3 ms·
YC is a better example of a credential than a Github account. The function of credentials is to outsource decision making about quality: you have to actually r
by patio11 16y ago
YC is a better example of a credential than a Github account. The function of credentials is to outsource decision making about quality: you have to actually read code to extract signal about a candidate from Github, a task which is expensive and beyond the capabilities of most investors and people with hiring authority. "YC alum", by comparison, tells you a lot about somebody in a sentence and doesn't require any work to understand - pg et al already did the vetting for you.
There probably exists a spectrum of opinions on whether the credential is useful because of the vetting or the experience of the actual program. Candidly, I think that YC probably has a value add in attendance. Higher education? Not generally, no. I have a $140,000 degree (two, technically) which basically certifies that at 18 years old I was smart enough to get into my university and then, for the next four years, I did not die or fail to sign my loan docs. I know I learned some things of value in those four years, but I could just as easily have written myself a course of study with zero commercial potential, and my degree would say the same thing in a language 99.998% of Americans can't even read anyway. (East Asian Studies degree written in... Latin?!
- kenjackson 16y agoThere probably exists a spectrum of opinions on whether the credential is useful because of the vetting or the experience of the actual program. Candidly, I think that YC probably has a value add in attendance. Higher education? Not generally, no. The problem with higher ed is that if there is value add they make it impossible to know. Try to get outgoing metrics, besides grad rates, of outgoing undergrads and its near impossible. Professional schools do a better job of this.
- robrenaud 16y agoFacebook and LinkedIn definitely have good data about college education and employment outcomes. I really wish they would just compete head on with USNews for college rankings. For example, I'd love to see income distributions by university/major. The universities themselves cannot be trusted to provide it in any accurate fashion[1], but mining it from a large sample of graduates would be much better and less biased. [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2011/01/09/business/09law.html?_r=1&src=me&ref=homepage http://www.nytimes.com/2011/01/09/business/09law.html?_r=1&#...
- jonbischke 16y agoI don't disagree but it's tough to scale YC. Same with Thiel fellowship. However, it isn't unreasonable to see a situation in which follower counts on sites like Github, Dribbble, Quora, etc. do become scalable ways of signaling. They aren't perfect indicators of ability or knowledge but then again, neither are college degrees (as anyone who has ever hired a dud college grad can attest to). YC, TechStars, Thiel, etc. are awesome signals for those who achieve them just as Harvard, Stanford and MIT are but I think the real juice is in the alternatives for those who don't fall into the top 1% of 1% who simply wish to prove their knowledge and abilities without having to drop six figures in the process.
- apl 16y ago> However, it isn't unreasonable to see a situation in > which follower counts on sites like Github, Dribbble, > Quora, etc. do become scalable ways of signaling. They > aren't perfect indicators of ability or knowledge but > then again, neither are college degrees "Karma"-based mechanisms favor a very specific personality profile. One that doesn't necessarily correlate with aptitude. Just have a look at the SO superstars -- none of them are auto-hires for all situations. You'd need to evaluate them individually and carefully. Presumably to a degree that makes their community rating superfluous.