3 ms·
eHang is further along. [1] 16 rotors. Battery energy density seems to be the big remaining problem. Flight times are too short. [1] https://youtu.be/T_mezyLh
by Animats 6y ago
eHang is further along. [1] 16 rotors.
Battery energy density seems to be the big remaining problem. Flight times are too short.
[1] https://youtu.be/T_mezyLhvlA https://youtu.be/T_mezyLhvlA
- CydeWeys 6y agoWow, those are gonna turn someone into ground meat at some point. I'm not sure that having that many propellers at knee and waist level is a good idea. These seem like less safe helicopters?
- Animats 6y agoThat's a problem. You don't want anyone anywhere near those things on takeoff and landing. Which is a problem if they use them for package delivery. However, the eHang really does fly, it really does carry people, and it works well enough they sent a reporter for the SCMP up in it. Closest thing to a flying car so far.
- CydeWeys 6y agoThis design is basically not safe to use except on controlled access helipads; landing elsewhere is eventually going to turn someone into hamburger meat. It's really not any different from a small helicopter, which have existed for decades. How is this any closer to a flying car? The key aspect of a flying car is that it's safe to drive around on roads and fly around in the air. This thing can't do roads at all, not the driving nor even safely taking off or landing on them.
- 7952 6y agoThe rear rotor of a helicopter will occasionally do that also. Although it could be better with a craft that can easily turn on and off in an instant. A helicopter is often accessed by humans when powered up
- CydeWeys 6y agoThe difference with the helicopter is that you can approach it safely from almost any angle to board/deboard, just don't approach from the tail, whereas this flying car thing has a ring of death all the way around the outside. And having the option of leaving the thing running has some advantages too. I'm just not buying that this design solves any problems. At most it miiiight be a cheaper helicopter, but right now, it looks substantially less capable than helicopters too, and it seems like its failure mode is worse (helicopters can survivably land through autorotation even with a full loss of power; N-copters can't). So I'm not really seeing the benefits of this design.
- supernova87a 6y agoA question I've always had is, how is the decision on how many propellers made? Why 16, and not 4? Or why 1?
- Animats 6y agoThe drone-type designs cannot autorotate like a helicopter. They don't have the variable-pitch blade controls a helicopter does. If you lose an engine or prop, you crash uncontrollably unless you have some spare props.
- supernova87a 6y agoAh, I see -- so the 4 prop one in the OP article... that is basically a death trap at some point?
- hengheng 6y agoIt's 8 (two stacked along the same axis in each corner), so there will be some kind of redundancy.
- 7952 6y agoI am not sure about this in particular. But in general for redundancy to work you need the remaining equipment to be able to support the craft fully. There needs to be enough spare power. And the remaining thrust must be central enough to avoid loss of control. This doesn't work well with even numbers like 2x or 4x. Also, adding additional rotors/engines could increase the chance of a failure in a particular flight as you have more things that can go wrong. A 2 rotor helicopter is definately not safer than a single bladed one.