4 ms·
That's not as radically different from Western culture as Western culture likes to pretend it is. We have traditions like a man asking her father for her hand
by DoreenMichele 6y ago
That's not as radically different from Western culture as Western culture likes to pretend it is.
We have traditions like a man asking her father for her hand in marriage. We change her last name to signify she has transferred identity from her father's clan to her husband's. We treat marriage as very much a financial contract and divorce tends to hurt women financially much more than it does men.
Etc.
- bitexploder 6y agoAnecdotally this is just wrong. My wife’s Dad was a real piece of work. In a country like SA she would never have gotten away from him. She met me online. The day after she graduated college, without ever discussing it with her father, she moved away with me across the country. Her choice. She decided to take my last name, for simplicities sake, but it was a rational choice we made. Every step of the way it was her choice. Amongst my peer group almost all married women are in a similar situation. The level of freedom is orders of magnitude difference IMO.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoI chose to take my husband's name and kept it when I divorced him. But the tradition is rooted in that idea that she left her clan and joined his. That's the origin story for it. I don't have a simple solution for that one. I don't think it's inherently bad that women typically change their last name. But the reason it is done is because the way women get treated the world over has some things in common. The level of freedom is debatable for Western women. But I already said Westerners don't like to hear that and it got downvoted and dismissed out of hand. So I'm not really up for trying to argue it, given the climate.
- watwut 6y agoI think that you are underestimating level of control that exists in the countries we originally talked about. Comparing women being imprisoned and tortured right now because they did not followed the rules to name changed in western countries smells bad faith, honestly. Hence, some of downvotes.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoYou never speak to me except to attack me, speaking of bad faith. So maybe just leave me alone. The men here are brutal enough without women here "eating their own."
- watwut 6y agoDisagreeing with you or telling how it looks like when you commented on downvotes is not "eating their own". I do tend to comment more when I disagree which is fairly normal here and pretty much everywhere.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoWomen are so often collectively their own worst enemy. Yes, your overall pattern of behavior boils down to "women eating their own." I have damn little support here from the men. Most women that I can readily ID as female are openly antagonistic, as if they are jealous of my status, which is a typical female social dynamic. I've studied this stuff in depth. I discuss it regularly with my sons who are also quite knowledgeable. The best way to destroy someone is to do it politely and all this shit, completely within the fucking rules so it looks like they are entirely in the wrong. This gets done daily around the world to women and other marginalized peoples. And having not eaten and yadda today because eleven years here and being the top ranked woman isn't sufficient to get me connections adequate to establish a middle class income, I'm a tad frayed around the edges. So I'm having a little trouble politely going along with this BS today.
- watwut 6y agoThis is hard no from me. I dont have to team up with you just because we have same gender. There is no corresponding expectation on men to agree with each other either. They are free to be individuals. Also, I dont know why you think I should consider you higher status or even be aware of your nick when i am responding. In that, you are literally trying to use sexist stereotype to make me do what you want. The sexist stereotype that invalidates what i wrote and my opinions, using imaginary status instead. That is tripple hard no for me, I refuse to play this game.
- brabel 6y agoMy wife decided not to take my name, and I was cool with that (there were very practical reasons to avoid a name change). I have a male friend who took his wife's last name, actually (his reason was that his surname is basically the most common in the country, which made his full name highly non-unique)! I never understood why modern women still tend to change their name. It's definitely not something anyone expects, in my experience at least.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoI never understood why modern women still tend to change their name. It's definitely not something anyone expects, in my experience at least. I took my husband's name largely because it was a cheap, easy and very private means to stop having the same last name as someone who molested and raped me. I kept my married name when I divorced on the socially acceptable reason that it's the same name as my children. It's a valid reason, but the firmer reason was that my ex's last name is less objectionable than my rapist's last name as a moniker for myself. Should I ever remarry, I am highly likely to again take my new husband's last name to try one last time to wash off the shit of my past. Child molestation or other abuse by relatives is sadly all too common. I doubt anyone has formally studied it, but I would be shocked if it turned out I was the only woman who chose to change my last name for that kind of reason. If we want real equality, we will also need to stamp out the gendered trends in sexual assault. It is typically a male assaulting a female and this can have lifelong negative impact when she is assaulted at a young age.
- saagarjha 6y agoIt’s awful that this happened to you, and I appreciate you providing your insight as to why you personally decided to go through with it. However, I’m still curious why most other women do so–those who have no reason to separate themselves from their family.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoIt's socially acceptable. It's tradition/habit. It makes it easier to identify your new family unit of you, your spouse and children. If we start hyphenating all last names, it won't be too many generations before all have last names of three pages long. I don't know a nice, neat simple solution for this issue. There are some good points to "me, my spouse and kids all have a family name together and it's reasonably short." We also tend to trace inheritance via the father's family line. Some women trade their middle name for the maiden name and take their husband's last name as a solution, like Hillary Rodham Clinton. That seems to be a mostly upper class tradition for women with more of a public life where they have a real need to have some kind of continuity with their past identity in their own right. Trying to bring women out of the shadows of the very private lives as only full-time wives and moms and into the public sphere -- which is de facto the trend here as women live longer, have fewer kids and need to occupy themselves somehow other than just cooking and cleaning -- is complicated. When I don't completely hate my life and wish I had never been born, I occasionally think it's a great experiment in how to resolve some of these questions. There are no easy or simple answers for how to move an entire world rapidly and well from one system to another, which is more or less what the entire world is in the process of doing. How we used to handle it made logical sense for the social fabric of that era. And our social fabric is changing and what worked at one time is now seen as all wrong and bad and I worry that we are throwing the baby out of with the bathwater here. I guess literally, because trying to give women some kind of rights and just handing them a male model is clearly shafting mothers and children. And I think we need to do better than that. I think we urgently need to do better than that.
- bitexploder 6y agoI do agree women and men are far from equal in western society (America in particular), but it’s a strained comparison, which is where I think your downvotes came from. There are some parallels, but they are far apart.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoAn American friend of mine was living in the Middle East, I think married to a Middle Eastern man, and I think she had a baby. Some other woman at the hospital had triplets and everyone was gaga over the triplets. My American friend was uncomfortable with the situation and said something about it to someone to the effect that "It's cool now, but when she is home and caring for triplets alone, this will be a terrible burden." The person looked at her like she had completely lost her mind and told her "She is never going to have to care for triplets alone." I was a full-time wife and mom for a lot of years. I supported my husband's military career and raised and homeschooled our special-needs sons. And since the divorce, life has been extremely hard. My stats tend to be out of date, but I spent a lot of time reading a lot of stuff to try to sort out how and why my life went so very wrong. I was one of the top students in my graduating high school class and won a National Merit Scholarship, etc. The last time I looked at stats, women who were childless and unmarried made about 97 percent of what men made with similar education and experience. The minute she had either a husband or child, the average dropped to two-thirds what men make -- the same the Bible quotes a woman as making 2000 years ago. These are American stats and European women tend to fare somewhat better. It's also less bad these days, from what I gather, then it was 30 years ago. But I continue to be stymied in my efforts to establish an adequate income for myself and my sons. And I'm quite clear my gender is a very large part of that. I do not self-identify as a feminist. I was a homemaker for a lot of years and most self-proclaimed feminists I meet are openly hostile towards me, a la that scene in "Mona Lisa Smile." Women still are heavily burdened by the issue of childbearing and childrearing. And in the US you mostly have some kind of "equality" with men if you choose to not have children. And if you do have kids, your life can be completely flushed down the toilet over it and other people will shrug and say "Well, you shouldn't have had kids if you couldn't afford them." It's also not a policy that is sustainable. If we actively and successfully encourage all women to stop having kids, this is the last generation of humans. We have to find some means to give all people, regardless of gender or age, some kind of decent quality of life. We shaft far too many of our people and then wonder why there are headlines on Hacker News about the social fabric coming unraveled. They are only "far apart" if you have a narrow view of quality of life. I don't and my life experience tells me it is far more complex than most Westerners want to believe who like to claim we are the height of civilized achievement for all of human history and don't make us uncomfortable with niggling details about how mothers get shafted or something.
- dev_throw 6y ago"...and divorce tends to hurt women financially much more than it does men" Everything I read about this, including anecdotal evidence points to the opposite, where men are routinely taken to the cleaners by the family court. Could you point to some resources that suggest otherwise? I'm trying to see the full picture here.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoNo, I'm not going to bother. I appear to be the highest ranked woman on Hacker News. It has failed to get me significant career contacts or substantial income. I have not eaten today. I have 50 cents to my name. I was homeless for nearly six years. I am shitposting on HN because I am too hungry, tired and out of sorts to do anything better and I am sick to death of trying to point out the obvious to people who absolutely do not want to hear it. Anecdotally: I was a homemaker for years. I have six years of college and lots of evidence that I'm competent. I cannot turn it into a "career" or adequate income. My ex got to take his lovely resume and keep working and he bought a house and remarried and yadda. Because the years he spent working at his career while I cooked his meals and raised our kids is something he can bank on and I can't.
- dev_throw 6y agoSorry to hear about your situation, and thanks for taking my question in good faith. I see, basically a stay at home wife/mother is not adequately compensated for her time spent at home maintaining it and taking care of the children. In the west, this is still a choice though, right? These days I don't think anyone can "bank" on their spouse staying at home while they work. In those years, you had the choice of going to work. For better or worse (I personally think children need at least one parent in early development years), you stayed at home and took care of them.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoMy last serious boyfriend was Iranian. He treated me with more respect than any American man ever has and Farsi, like Japanese, only has a single gender-neutral pronoun. He had nasty, filthy sayings about sucking up to women in power equivalent to standard sayings I already knew for sucking up to men in power. I had never heard the equivalent in my life. Knowing him was a huge, huge personal growth experience and helped me figure out how to stand up for myself and insist men not shit all over me every single step of the way in life. Which is probably one of the reasons I appear to be the highest ranked woman on Hacker News. So I do have some insights into how women get treated in the Middle East. And before anyone jumps up to tell me my last boyfriend must have been some kind of statistical outlier, that's the same BS excuse people are making in this same discussion for American women who get treated like property in some parts of the US. It amounts to "La la la not listening. Don't confuse me with the facts." Certainly, there are differences. But as someone who is still suffering terribly the consequences of having been born female, I find it personally galling for people to act like I'm some kind of loon for pointing out the differences aren't as dramatic as we want to imagine.
- lowdose 6y agoCould you point out a single example in the Western world where a twelve year old girl is married to a 30 year old man because she had her first period? 720 million women living today married as children, many of them have had several children themselves with an immature body before they became adults. None of these women live in Western societies! https://www.girlsnotbrides.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/GNB-factsheet-on-child-marriage-numbers-Oct-2014.pdf https://www.girlsnotbrides.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/GN...
- klyrs 6y agoPolygamists in the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints have done this in recent years, in Canada and the US. Can't remember dude's name who married his 12 year-old step daughter, but they're out there. Yes, in "western society".
- pcf 6y agoSure, but extremely few of them. And more importantly, it's generally not socially accepted at all, compared to countries like Yemen and Turkey, where this harmful practice is quite normal.
- kgwgk 6y agoEven more importantly, that was a reply to a comment asking for "a single example in the Western world".
- lowdose 6y agoMaybe I should have asked for a single example in the West where sexual and mental child molesting is legal and/or is not actively criminally prosecuted. But at least it is very clear that we could only find a rare example against systematic rape of under aged girls in other societies. 15 million girls a year marry before the age of 18.
- 6y ago
- klyrs 6y agoJust this week a woman who's spoken in favor of a man controlling his wife's vote was featured at the RNC. In my family, three of my female cousins were forbidden by their husbands from voting, employment, opening bank accounts or holding credit cards, and learning how to drive. They were evangelical Christians. Two have since stood up for themselves and divorced their husbands, one persists and still considers her obeisance a duty to god. I really don't understand why you're getting downvoted, Doreen.
- sukilot 6y agoBecause those women haven't been arrested by the police and put to death by the state. They are free to move away, get almost any job man can, and remarry. If a husband tries to prevent her from that, she can get aid from friends and the state to resist. Are 1 and 100 both numbers? Test. But they aren't close.
- oh_sigh 6y agoDo you think the people you're describing represent any kind of norm?
- klyrs 6y agoIn the evangelical Christian community, yes, this is seen as normal. My cousins' husbands had their pastor's support and encouragement in this shit. The sect is pretty popular in the US, and makes up a sizeable chunk of Trump's base.
- oh_sigh 6y agoI grew up adjacent to super evangelicals and never heard of anything like this. Yes, there was a ton of pushing for traditional gender roles. And really, that's up to the women to decide if that's how they want to live their life. Clearly they shouldn't be forced into it but if they willingly choose it, then :shrug:? I don't believe in the Amish lifestyle, but so long as there is an actual escape path and they aren't being held against their will, I don't really see a problem with it. Some people want to live their life subordinate to others. I don't see the allure but some do. The key difference here is that if an evangelical wife doesn't like her husband's views on life, she can just go to the court house and divorce him and move wherever the heck she wants, and do whatever she wants to do. I don't think that same freedom exists in Saudi Arabia.
- oh_sigh 6y agoWell, this is a silly take. It's like saying getting a splinter and being impaled by a 2x4 aren't radically different.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoDeath by a thousand cuts instead of just one is still death. It is also torture instead of mere execution.
- oh_sigh 6y agoYes, that is definitely a saying. Not sure that it's appropriate here. If you think the plight of women in America is even remotely akin to the plight of women in SA, then I don't know what to say. There probably can't be a productive conversation if two people have such radically different understandings of reality.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoAnd, of course, naturally, your take trumps mine enough to make you comfortable simply dismissing mine out of hand. Upvotes for you and downvotes for me equals more social proof that obviously I'm a loon. Let's not let facts get in the way here.
- oh_sigh 6y agoDo you want me to just defer to random internet person's viewpoints instead of my own experience. Is that how you live your life? The facts of the matter are that empirically women in SA are not even on the same plane of existence as women in the US, regardless of the fact that true gender equality doesn't exactly exist in the US. Evidence of such is in the article for this HN post, which is "women are allowed to play video games now"
- DoreenMichele 6y agoDo you want me to just defer to random internet person's viewpoints instead of my own experience. Is that how you live your life? No, I want you to follow the guidelines for HN of being respectful. Or do you think that somehow doesn't apply to me for some reason?
- toyg 6y ago> We have traditions like a man asking her father for her hand in marriage. We change her last name "We" as in certain barbaric anglo countries ;) These things have long been abandoned in many (most?) other countries (Italy, France, etc). > We treat marriage as very much a financial contract Not really. Although community of wealth is the traditional European stance, in a lot of countries you can now keep things separate simply by ticking a box when registering the marriage. > divorce tends to hurt women financially much more than it does men That's a complicate issue, tied to the loss of income due to career interruption for pregnancy and child-rearing, as well as the fact that women simply earn less on average. But divorce is now basically a bureaucratic procedure pretty much anywhere in Western and Northern Europe, which can be accomplished without any assistance from the other side. Obviously old traditions are not that different - we all come from rural societies. However, Western Europe and similar contries have seen massive progress in the XX century on this topic. I think it's fair to call out the countries who don't seem particularly willing to follow along.