7 ms·
This reminds me of the gender-based discrimination in Banks’ Culture novel The Player of Games. It’s still astounding to me to see a country keep half of its p
by sneak 6y ago
This reminds me of the gender-based discrimination in Banks’ Culture novel The Player of Games.
It’s still astounding to me to see a country keep half of its population in effective slavery.
- vertis 6y agoI don't even remember that from 'The Player of Games', perhaps I need to re-read.
- webmaven 6y agoIn the book, the dominant "apex" gender is quite blatant about its subjugation of the other two (males and females). In this way, Banks managed to present an extremely unequal society and its ills without having to refute any of the unfair critiques either a patriarchy or matriarchy would have prompted.
- klyrs 6y agoThe death penalty is still employed against LGBT folks there, too. Pretty awkward when your company wants to do business in a country where an onsite could be a lethal endeavor. Maybe, just don't do business with these folks until they get with the times. It worked with South Africa.
- sukilot 6y agoIt's not freedom, but it's not slavery.
- watwut 6y agoIt is not chattel slavery. It is that far off to other forms of slavery.
- luckylion 6y agoIt's pretty far off from other forms of slavery as well. The slaves in Saudi Arabia are the foreign domestic workers, like in pretty much all Arab countries. It's an underdeveloped culture, women don't have equal rights by any means, but it's not slavery. Continuously reaching for superlatives just makes the terms useless.
- watwut 6y agoThe "not having equal rights" is euphemism too, it makes it feel like western 1950-1960 when women still had significantly more freedom. Inability to leave makes big difference. Especially when limts are enforced by police prisons and both state and private violence. It is hard to distinguish from ownership.
- luckylion 6y agoI said they don't have equal rights by any means, in other words they're not close to having equal rights. But it's still not slavery. Navy blue isn't as light as aqua blue, but that doesn't make it black. I'm not arguing for Saudi Arabia here, I find most things I know about their culture and traditions to be disgusting (though they appear to be making progress, no doubt thanks to international pressure and the oil money drying up). But I'm strongly against this trend of constantly reaching for the most extreme words for dramatic effect. Saudi Arabia does have slaves, actual real slaves. But they're not Saudi women (they're often women, but they're from e.g. Malaysia or the Philippines and are forced to serve these Saudi women you call slaves). If you call the Saudi women slaves, what word would you use for their slaves? Slaves' slaves? Super slaves? Real slaves? Why not just call them slaves, and call the Saudi women something else, describe their situation with different words. Something like saying they're not given anywhere close to the same rights as Saudi men of equal standing, are not given the freedom that we consider a basic human right, and are forced to live in an underdeveloped society. That's bad enough, and I hope their situation improves, but it's not slavery.
- klyrs 6y agoIn the US, house slaves were no less slaves just because they could boss the plantation slaves around. Women in Saudi Arabia do not have autonomy, and they're treated as property by the legal system and by the culture. You're responding to somebody who said "effectively slaves," an attempt at softening the language that you're taking issue with. What other word in our language conveys that a person is property?
- klyrs 6y agoWomen are effectively owned by men. They can do very little without permission of a male guardian. There's been a bit of progress in the last few years, but for example marriage is a contract between two men amounting to transfering ownership of the bride.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoThat's not as radically different from Western culture as Western culture likes to pretend it is. We have traditions like a man asking her father for her hand in marriage. We change her last name to signify she has transferred identity from her father's clan to her husband's. We treat marriage as very much a financial contract and divorce tends to hurt women financially much more than it does men. Etc.
- bitexploder 6y agoAnecdotally this is just wrong. My wife’s Dad was a real piece of work. In a country like SA she would never have gotten away from him. She met me online. The day after she graduated college, without ever discussing it with her father, she moved away with me across the country. Her choice. She decided to take my last name, for simplicities sake, but it was a rational choice we made. Every step of the way it was her choice. Amongst my peer group almost all married women are in a similar situation. The level of freedom is orders of magnitude difference IMO.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoI chose to take my husband's name and kept it when I divorced him. But the tradition is rooted in that idea that she left her clan and joined his. That's the origin story for it. I don't have a simple solution for that one. I don't think it's inherently bad that women typically change their last name. But the reason it is done is because the way women get treated the world over has some things in common. The level of freedom is debatable for Western women. But I already said Westerners don't like to hear that and it got downvoted and dismissed out of hand. So I'm not really up for trying to argue it, given the climate.