4 ms·
I agree with most of the post but I don't think academia is generally obsessed with originality. A lot of academic work is explicitly incremental by nature, whi
by Barrin92 6y ago
I agree with most of the post but I don't think academia is generally obsessed with originality. A lot of academic work is explicitly incremental by nature, which is determined by the methodology of academic work, which aims to satisfy formalisms and to be reproducible (at least ideally). One just needs to look at the turmoil that the proof of the abc-conjecture caused in maths.
I associate forced originality more with Silicon Valley startup culture, which used to look down on places like China not too long ago for copying on every opportunity it got, and there was probably one blogpost per week complaining about rote memorisation in education and deschooling their kids coming out of that culture.
- LeegleechN 6y agoAcademia is obsessed with "novelty" which is a weaker form of originality. Very frequently there are ideas which are an obvious next step to everyone in the field, but the first person to actually implement and publish it is the one who will get the credit / future citations. I wouldn't consider those kinds of ideas original because many people already independently conceived them and are working on implementing them, but they are novel in that they haven't been instantiated before.