4 ms·
Just this week a woman who's spoken in favor of a man controlling his wife's vote was featured at the RNC. In my family, three of my female cousins were forbid
by klyrs 6y ago
Just this week a woman who's spoken in favor of a man controlling his wife's vote was featured at the RNC. In my family, three of my female cousins were forbidden by their husbands from voting, employment, opening bank accounts or holding credit cards, and learning how to drive. They were evangelical Christians. Two have since stood up for themselves and divorced their husbands, one persists and still considers her obeisance a duty to god. I really don't understand why you're getting downvoted, Doreen.
- sukilot 6y agoBecause those women haven't been arrested by the police and put to death by the state. They are free to move away, get almost any job man can, and remarry. If a husband tries to prevent her from that, she can get aid from friends and the state to resist. Are 1 and 100 both numbers? Test. But they aren't close.
- oh_sigh 6y agoDo you think the people you're describing represent any kind of norm?
- klyrs 6y agoIn the evangelical Christian community, yes, this is seen as normal. My cousins' husbands had their pastor's support and encouragement in this shit. The sect is pretty popular in the US, and makes up a sizeable chunk of Trump's base.
- oh_sigh 6y agoI grew up adjacent to super evangelicals and never heard of anything like this. Yes, there was a ton of pushing for traditional gender roles. And really, that's up to the women to decide if that's how they want to live their life. Clearly they shouldn't be forced into it but if they willingly choose it, then :shrug:? I don't believe in the Amish lifestyle, but so long as there is an actual escape path and they aren't being held against their will, I don't really see a problem with it. Some people want to live their life subordinate to others. I don't see the allure but some do. The key difference here is that if an evangelical wife doesn't like her husband's views on life, she can just go to the court house and divorce him and move wherever the heck she wants, and do whatever she wants to do. I don't think that same freedom exists in Saudi Arabia.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoI really don't understand why you're getting downvoted, Doreen. I am getting downvotes because anytime a woman tells Western men they don't treat their women as wonderfully as they like to imagine, they kick the living crap out of her and let her know she needs to SFTU because women have it so very good here. It's par for the course.
- pcf 6y agoWestern men "kick the living crap out of" women who speak their mind like that? And tell her "to STFU"? I think you're confusing the West with countries like Saudi Arabia.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoMmm, hmmm. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24317792 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24317792
- luckylion 6y agoYou are mixing up traditions that are optional, voluntary and more role play than anything else (as if it was common that a Western man in a Western country would ask the father of the bride to be instead of her; it's, for some people, a formality after the couple has decided to get married, and everybody plays their part) with state law with heavy punishment. Similarly: it's tradition to say "until death do us part" in marriage vows, but essentially nobody means it, divorce is common. "There are crazy drops in a sea of sane people" != "There's a sea of crazy people, but I've seen a sane drop or two".
- DoreenMichele 6y agoI'm really not mixing up anything. Please, kindly, don't tell me I simply have muddled thinking and no real validity to my point of view. I appear to be the only woman to have ever spent time on the leaderboard of HN. I spent nearly six years homeless while a member here. I remain dirt poor. Meanwhile, some of the men on the leaderboard are millionaires who made their millions in part by networking via HN. The figures for women in leadership positions at Fortune 500 companies is something like 6 percent female CEOs and 17 percent overall. There appears to be one and only one woman on HN to have ever graced the leaderboard, a list of 100 names that has changed over time. So my brief appearance there puts me in a league of my own and well under one percent of those names is someone who posts as openly female. Yet all most men here want to know if they email me is if I will sleep with them. So HN has been a huge networking fail for me and I remain dirt poor. Since that poverty means I can't afford to eat today, I'm a hair crankier than usual about the whole thing. Sexism is alive and well in the West and the gains we've made fall very far short of anything resembling equality. I think I'm done here for now. My story is not remotely a secret. It's galling how I get treated here and then told to quit my whining about my poverty. In discussions of gender equality, so it's on topic. It's just not welcome and this is a silencing tactic that helps ensure I can never get any kind of remedy.
- watwut 6y agoThe option of divorce makes massive difference here. In subculture of conservative christians, yes,helpmeet theory make women very subservient. But this christianity is not forced by law and leaving the group is legally and practically possible. Moreover, these groups represent significant minority of populace.
- klyrs 6y ago> But this christianity is not forced by law and leaving the group is legally and practically possible. Reproductive choice is a glaring counterexample to this. Even women's employers get a say, there.
- luckylion 6y ago> Even women's employers get a say, there. No, they don't. They can neither force nor stop a woman from getting pregnant. "But she might not get the CEO job when she's having young children" isn't "giving them a say".
- watwut 6y agoI think the comment you responded to was about employers ability to determine whether abortion and possibly contraceptives are paid from health insurance.
- luckylion 6y agoThat's possible. I wouldn't say that the employer has a say in whether you get surgery or not based on whether they provide health insurance. If they don't provide company housing, they don't provide company housing, but they don't get to decide whether you get to live in a house or not. "They get a say" = they are involved in the decision. They aren't though. They might not be forced to pay for what an employee decides, but they aren't making the decision. If them not paying means they make the decision, then the government is deciding whether people get to fly to the moon. That's technically correct under those premises, but I believe we agree that it's a silly statement.