3 ms·
I think this is a good example of "you can't solve human problems with cute tech workarounds" because I think Google is actually in the right here (given you th
by Spivak 6y ago
I think this is a good example of "you can't solve human problems with cute tech workarounds" because I think Google is actually in the right here (given you think their ban on hate speech is general is legitimate). It shouldn't matter at all the technical details of how an app works or the fact that it's federated or distributed. All that really matters to the policy is what a user sees when they download and open the app.
And on that front I completely understand where Google is coming from. Because the fediverse has a laissez faire attitude towards moderation (i.e. instance owners don't really block much) much of what you see on the fediverse is stuff that would get you banned on mainstream social networks [1]. And that content is the default experience unlike a web browser/chat programs/communities where you have to seek out that kind of content.
I expect that an app tied to a specific instance that put effort into moderating their content and put up some safeguards against seeing content on other instances by default with some popup like "content on other servers is not vetted, are you sure?" would be allowed to stay.
[1] Which makes sense since these are some of the only havens for people who can't make it on Twitter/FB/Reddit.
- bccdee 6y agoThe technical details do matter quite a bit though, because the same logic could be used to ban (for instance) web browsers. Because the web is an open protocol that can be used to communicate with any website, even objectionable ones, every browser is an app that gives access to hatespeech content. Google may ban the 8chan app, but they don't ban browsers despite browsers being able to access the 8chan website. Of course, Google won't ban the web, but only because it doesn't suit them to. What we wind up with is Google having arbitrary control over which types of communication protocols are allowed on Android with no need to justify their decisions, because any protocol could carry hatespeech, and that's pretty concerning.