5 ms·
The slow march to cost-effectiveness continues. But no killer app yet. Much of this is a mechanical design problem. You need to be able to generate large force
by Animats 6y ago
The slow march to cost-effectiveness continues. But no killer app yet.
Much of this is a mechanical design problem. You need to be able to generate large forces from a small package, but not all the time. Hydraulics can do it, but then you need a big pump and power source, like the older Boston Dynamics machines. Until recently, all-electric didn't have the power density. Now it does. Which is why quadrotor drones work.
Small polyphase permanent magnet motors ("brushless DC") have taken over. The controllers to drive them at variable speed are now cheap. No brushes, no arcing, no magnet demagnetization. The remaining limit on motor power is cooling.
It's too bad Schaft Robotics was liquidated. They were doing well on humanoids. Then Google bought them, trashed them, and dumped the remains.
They were into small liquid-cooled motors. That's a way to get huge torques when you need them.
Reduction gears are always a problem. If they're big enough not to snap gear teeth on shock loads, they're too heavy. Better materials for toothed belts have helped. Those have more space to absorb a shock load. Researchers like harmonic drives, because they can put a big reduction in a small package, but harmonic drives are especially vulnerable to broken gear teeth on overload.
Direct drive, without gears or belts, would be nice. The advantage of direct drive is, as someone said a century ago in the context of electric locomotives, "You cannot strip the teeth of a magnetic field." Washing machine motors are often direct drive today. The electronics is cheaper and more rugged than a gearbox. It's encouraging seeing that happen in a mass-market product.
There's a lot of engineering like that which needs to be done to get mobile robots down to the price of a non-luxury car.
- pharke 6y ago> Then Google bought them, trashed them, and dumped the remains. This seems to be a too oft repeated refrain. Google has become such a mire of intra-office politics that being acquired by them is almost a guaranteed death sentence.
- Ygg2 6y agoGoogle is the new IBM.
- andromeduck 6y agoIBM at least had the maturity not to freak out at anything resembling a defense contract.
- jamiek88 6y agoLike in 1939? They sure fulfilled that contract.
- candiodari 6y agoIn case somebody doesn't realize what this is about. IBM helped governments execute government programs. In 1939, IBM helped the then German government, the Nazi government since 1933, among other things with their new task of "ethnic identification", determining who was Jewish and who was not (because they had complex rules about that involving ancestry). They continued doing this during the war, ... and during the "trial run" holocaust by the German and Austrian Youth Services, then the continuation of that trial run by the psychiatric institutions ... and then with the actual Holocaust. They used a Polish subsidiary, run by a Nazi (owned 90% by IBM), in case you were wondering how they did that without being convicted of treason. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_and_the_Holocaust https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_and_the_Holocaust
- tgflynn 6y agoDo you think there's any chance of direct drive generating enough torque for a roughly human sized robotic arm with human like performance (say to lift a 20 kg load) ? The last time I looked into this it didn't look like that much torque was available in a small form factor. I found it rather surprising because larger scale industrial robot arms appear to far exceed any biological arm in both strength and speed.
- macrolime 6y agoThere's at least some with 8kg payload https://www.halodi.com/ever3 https://www.halodi.com/ever3
- thefounder 6y agoI don't think a robot needs to lift more than 1kg or even less to be game changer. It just needs to be accurate and smart enough so that it can use different tools(i.e push different buttons) that do the heavy lifting.
- tgflynn 6y agoIf all you want to do is push buttons there's probably a much simpler and cheaper way to accomplish what you want electronically.
- Teever 6y agoI think we're talking about integrating robots into an environment that is designed for humans. As such robots pushing buttons is a good thing to reach for.
- tgflynn 6y agoI still think that application is a dead end. Anything that has buttons on it these days (and increasingly so in the future) is likely to also have some kind of wifi or other remote and/or programmable interface so control of that machine really isn't something you need or want a robot to do. I'm not sure exactly what the parent had in mind but consider the problem of washing dishes. A robot that can load a dishwasher has value, a robot that can only press the start button not so much.
- spullara 6y agoBack in high school I had an idea for strings of electromagnetics and springs acting like muscles when power was applied. Seemed like a cool idea but never really figured out if it was at all plausible. Are any of these systems trying to simulate muscles more directly?
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 6y agoIt's amazing to think that so much of the future we imagined decades ago (flying cars, robots, jetpacks, maybe even leisure space travel) might be here if energy weren't an issue. If there's ever a 10x breakthrough in battery tech (today's performance with 10x the energy density), I'd bet the world would change pretty quickly. Even a 2x breakthrough.
- andromeduck 6y agoYou can throw "renewables" in there too. Everyone just assumes battery tech is on some kind of moore's law scaling just like how everyone thought SSDs were going to be 1c per TB by now.