4 ms·
Telling someone the truth cannot be a disparaging remark.
by onion2k 6y ago
Telling someone the truth cannot be a disparaging remark.
- vlovich123 6y agoFirst, I'm pretty sure you're confusing defamation with disparagement. Defamation requires the claim to be untruthful. Disparaging remarks can definitely be true - they just require the remarks to paint you in a negative light. All defamation is disparaging. Not all disparagement is defamation. Secondly, it seems like you're picking sides rather than objectively evaluating the merits of the argument. Sure, Facebook saying Apple gets 30% of the cut is technically a true fact. The truth is ultimately more than a collection of facts that are true. You can manipulate perception by how you present the set of facts, which you emphasize & which you omit. It's totally conceivable to imagine there Apple may feel the true fact Facebook is emphasizing isn't a fair representation of the truth. Even if it were, Apple would surely feel they don't want individual apps putting up advertising that disparages the very platform they are being served by. If they allowed it for Facebook it would open up the flood gates for publicity stunts/coordinated attacks from smaller companies which would force shifts in policy they view as important for the long-term health of the ecosystem (& their revenue & margins too probably). Finally, Google has the same policies & the notice appears to be missing from the Android app too [1]. This is trying to hold Apple to task over a purity standard that no one follows. This all feels like a media and legal blitz by very large companies trying to leverage dissatisfaction with the tech companies in Congress to wrest significant concessions from Apple. I'm genuinely curious about the media blitz focusing on Apple when Android has all the same policies. Is Apple viewed as the first important domino to then take on Google with? Does Apple just hold the lion's share of profitable users? Is Apple just making stories "pop" more with readers? Disclaimer: I work at Facebook & have worked at Google & Apple in the past. I don't have a dog in this fight & all opinions are my own. [1] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-facebook-apple-exclusive/exclusive-facebook-says-apple-rejected-its-attempt-to-tell-users-about-app-store-fees-idUSKBN25O042 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-facebook-apple-exclusive/... > The social media giant also planned to tell users on Alphabet Inc’s Google Play store it would not collect a fee for ticket sales, but that message was not displayed either, Reuters found.