p_l 6y agoWind is not as predictable as it seems, and most importantly, you don't get to control the production except for clamping down when you overproduce (this results in negative prices on the market and such). Then you have to add transfer issues, and you have situations where North Germany is exporting, while south Germany is importing, and there's a lot of fossil fuels burned just so you have capacity to keep the grid in shape. There are of course alternatives, like controlling demand via methods such as informing people they have to reduce power usage ASAP or get cut off (hope you didn't just start washing machine or put food into electric cooker)
- ip26 6y agoIn my ideal future, demand doesn't need to be controlled that forcefully. Tank water heaters, electric cars, air conditioning, furnace fans, and dryers can all be networked and choose to operate when power is cheap. They can soak up spikes in production and back off in troughs. These things are also the vast majority of residential power (the only other heavy hitter is cooking) Improved distance transmission would definitely be a big help.
- ie7eyrdueu 6y agoAll of those things disrupt a much larger swathe of land than a nuclear plant though. Environmental impact is more than "does it explode?" it's also things like ecological impact. Hyrdoelectric dams are incredibly disruptive to their environment and wind/solar take up at least 300x the space of a nuclear plant depending on which of the two you're talking about.
- formercoder 6y agoYep, if you want California-style rolling blackouts.
- osn9363739 6y agoExcept those have been happening longer than renewables have been a meaningful provider of energy.
- cure 6y agoIt's odd to me that anti-nuclear is being labelled anti-science. It's almost like the pro-nuclear people have blinders on. Nuclear is fantastic, in theory. In practice, in the real world, the consequences of accidents are extraordinarily bad and costly. The odds of a bad accident may be very small, but they are not zero (cf. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_and_radiation_accidents_and_incidents https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_and_radiation_accident...). And dealing with the waste is another highly risky and unsolved problem. I will be happily become pro-nuclear the moment that all the real-world externalities are actually priced in. How much do you think it cost to have 1,000 square miles in the Ukraine uninhabitable for the next 20,000 years? What if such an accident happens in a densely populated area? How much do you think it will cost to keep all that nuclear waste safe for the next half a million years or so? Plutonium-239's half-life is 24,000 years, and isotopes are dangerous for 10 to 20 times their half-life (cf https://www.livescience.com/33127-plutonium-more-dangerous-uranium.html https://www.livescience.com/33127-plutonium-more-dangerous-u...). The same problem of externalities exists for fossil fuels, of course. And even for hydro power in a different way: it has displaced millions of people and flooded many beautiful places.
- burfog 6y agoPlutonium-239 is not waste. It is fuel. Use it. The longer the half-life, the less we care. Bismuth and tungsten are radioactive, with half-lives longer than the age of the universe, but they aren't going to hurt anybody.
- chiefalchemist 6y ago> The odds of a bad accident may be very small but they are not zero re: Very small We've had nuclear power less than a century and we've had more than one significant event, and even more near events. But its not simply the odds, but the impact. We have yet to see a worst case scenario. How much longer can that last?
- Lazare 6y ago> In practice, in the real world, the consequences of accidents are extraordinarily bad and costly. ...not really. Fossil fuels kill a simply enormous amount of people. Coal is responsible for something like 13k deaths per year in the US alone; air pollution (from burning fossil fuels) kills something like 10k people per day. > How much do you think it cost to have 1,000 square miles in the Ukraine uninhabitable for the next 20,000 years? A number so low it rounds to zero in this context? > The same problem of externalities exists for fossil fuels, of course. I don't think you can handwave that away as an "of course". The externalities around fossil fuels are simply enormous; the issues and costs and risks of nuclear are multiple orders of magnitude less.
- legulere 6y agoJust because you need a bit of science to understand nuclear power plants doesn’t mean that it makes sense to build new nuclear plants. New nuclear is simply too expensive, with high construction costs in the west.