4 ms·
isn't compressed air pretty dangerous? i.e. if you end up in an accident
by vaksel 18y ago
isn't compressed air pretty dangerous? i.e. if you end up in an accident
- nirmal 18y agoA lot of people in India drive cars that run off of compressed natural gas.
- mikkom 18y agoIt's totally different, the compression there is just for more effective storage, the power still comes from the gas itself. In compressed air however it's the compression that contains the power to move the car. Drive an accident and the same power that moves your car will release its power with quite an unpleasant speed.
- noonespecial 18y agoFew things in the common life of people are as dangerous as 25 gallons of unleaded. I'd much rather face any compressed air explosion than be soaked in burning gas.
- misterbwong 18y agoI don't quite buy this argument. Gas is far less volatile than people think. In the event of an accident, I would much rather face a tank of gasoline, which most likely wouldn't explode at all, than a tank of compressed air. In the middle of the fire, however, I'm not so sure.
- bprater 18y agoGas vapors are dangerous. Without the air, you can drop a lit match in a gas tank, without a 'big boom'. However, in an accident, you'd want to pick the compressed air tank. The tanks are very strong. Gas tanks in cars are built with very flimsy steel. Industries like welding has been using high-pressure tanks for decades, and bottles rarely fail.
- Dobbs 18y agoYes industries like welding have been using high-pressure tanks for decades, but that's not high pressure tanks that are traveling at 70 miles an hour in a tight corridor surrounded by hundreds of other cars that likewise are traveling at 70 mph. Can you say chain reaction? Compressed air is far more dangerous than gasoline. Gasoline is not a guaranteed explosion more likely its a fire.
- ars 18y agoI would like to see that in action, because it seems to me that allowing gas to expand that fast is going to drop the temperature of the gas so low it'll probably freeze CO2 out of the air. And that process will probably rob a lot of the explosive force. Can you compress gas so much that if it exploded it would liquefy? With a quick google I couldn't find an equation relating pressure drop to temperature in real air (not ideal gas).
- noonespecial 18y agoI think its worth mentioning that explosion is not the danger we should be thinking about when it comes to gasoline. Gas is a low viscosity, oily (duh) substance held in flimsy metal or plastic containers that ignites easily and is hard to put out. We are comparing the danger of being injured by the compressed air explosion with the danger of being burned severely by sprayed or leaked fuel. Sign me up for the shrapnel because burns suck huge.
- noonespecial 18y agoHave you never driven behind a welding supply truck with all of those tanks rattling and smashing around back there? Some of those tanks are both under extremely high pressure and contain explosive gases.
- radu_floricica 18y agoI was just thinking about these. Yes, they're used for years, but they are incredibly dangerous and treated as such. I remember that not any compressor can load them: if it leaks the tiniest amount of oil in the air it'll create an explosive mix.
- rms 18y ago>Few things in the common life of people are as dangerous as 25 gallons of unleaded. How about driving a car?
- mikkom 18y agoOr eating a razorblade?
- bprater 18y agoCompressed air is dangerous if it is released too rapidly, especially if it's pointed at your eye or someone breaks the cap off a bottle. Otherwise, compressed air is used in every car shop in the world for. Pneumatic tools may not require as much pressure as this car, though. But we have plenty of experience in designing containers to hold gas under high pressures.
- vaksel 18y agothe air tanks in the garage aren't in danger of being suddenly ruptured by a car that rear ends you at 40 mph. And don't tell me that doesn't happen, since I had that happen to me two times already, strangely enough the accidents were less than 2 weeks apart, and both times they were big SUVs(Navigator and an X5). Actually the same thing happened to a friend(in his case it was a Grand Cherokee). So accidents like this probably happen quiet often. And yes before someone asks in all 3 cases, it was a soccer mom on a cell phone.
- DaniFong 18y agoThe PSI 4500 containers they use are brittle, but they don't explode or shatter -- they just crack. It's actually a mature technology.
- reazalun 18y agoThe tank is made of carbon fibre. So if you get an accident, the tank won't explode, it just splits. Check 3:06 in this video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QmqpGZv0YT4 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QmqpGZv0YT4