3 ms·
I'm sorry but I don't believe them that it can run for 300km in between refuels. Compressed air is just not a very dense fuel. Enough fuel to power a car for th
by ars 18y ago
I'm sorry but I don't believe them that it can run for 300km in between refuels. Compressed air is just not a very dense fuel. Enough fuel to power a car for that long would be a tank about 1/3 the size of the car.
(My calculation: gasoline stores about 3000 times as much energy as compressed air per volume. But a gasoline engine is also only 10% efficient, an air engine would be much more efficient. Assuming 100% efficient, then gasoline stores 300 times as much. I can go about 300km using 11 or so gallons of gas. Lets assume a lighter car, so 5 gallons per 300km * 300 = 1500 gallons of air, which is about 5.5 cubic meters. So you'd need a box 1.75 meters on each side. Which is about 1/3 of a car.)
Obviously if they can store the air at a higher density then the box can be smaller, but if they did that it would also have to be stronger and thus heavier. (Edit: they are running at about 1/3 more pressure than my numbers assumed.)
And now comes the bigger problem: you waste a tremendous amount of energy by heating the air when you compress it.
And then you let the air cool, and lose again, because as it expands it gets _really_ cold, and won't expand as much. On the plus side running the A/C will be free. But forget about heat in the winter.
Using higher compression makes this much worse.
All in all, I simply don't think this will work for that distance. Maybe as a 30km car it would work fine (and there's a large market for that), but not 300km.
And the heating/cooling losses are really going to hurt efficiency.
And as an aside using vegetable oil is a bad idea. Unless you can seal it away from air (doubtful) it will oxidize and won't be oil anymore.
Now please tell me if I made any mistakes in my calculations.
- DaniFong 18y agoYou've made a few small mistakes, but they're non-obvious. One big thing is that your current vehicle doesn't push the technical mileage limits as far as the Air Car does. You've assumed the car is the same weight. Cars can be made much lighter than those currently on the market today. You can get well below 1000 pounds. For example, one design prototype is the Volkswagen 1-liter car, which gets 282 mpg. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_1-litre_car http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_1-litre_car). This design uses a variety of techniques to get the mileage up, and does so quite wonderfully. With an Air Car it's even easier: you can even do it in a production, mass market system. You need not have a transmission, or an electrical system, or an air conditioning system, so you can get a very good car, a production car, for under 1000 pounds. Also, unlike gasoline engines, it's a comparatively simple matter to have breaks which recover power. Power recovering breaks become simply a system for compressing and releasing a piston: a fairly mature technology actually. So breaking is not as much of an issue, and the energy you'd lose for it can be recovered at about the 70% efficiency level. Also, compressed air, at 300 bar (4500 psi) stores approximately 16 kwh per 300 liters, (via wikipedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_vehicle#Storage_Tanks http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_vehicle#Storage_Tanks), giving an energy density of 0.0056 of gas (in liters). In other words, gasoline takes 176 times less space, not 3000 times, as you guessed. And given modern tanks, the air is lighter than it is large (compared to gas), though weight is a property of the tank, and does not scale linearly. I haven't factored the efficiency of gas versus air engines into this calculation, as both technologies are varied and evolving. When these factors combine, you can get a much, much more efficient vehicle than ordinary. Getting around 80 km is a no-brainer, and 300 km is well within the realm of possibility. You might go up to 1000km before you start to hit fundamental limits. To address some of your other concerns. The temperature regulation of the compressed air tank is not as much of an issue as you think. There are two temperature regulation problems. The first is heating the tank as you compress it. This is not a fundamental problem, but it's actually a technical detail that I think I've solved, and I want to develop it for my startup. You'll just have to trust me that there's a way to heat this cost effectively. The second direction is when the air is expanding. While the expanding air leaving the tank is quite cold, the tank itself doesn't expand very fast, and air simply doesn't have much heat capacity. Oil and water have a far greater heat capacity, and so running a radiator in a gasoline car is actually a much more significant problem. Also, the oil they use is actually a vegetable oil derivative. They use a combination anti-oxidant and mineral (anti-corrosion) additive (such as http://www.hexion.com/products/technicaldatasheet.aspx?id=3986 http://www.hexion.com/products/technicaldatasheet.aspx?id=39... though I don't know the exact product). Additionally, there are wonderful, wonderful ways in which to improve the energy economy of these vehicles as compared to gasoline (or any other comparable vehicle, including electric). Email me, if you might be interested, since I am working on them, and actually looking for more mechanical engineering and organizational talent, or funding, or mentorship.
- ars 18y agoAs I replied to someone else, you are right, I was off by 10 in my calculations (a typo in my calculator, sigh). But I did take efficiency, and light weight vehicle into account. But I still maintain that the heating/cooling losses from compressing the air are going to hurt efficiency a lot. It's really hard to do anything with waste heat, especially since this car probably won't be sold in cold climates, so the waste heat can't be used for heating. But, since an air engine is so much more efficient than internal combustion, it might work out. But if it works so well, I wonder why no one did it before now - is the tank the problem? Does it make sense to use a larger, lower pressure tank? I'm very interested in these ideas, and I spend a lot of time dreaming up ideas - basically every time I have to fix something in my car I think of a way to design a car without that part. But I don't know if I could actually help you - I'm a computer programmer, I don't have experience with any of the skills you mentioned.
- DaniFong 18y agoMost of the best engineers were outside of car design and into aerospace since the early 40's. Getting a car that works at this level of efficiency requires three or four conceptual jumps, which weren't made until a market forces induced some thought on the problem. Additionally, none of the interested parties have figured out the last step: how to cheaply charge the thing (while recycling the waste energy). But I think I might have.
- MaysonL 18y agoIn the winter you compress the air at home and use the heat to keep your house nice and toasty. Your calculations are off: energy density of gasoline ~35 MJ/L, compressed air at 300 bar ~ .15, so per volume is ~230 times, so w 10x efficiency, it's down to 23X volume required: tank to be used is 340 L : divide by 23 ~= 15 L ~= 4 gal. Much closer to their claim, no? The compression stations will have heat exchangers, so be able to use at least some of the wasted energy... (Note: energy density figures from Wikipedia)
- ars 18y agoMan, that's embarrassing. I also got my numbers from wikipedia, but typed .01 instead of .1 in my calculator :( So yes, now I have to retract what I wrote about the size of the tank. I have new respect for the power of air.