3 ms·
You're missing the fact that more space allocated to roads and parking moves the things people actually want to do farther apart, increasing the need for more r
by adrianN 6y ago
You're missing the fact that more space allocated to roads and parking moves the things people actually want to do farther apart, increasing the need for more roads and parking.
People don't want to drive, they want to get to places. That's the actual demand that needs to be satisfied. Cars don't scale very well to do so. You can't realistically build roads in cities that can move the same number of people as a subway line. If you did you wouldn't have a city anymore, you'd have a parking lot with some buildings sprinkled across it.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> You're missing the fact that more space allocated to roads and parking moves the things people actually want to do farther apart, increasing the need for more roads and parking. But if this is your concern then the thing that really moves the things people actually want to do farther apart is low density zoning requirements. Which is also the thing that keeps mass transit from being viable, because it needs enough population density to fill the vehicles while still offering frequent enough service to be competitive.
- emn13 6y agoThat's too simplistic; you can't pin the blame on a singular effect like that nor choose to disregard other factors to conveniently support some conclusion. It is incidentally clear that low density zoning requirements are not the singular driving factor for sprawl simply because the sprawl occurs even in places without those rules (e.g. houston). Furthermore, effects like these have complex feedback loops. Zoning laws are entirely politically motivated - so the public's support is critical. You can be sure that public support would be affected if it became clear they led to crippling congestion that would not be solved by more road infrastructure; and conversely sprawl-encouraging zoning laws also encourage sprawl-enabling transport investments. Other factors to consider are parking availability (and rules concerning that), and probably more. The correlation between these effects means that you should be careful blaming just one factor, and certainly cannot conclude anything meaningful if you intentionally and artificially exclude related factors from your analysis.
- anonymoushn 6y agoIn downtown Austin, many uses are placed next to each other and density is fairly high, but half of the blocks are allocated to parking. So somehow the things people actually want to do are moved far apart by factors other than low density zoning.