4 ms·
> Nobody claimed that they'd buy slaves and made them do hard labor in the plantations for the slaves' benefits. They really did, I literally learned that from
by watwut 6y ago
> Nobody claimed that they'd buy slaves and made them do hard labor in the plantations for the slaves' benefits.
They really did, I literally learned that from history books. I just googled "civilizing aspects of slavery" and found this https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/27530631.pdf https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/27530631.pdf But really, any detailed book on American slavery will have those arguments in it.
I think that one massive thing to learn from history is that it is not really new to frame oppression as guardianship.
> That's not what I said. The legal relationship is close to that of custody/guardianship, not the emotional one.
It is really not. As I told, the jail and torture if she crosses the line makes the difference. It is even less guardianship then slavery - the guardianship framing makes it sound nicer and more palatable then what it really is. The protection thing is not going on, the ownership thing is going on.
> Saudi Arabia does have slaves, actual real slaves. But they're not Saudi women (they're often women, but they're from e.g. Malaysia or the Philippines and are forced to serve these Saudi women you call slaves). If you call the Saudi women slaves, what word would you use for their slaves?
You do here exactly the slavery as metaphor thing too. They actually dont have actual slaves per law, that was abolished long time ago. The abused domestic workers are formally not slaves and are not traded in slave market either. Their children are not sold as slaves either.
Btw, slaves did oversees other slaves. Roman slaves could become valued friends of household owner - while still being at his mercy. That would not be possible in American chattel slavery.
- luckylion 6y agoRetroactive "slavery wasn't all bad, look" explanations aren't changing the idea and intent of slavery. > The abused domestic workers are formally not slaves and are not traded in slave market either. They literally are, and when they bring them outside of Saudi Arabia, it's not rare for Saudis to be convicted of human trafficking and enslavement - if it becomes known to authorities. The Saudi state regularly posts bail in these cases. > Btw, slaves did oversees other slaves. Yes, but they didn't have slaves. It's the difference between being the shift foreman in a factory and owning the factory.