3 ms·
This will be fascinating as every country tries to have their own system. If humans were rational creatures, we would build and maintain one system to stop rein
by mensetmanusman 6y ago
This will be fascinating as every country tries to have their own system. If humans were rational creatures, we would build and maintain one system to stop reinventing the wheel and preventing kessler syndrome.
- pharke 6y agoWe are rational creatures but we have imperfect knowledge. It's in our nature to advance through search and competition rather than attempt to preplan everything.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoBut we do occasionally stop competing when we know it harms our own chance of survival, e.g. nuclear testing. I wonder if filling the skies with over 1-10 million satellites will pose similar types of self-reflection, or if the risk is too low for anyone to care that much.
- pharke 6y agoThe problem with a reactionary halt in some area due to a perceived sense of danger is that we often go too far. The campaign against nuclear arms also leaked out into a campaign against all things nuclear. We're only now starting to restore some sanity to the discussion and begin tentative funding of promising technologies in that industry. If you look at the broad history of nuclear power you'll realize that we are far behind where we should be. Power plant design hasn't changed in decades and nuclear power generation is nowhere near as widespread as it should be. Given that the largest contributors to CO2 emissions are electrical power generation and industry you could even make a case that the anti-nuclear movement of the 1960s, which resulted in the drying up of funding and academic interest in nuclear science as well as rampant NIMBYism and political opposition to nuclear reactors, is the reason we are now suffering from the effects of excessive CO2 in the atmosphere. Ironic.
- rossdavidh 6y agoIf we "build and maintain one system", we are maximizing our chance of accidentally having zero working systems.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoBy one system, I mean one with all the redundancies that such a system serving all of man kind would have, assuming man could actually work together across cultures, etc.
- pengaru 6y agoI can't see how creating a global communications monopoly could be seen as rational from the perspective of the masses.
- xudyeuwisd 6y agoIt's because humans are rationale that they don't do this. There's very real advantages to operating the system and not being beholden to what a committee of nations wants, especially if you're a large economy that would be contributing vastly more than the smaller nations anyway.