6 ms·
> 1. Mandate that every mass produced device with a li-ion battery have a simple mechanism to remove the battery Apple has argued that they can fit a bigger, h
by dehrmann 6y ago
> 1. Mandate that every mass produced device with a li-ion battery have a simple mechanism to remove the battery
Apple has argued that they can fit a bigger, harder to remove battery into devices, and the added capacity because it's bigger makes up for it being hard to remove. I've changed batteries on a Thinkpad X1 Carbon, and it's very straightforward; I'm not sure how much truth there isn't to that argument on laptops. Phones are so small that I find that explanation more plausible.
- shajznnckfke 6y agoMaybe Apple could be given a choice here: user-replaceable battery with a refundable core charge, or they have to build a battery recycling program with the same sort of core charge applied at purchase. The core charge would be returned if the user sells the phone to any legit business (funded by the core charge originally paid to Apple). If the user sells the phone on eBay, the buyer can recover the core charge later, so it’s part of the market value of any phone that has a battery in it. The charge also could be recovered if the phone is given to a recycling center. It’s on Apple to figure out how to get the batteries out and pay whoever does that work. Apple can decide whether to do the engineering to make the battery replaceable up front, or fund the delicate labor of taking apart the phone later.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> or they have to build a battery recycling program with the same sort of core charge applied at purchase They will already recycle your battery for free. I think they will actually also recycle other manufacturers' batteries for free as well, and also any random loose batteries you hand them. Seems pretty reasonable to me?
- shajznnckfke 6y agoI think the missing piece here is the core charge, which makes the average user think of the battery as something of value that shouldn’t just be thrown in the trash. Currently, I think a lot of users with an obsolete phone with a smashed screen would just throw it in the garbage.
- totalZero 6y agoIt's not the core charge that makes you return a battery -- it's the core refund.
- shajznnckfke 6y agoAgreed. The point of the core charge is to make the program more palatable to manufacturers. They’d rather the customer see the charge as a line item than rise their prices to fund it. I think the line item also helps educate the customer at purchase time that the refund exists.
- no_wizard 6y agoThe sad reality with phones is whatever Apple doss most if not all other manufacturers follow one way or another. Samsung used to allow you to remove your battery easily but they also stopped at least in their flagship phone, last time I looked at one anyway. I know they also offer phones that do allow for this but the flagship phones really set the tone I feel for the downstream expectations over time. Rather unfortunately I don’t think Apple sees value in removable batteries, which while I understand the trade offs I think is a net negative in this case
- macromagnon 6y agoApple doesn't want you to easily extend the life of older models; they want you to buy the new one.
- QuixoticQuibit 6y agoAnd yet they have the longest software support for smartphones in the industry by a large margin. Plus they offer consumers the ability to replace the battery for a fee.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> And yet they have the longest software support for smartphones in the industry by a large margin. No, that would be the various libre phones that have in-tree kernel drivers and correspondingly support updates to the latest system indefinitely. The default in the industry prior to Apple was for software to be independent from hardware. You can install the latest Windows on hardware going back to the earliest x64 processors and Linux or BSD on hardware going back more than 20 years. If random community-supported Linux distributions can support hardware from the previous millennium, Apple could support all the iPhone hardware ever made, but they don't. So that's just another instance of them doing something user-hostile so you have to buy a newer iPhone and Samsung et al following them. Offering battery replacements in that context is just another way for them to stick it to you -- you have a four year old iPhone with a flat battery, they take your money to put in a new one and then stop issuing it software updates a year later so you have to buy a new one regardless.
- wongarsu 6y agoOn my Dell XPS replacing the battery also only involves unscrewing a few screws and unplugging one connector, then putting that back together with the new battery. It couldn't be simpler, and that's in the space constraints of an ultrabook. On phones there's a better case for fixed batteries, but at least I don't mind another millimeter thickness if that means I can replace the battery.
- sushshshsh 6y agoI miss the good ol days when my T410 just simply unclipped. Completely modular, no screwdriver required, almost like battery replacement was a feature!
- eropple 6y agoFor a while, up until the T480, you had both an external and the internal battery. So if you had a few batteries it was pretty trivial to swap them while on the go--and sometimes you really do need 18 hours of battery life on a laptop, even if you aren't pleased about it.
- sudosysgen 6y agoAll Apple would have to do is to have the back cover use screws instead of adhesives, using up about one tenth of a cc more volume, and use a more malleable adhesive for the battery (or none at all). It would take at most two more tenths of a cubic centimeter more volume.
- roenxi 6y ago> All Apple would have to do... This is hardware engineering, and high quality engineering at that. When Apple decided to use an adhesive rather than screws they could would have had excellent consideration of cost/quality/aesthetic issues. It is true that they could easily create devices to match the requirements of randoms on Hacker News, but that isn't going to lead to Apple - the once in a decade consumer products behemoth. It leads to the Openmoko. Turns out nearly nobody wants that. So yeah, it is an "All Apple would have to do", but evidence is Apple is much better at deciding what it should and shouldn't do than back-seat designers. Sorry if that sounds a bit brusque, a nerve might have been hit here. But hardware isn't easy.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> It is true that they could easily create devices to match the requirements of randoms on Hacker News, but that isn't going to lead to Apple - the once in a decade consumer products behemoth. It leads to the Openmoko. Turns out nearly nobody wants that. This fallacy seems to be common in discussions of Apple. Apple is very profitable, therefore everything they do is infallible and impossible to improve. Look at a picture of an Openmoko device. Just look at it. Here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Openmoko https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Openmoko Compare this to various modern phones with a replaceable battery: https://www.androidauthority.com/best-android-phones-removable-battery-697520/ https://www.androidauthority.com/best-android-phones-removab... There are obvious reasons to expect the former to fail in the market but not the latter, even though they all have a replaceable battery. Meanwhile the Apple devices further run iOS and are compatible with iMessage and the complete set of third party iOS apps, which are a large component of their success, but none of which would be any less true if they had a replaceable battery. Doing a lot of things right can't prove that they're not doing a specific thing wrong.
- hyperpallium2 6y agoProbably similar story to them slowing down old iPhones: there's a legimate and an illegimate motivation. But honesty had to to be forced out of them.