3 ms·
There's a couple of misleading statements in here. It's true that CDF firefighters make a decent living, but it's also true that every other fire department pay
by jeffbee 6y ago
There's a couple of misleading statements in here. It's true that CDF firefighters make a decent living, but it's also true that every other fire department pays better. They'd all take a position in a city fire department if they were after more money.
The other misleading thing is associating these current fires with bad forest management practices. It's true for Sierra Nevada forests generally, but that's not where these fires are. The Big Basin area near Santa Cruz isn't supposed to regularly burn. Historically it goes through intense fires rarely. "Preventing megafires" isn't what that coastal redwood forest wants. The other big fire in the San Antonio Valley and Del Puerto Canyon is virtually all privately-held land. There doesn't seem to be a mechanism for the state to require a prescribed burn through private lands, like you might do in a national forest or BLM holding.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> It's true that CDF firefighters make a decent living, but it's also true that every other fire department pays better. Except CDCR, which pays notably worse, but that's not really competing for firefighters. > There doesn't seem to be a mechanism for the state to require a prescribed burn through private lands, like you might do in a national forest or BLM holding. There's not mechanism for the state to require a prescribed burn on national forest or BLM land, either (both of which are federally managed.)
- samcheng 6y agoTo save some people a search: CDF = California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection, also known as "CALFIRE" CDCR = California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, which in this context supplies convict labor to fight fires. One issue this year is that the California State Prisons are all horrifically overrun with COVID-19, thereby incapacitating what had previously been a critical firefighting function. The situation (mass incarceration, crowded conditions, negligent and/or derisive healthcare for inmates, climate change, lack of prescribed burns, and now inadequate resources to fight large fires) is really quite depressing to untangle.
- mschuster91 6y agoIdeally, the state should not require (it is what it is) slave labor to fulfill basic needs of society. Yes I know in theory it is voluntary and everything, but it is wage dumping using forced labor - because without said slave labor the state would have to pay a lot more for a real standing force. As with most cost cutting measures, eventually the chickens will come home to roost, and there has been quite a horde of chickens that came home over the last months, across the world.
- me_againnnnnn 6y agoFor example,90+% of the deaths from covid 19 in Sonoma county are from crowded, underfunded nursing homes. A problem that has been completely ignored for so many years. All the rules they made to fight the problem and none of them are actually changing the original problem.
- mandelbrotwurst 6y ago"the state" is often used as a general term for the government and not necessarily the government of a specific area.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- njarboe 6y agoThe current biggest fires are not in the Sierra Nevada and the ones in the coastal range tend to burn more structures because there are more of them, but there are also many large fires in the Sierra Nevada at the moment. Check out this map[1] from Cal Fire. Almost no media coverage for the Sierra Nevada fires though.
- stickfigure 6y agoOne other thing I've recently learned is that outside of cities, fire departments are mostly volunteer. Here in the Vacaville Fire Protection District (most of northwest Solano county, which burned heavily in the LNU complex) the department is 90% volunteers. And that's fairly typical. (I recently applied)
- Marsymars 6y agoHah, growing up in a rural area, I assumed that fire departments were volunteer-based everywhere, and didn't discover otherwise until I moved to a large city.
- theptip 6y ago> The Big Basin area near Santa Cruz isn't supposed to regularly burn. Do you have any sources you can share for further reading on this? I did a little bit of digging and found https://www.nps.gov/pore/learn/management/firemanagement_fireecology_vegtypes_redwoods.htm https://www.nps.gov/pore/learn/management/firemanagement_fir..., but couldn’t come up with anything for Big Basin specifically. The closest I found was: > Fire return intervals range from as long as 500 years on wetter, northern sites to 5–25 years on drier, southern sites. Point Reyes NS falls closer to the shorter end of the fire return interval spectrum. Researchers report a fire return interval of 7.7 years for redwood stands at Point Reyes. A study of redwood stands on Bolinas Ridge and Mount Tamalpais found point estimates of fire return interval ranging from 21.7 to 27.3 years. Regardless of what the natural fire frequency was in the past, isn’t this an empirical question about unburnt fuel levels and other environmental factors listed in the article? If we have a large surplus of fuel building up in these forests, and more controlled burns would manage it, that seems like a management problem even if frequent burns were not part of the historical norm.