5 ms·
Exactly. This is Google drawing the line on where this "hate speech" is from and they believe that such "content" can be accessed via the Fediverse. To see how
by rvz 6y ago
Exactly. This is Google drawing the line on where this "hate speech" is from and they believe that such "content" can be accessed via the Fediverse.
To see how ridiculous this sounds, Google might as well completely take down the entire social media and internet browsing category on the Play Store since I keep seeing the same content from both extremes on all these platforms.
Just wait until you tell them to take down their own browser since you can find this "content" with a simple search. They will soon realise that "drawing the line on hate speech" is more tougher than solving leetcode CS questions.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- noworriesnate 6y agoI get what you're saying, but I don't think this is because Google cares about hate speech. Google is simply using hate speech as an excuse to get rid of apps that it doesn't like. Deciding which apps you like and which you don't isn't that hard of a line to draw.
- tsherr 6y agoThat's precisely what they are doing. They don't care about hate speech. If they did, they wouldn't have Trump ads on the YouTube banner. This is justification to get rid of apps they don't like.
- djsumdog 6y agoNot allowing a parties political ads would be clear favoritism in a political situation. You might not like Trump, but it's quite the jump to say republican ads are "hate speech." .. in fact that's quite literally weaponizing the word "hate speech" to censor political opinions you don't like.
- VLM 6y agoWhich is the whole point of hate speech laws. Can't market censorship of one party, but who could ever oppose censoring hate... then redefine hate to be anything you'd like censored, and ... that's what we have now. Any time anyone complains about censorship, roll out the excuse of holocaust denial, regardless whats actually being censored.
- chrisco255 6y agoYes it's why freedom of speech is a thing. Ideas are meant to compete and the power to decide which ideas are acceptable is an absolute power that completely corrupts a society.
- betterunix2 6y ago> it's quite the jump to say republican ads are "hate speech." It is not a jump when they have used Nazi symbols in their campaign ads, promoted antisemitic conspiracy theories in their campaign ads, made transparently racist statements about their opponents, etc. It is not that "hate speech" is being weaponized to censor political position (the Republican party is not even promoting a specific policy agency in this election cycle), but rather that the term "censorship" is being weaponized to legitimize the extremist ideologies of domestic terrorist groups (classified as such by the FBI). To put it another way, if one of your coworkers was carrying on about how wealthy Jews were conspiring to spread civil unrest as part of a broad plot to destroy the United States, you would call it "hate speech" and you would be right to report them to HR. Yet that is just one of the many extremist conspiracy theories the Republican party has promoted in this election cycle, which follows the previous two cycles that featured similar antisemitism and other expressions of racism. Some Republican politicians have publicly stated that George Floyd was killed in order to start a race war in America, which only a few years ago is a statement that you would have only found on a website like "the daily stormer." The current Republican president has endorsed a candidate who said Muslims marry their siblings, and another candidate who said Muslims are a cancer on humanity and should be forbidden from holding office. None of that is "political opinion," it is extremist ideology that is on par with the kind of things that ISIS claimed about the Yazidis.
- tachyonbeam 6y agoGoogle is politically very very left. I'm guessing that someone at Google may have browsed these apps, decided they didn't like what they saw, and pressured to have the apps banned. Obviously they can't do that to large players like Facebook, but small apps, they can easily crush, and nobody's going to do anything about it. Image if Google decided to just block certain websites on Chrome, or if big tech got domain registrars to drop 4chan, or whatever humor websites they don't find amusing.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- passerby1 6y agoWhat prevents Google from stopping resolving some domains at 8.8.8.8?
- dash2 6y agoThat already happened with certain extremist Islamic websites.
- at_a_remove 6y agoI wonder if Cloudflare is still protecting ISIS sites from DDoSses and the like.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoThe fascinating part of this is that Google has officially claimed the mantle of arbiter of what is allowed on the internet ( they are not exactly a gate keeper yet, but given how people have trouble accessing information outside FB, Apple, Google gardens, they are well on their way ). edit: Trouble in a sense that it is inconvenient for them.
- rootsudo 6y agoYou are absolutely right, and this is scary. Absolute fear.
- VLM 6y agoAs the editor of the internet, are they not taking on full legal liability for anything they haven't blocked yet?
- heavyset_go 6y agoNo, and there are laws and tomes of case law that reinforce that no matter how much curation they do, an interactive computer service will not be held liable for user generated content.
- chrisco255 6y agoYeah but that can be changed with a simple act of Congress and it should be. Their support is rapidly eroding the more they flex their power.
- Nasrudith 6y agoThat would be an especially stupid move even for Congress. Expect to see either bland corporate content or goatse everywhere then.
- core-questions 6y ago> Just wait until you tell them to take down their own browser Well, they're taking the address bar away, bit by bit; they have SafeSearch; and they have AMP. It's a very slow erosion, but there will come a point at which going outside of the list of officially acceptable sites will become more difficult - first with mandatory warnings, then maybe with mandatory reporting to law enforcement or whomever, and eventually not at all. Yes, it sounds like a "slippery slope" argument, but we're a few steps down the slope now, and any argument that encourages us to climb back up has to point out where things may go if we don't resist. It sucks that this requires us to defend the rights of people to speak whom we may intensely disagree with, but that's the crux of the matter. Either we become mature enough to understand that people will have discourse we dislike, and avoid it or engage with it as we see fit, or we continue to hide behind authority figures who will purport to keep us safe by controlling what we can say and think.
- rossjudson 6y agoAnd yet the rest of the category is still there. This is a great opportunity to put on your thinking hat.