13 ms·
Is Cyberpunk Dead? A Conversation with Bruce Bethke
- 082349872349872 6y agoWhat are, in the 20's, the big concepts that "cyber"[1] was to the 80's? Ecopunk has apparently been done, in 風の谷のナウシカ: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24298259 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24298259 [1] we started with Tron and wound up with "I put on my robe and wizard hat."
- keiferski 6y agoI'd nominate "loss of trust in traditional media / fractionalization of society-wide narratives" as a major one. PropagandaPunk? TruthPunk?
- dleslie 6y agoThat's been a go-to backgrounder for Tom Clancy and other military/spy thriller writers for decades.
- keiferski 6y agoI meant more with regards to the Internet and the "post-truth" era we are supposedly in, at least in a media context. From my perspective every media source has become intensely partisan / there is no single mainstream media narrative anymore, which is a new phenomenon. +1 for Tom Clancy though. I grew up reading all the Rainbow Six books.
- dleslie 6y agoIt's not a new phenomenon; the idea that there's a post-truth era to news media is as old as news media itself. This is where the term "Yellow Journalism" derives from; but even that aged term came to being well after distrust in news media was common.
- keiferski 6y agoI don't agree. Yellow journalism was a similar phenomenon, but the pre-social media landscape was far different from the one today. Pre-social media, you still needed significant resources to push your narrative. Today, you mostly just need to go viral. Not too many resources required. Very different situation.
- dleslie 6y agoPublic access and small local radio were cheap or free to access, and common sources of fringe ideas. It wasn't until the spectrum ownership was consolidated that this access disipated; but by then, dial up BBSs were common and growing popular. Also, handing out and distributing hand-pressed folios was common; and a source of much of the zeitgeist for several political revolutions.
- notahacker 6y agoBiopunk's been done but pandemics and battles for cures and control over cures and 'was this all a conspiracy' seem very relevant to this year specifically
- dleslie 6y agoBioPunk? Paolo Bacigalupi's "The Windup Girl" is an interesting take on this. The most concise take I've seen for the core defining aesthetic of cyberpunk is: "high tech, low life." With that in mind, I don't think it _really_ matters what the tech is, so long as the story is about those on the fringes of society and their interactions with it; how _alien_ the world is to them, and how alien they are to the world.
- nrp 6y agoI would add “Blindsight” by Peter Watts to the list of great biopunk novels.
- jfb 6y ago"Whenever I find my will to live becoming too strong, I read Peter Watts". —James Nicoll
- Apocryphon 6y agoWatts's work is great also as an existentialist hard sci-fi cosmic horror. It's got all of the Plutonian depths, malevolent antediluvian creatures, unfathomable aliens, degenerated humanity, and posthuman body horror of Lovecraft, just not the omnipotent space gods. Plus, he even continues cyberpunk tropes to their natural dystopian conclusions- in Rifters, "N'Am" is a continent governed by the power company that sends PTSD-afflicted veterans and abuse survivors to maintain deep sea geothermal generators, gigacorp execs are literally called "corpses", and the internet is completely swallowed up by A.I. spam bots.
- dymax78 6y agoHow would you rate the Rifters trilogy vs the Firefall trilogy? (I thoroughly enjoyed Blindsight, hobbled my way through Echopraxia, and it's unlikely I'll read Firefall)
- Apocryphon 6y agoI haven’t finished the Firefall trilogy yet, but Blindsight was pretty good up until the last book at least.
- fludlight 6y agoThe pandemic will feature prominently in fiction for many years. Every genre from scifi, dramas, horror, comedies, etc will be touched by it since the event has touched every person on earth. Themes around loneliness and isolation will be more common than before. The aesthetic will be sweatpants. The other big concept will be concentration camps, specifically the ones currently operated by the United States. China also has these, at a larger scale and with much, much worse treatment, but the megacorps that control western media are too cowardly to broach the subject until after they are banned from the country. Criticizing the US is less risky. Perhaps the next Nobel in literature will be written by a teenager currently laying on a concrete floor trying to console a toddler who was sprayed with a chemical prohibited by the Geneva Convention.
- hnick 6y agoSomeone else mentioned Mr Robot and I think it fits the bill. Without giving too much away there are questions like who is really in control, the nature of reality, the rise of China, the interplay between control/privacy/hacking, and of course a heavy dose of mental health issues. I think one big thing they missed was the decay of traditional news media and the rise of social media but maybe I'm forgetting something.
- keiferski 6y agoBethke coined the word cyberpunk and here's a little essay about it: https://web.archive.org/web/20130716211015/http://www.brucebethke.com/articles/re_cp.html https://web.archive.org/web/20130716211015/http://www.bruceb...
- teilo 6y agoThank you. The word Cyberpunk may have come first, but there is no question that Gibson defined what it means.
- parsoj 6y agoI'm confused - is this complaining about the genre as a whole being less popular? Or just books? I think with one of the most hyped and games of the year being a cyberpunk game (with "Cyberpunk" literally in the name) - its definitely premature to call the genre as a whole "dead" If this article is just lamenting the absence of Cyberpunk books - well surges in popularity in one media can always carry over to others...
- keiferski 6y agoThe article isn't about either of those things. It's about the original ideas of cyberpunk (which were rooted in the 80s) being turned into cliches and repeated ad infinitum since and whether a new 2020-era genre is needed.
- whatshisface 6y ago>whether a new 2020-era genre is needed. The idea that a new genre could be created because critics concluded that one was "needed" is the daftest and most out-of-touch thing I've ever heard...
- keiferski 6y agoOr, you know, times change, new problems arise, thus needing new solutions...
- NineStarPoint 6y agoWell, generally it’s more like critics pointing out that the niche cyberpunk used to fill is now empty and that something will inevitably come to fill it. Critics definitely don’t have the power to actually create a genre like that, those come from grassroot sources, but a good critic would be able to realize that there’s a literary void that is waiting to be filled.
- _jal 6y agoThe idea that a random person on a message board could inspire someone to write software because someone said they needed a tool is the daftest, most out-of-touch thing I've ever read. Oh wait, that has happened multiple times. Granted, a genre is bigger than a tool. But this free-floating hatred for commentators of all stripes literally blinds people to reality. And it isn't some Critic-On-High making pronouncements and waiting for followers to act. It is observational.
- CapricornNoble 6y agoWasn't William Gibson (author of Neuromancer) roughly quoted saying: "I don't write 'cyberpunk' dystopias anymore...because we are living them. They are our reality today. So I just write contemporary fiction." ....somebody help me out on this...I might be off the mark.
- anotherman554 6y agoI suspect you are thinking of a different writer. I've never read a Gibson interview where he said anything like that, though I have not read every Gibson interview.
- akeck 6y agoThis article has similar quotes from Gibson: https://www.theguardian.com/books/2020/jan/11/william-gibson-i-was-losing-a-sense-of-how-weird-the-real-world-was https://www.theguardian.com/books/2020/jan/11/william-gibson...
- anotherman554 6y agoNot really. He doesn't describe our world as a cyberpunk dystopia in that interview. Whatever world we have today I don't believe he has ever referred to as cyberpunk-esque.
- markedathome 6y agohttps://www.theguardian.com/books/2020/jan/11/william-gibson-i-was-losing-a-sense-of-how-weird-the-real-world-was https://www.theguardian.com/books/2020/jan/11/william-gibson...
- yesbabyyes 6y agoIt's not exactly that, but about how Gibson has steadily gotten more and more near-future: "The ten novels that Gibson has written since have slid steadily closer to the present. In the nineties, he wrote a trilogy set in the two-thousands. The novels he published in 2003, 2007, and 2010 were set in the year before their publication. (Only the inevitable delays of the publishing process prevented them from taking place in the years when they were written.) Many works of literary fiction claim to be set in the present day. In fact, they take place in the recent past, conjuring a world that feels real because it’s familiar, and therefore out of date. Gibson’s strategy of extreme presentness reflects his belief that the current moment is itself science-fictional. “The future is already here,” he has said. “It’s just not very evenly distributed.” The further Gibson developed his present-tense sci-fi, the more mysterious and resonant his novels became. They seemed to reveal a world within the world: the real present. The approach was risky; it put him at the mercy of events. In 2001, Gibson rushed to incorporate the September 11th attacks into his half-completed eighth novel, “Pattern Recognition,” a story about globalization, filmmaking, Internet forums, brand strategy, and informational deluge. Terrorism turned out to fit neatly within this framework; “Pattern Recognition” is often described as the first post-9/11 novel. The risks could pay off." Also a great interview with the man. https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2019/12/16/how-william-gibson-keeps-his-science-fiction-real https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2019/12/16/how-william-gi...
- overcast 6y agoCyberpunk 2077 should change this.
- karpodiem 6y agoCyberpunk isn't dead - we're living it.
- bytematic 6y agoThe single most awaited game in history is about to release, titled "Cyberpunk 2077".
- yters 6y agothe only time i hear about this game is a few random people referring to it as the most awaited game in history
- hobofan 6y agoThen you should maybe step outside your filter bubble? The amount of merch and cosplays out there for Cyberpunk 2077 is unprecedented for an unreleased game as far as I can tell.
- Andrew_nenakhov 6y agoAfter the (disappointing) release of Duke Nukem Forever, the title of the single most awaited game in history was overtaken by Half-Life 3 (or, maybe, Half-Life 2: Episode Three).
- Insanity 6y agoYeah I would give HL this 'title'
- hobofan 6y agomost != longest I don't think a lot of people are still holding their breath for HL3, especially without any official acknowledgment of its development and the release of Half-Life:Alyx. HL2 was also so long ago (16 years) that most young adults don't even have a connection to it, as they didn't grow up with it.
- detaro 6y agoAny reason to assume it won't be just rewarmed clichés of the genre? (which could still make a fun game! - but probably not satisfy the discussion in the article)
- 6y ago
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoIt is an interesting take, but once you look beyond the obvious, the critique is reminiscent of "Nothing new under the sun" trope ( they phrase it as a minor insult -- Akira fan fic ). Not exactly compelling argument in my mind. Personally, I think interest in Cyberpunk may have declined ( and oddly increased in mainstream DND ), because, frankly, we seem to be living in early Cyberpunk universe ( powerful corporations, nascent augment technology.. ). edit: Then again, Cyber 2077 may re-ignite mainstream interest in the genre.
- toyg 6y agoI think we've been in "early cyberpunk" for about 15 years already (if not 20). The renewed interest, imho, is due to a combination of factors, but mostly two: the generation that grew up reading it as kids is now old enough to be in positions of power over artistic output, so they will use those influences in their own work; and some of the societal shifts cyberpunk speculated about, are now recognizable by pretty much everyone.
- Grimm1 6y agoI mean maybe in books, but Deus Ex and the remakes are as fresh as a few years ago now we have Cyberpunk 2077 coming out and Detroit Become Human is fantastic from a story setting. Not to forget The early 2000s telling of Ghost in the Shell and the the most recent ones from 2016ish to now. Less story inclined but just as cyber punk being the Watchdog games. Cyber Punk and it's ideals are very much alive, however the medium of expression has changed to ones more fitting of Cyber Punk IMO.
- jjoonathan 6y agoNot to mention, many cyberpunk ideas just became everyday life, from social networking and "always-connected" being the new normal, market dominance by technological megacorps, and cybercriminals scoring big payouts right down to minor terminology like hashtags and life hacks. The other day an ad for "Mom Hacks" played over the Walmart store intercom. It doesn't seem so long ago that my own mother warned me that normal people only understood the term "hack" to refer to cybercrime. Somewhere between then and now, ideas from our little corner of the world colonized the rest of it, and I don't think I realized how thoroughly it had happened until "Mom Hacks" made me reflect on it.
- Grimm1 6y agoRight exactly, we currently live in a world just shy of having Zaibatsus with their own paramilitary arms minus some of the flashier tech but still including many elements of the dystopias works from the 80's and 90's and even early 2000's were trying to warn us about.
- toyg 6y agoCertain stories about Apple coopting Bay Area police forces to track down their lost prototypes, would indicate that some zaibatsu already have, in practice, their paramilitary. And of course oil companies have had military-grade security basically forever.
- Grimm1 6y agoI'll also add in terms of the concerns of cliches, I mean the ethics and ideas in Cyberpunk have 40 years of discussion and mainstreaming now which means many people will wear the ideas of cyberpunk as an aesthetic and really not intern or create works that embody the ideology. The thing is this happens with every set of ideas and I refer back to this post as a good exploration of why "https://meaningness.com/geeks-mops-sociopaths" https://meaningness.com/geeks-mops-sociopaths" Unfortunately this means that if you do have a more vested interest in works that respect and extend classical cyber punk thoughts you have to work a little harder to separate wheat from chaff. A recent example of this is Ghost in the Shell SAC_2045 that revives characters and art from earlier more idealistic works that are much more in line with the ethos and work hard to make points about sociopolitical events and where they could lead us, but this iteration really falls short, in my opinion, of making any of it's own strong points. Instead they rely on the flashy tech, scenary and tropes we've come to be familiar with in Cyberpunk. Not to say they didn't try though but they couldn't carry it like previous writers in the series.
- donkey-hotei 6y agoKill Cyberpunk. Long Live Solarpunk
- dougmwne 6y agoAt it's best, sci-fi is a great canvas for social commentary. You can use present day concerns and take them out to their ultimate conclusions to highlight the risks and rewards of taking our society down a certain path. That also means sci-fi is very much a product of the time it was created. If cyberpunk is getting less relevant, it's only because our society's concerns have moved on from corporate skepticism to corporate embrace and from techno-fear to techno-love. The cyber tech itself has gone from new to mundane. The next anxieties will produce the next sci-fi.
- spiritplumber 6y agoIt happened.
- bugaku 6y agoThe unlimited price nearest to truth was set by Amazon CEO's private life hack with geopolitical implications. Was this ever imagined before in a plot line?
- currymj 6y agoThe book "Void Star" is an interesting one. It has a William Gibson style plot very similar to Neuromancer but instead of 1980s aesthetic choices, it has 2017 aesthetic choices. So instead of ninjas you get MMA jiu jitsu guys, US tech mega corporations are dominant rather than Japan, aftereffects of climate change rather than nuclear disasters, cartels rather than Yakuza, and so on. It's like 2017 future is extrapolated out instead of 1984 future. But the plot is extremely Gibson-esque: a woman hired as a consultant on a strange project for a mysterious ultra-wealthy client, rogue AIs, interactions between mega corporations and the criminal underworld. So if you take cyberpunk to mean just the synthesizers and neon and chrome aesthetic, then it is getting sort of tiresome. But you can update all that stuff to something slightly fresher and still tell the same kind of stories and it works.
- toyg 6y agoWell, put it like that, you could probably swap a few terms (feudal lords for corporations, bandit guilds for cartels, etc etc) and tell "the same kind of story" as Fantasy. I do agree that some (well, most) of the cyberpunk themes are still very much alive though.
- nip180 6y agoYou could, but ultimately it would be harder. In cyperpunk nature is almost never a character or force, but in fantasy words it often is. Cyperpunk aesthetic is also largely about how today’s technology might change the world as it develops. It would be very hard to tell that story in fantasy.
- theptip 6y ago> It would be very hard to tell that story in fantasy. Perhaps Steampunk is closer to this, given that "steam" was part of the first industrial revolution. However there are some interesting ideas floating around that you could use to tell a pure-Fantasy cyberpunk story; I'm sure someone's tried a novel, but I am only familiar with the tabletop RPG http://cryptorpg.com/ http://cryptorpg.com/, where magic enables cryptography and messaging. From there you can recapitulate pretty much all of the dystopian power/narrative structures that make Cyberpunk what it is. Magic-as-technology is a surprisingly under-explored concept, with the right magic system I think you could easily tell a Cyberpunk story.
- spiritplumber 6y agoPolite reminder that the original Cyberpunk RPG took place in 2013.
- nine_k 6y agoCyberpunk is sort of what we're living through now. It's like being the proverbial fish who does not notice the water around.
- PedroBatista 6y agoPart of it became the news, other part became so overplayed it became cheesy and the rest was always cheese to begin with. This happens all the time, Cyberpunk is not above the "laws" of time.
- shmerl 6y ago> I would dearly love to see a new form of SF emerge that reflects the baseline of now, and begins a whole new series of extrapolations that creates a new consensual vision of a different future. I think VirtuaVerse does it pretty well. It has that classic cyberpunk style, but it explores very contemporary ideas. I.e. it's not stuck in the '80s. See: * https://www.gog.com/game/virtuaverse https://www.gog.com/game/virtuaverse * https://masterbootrecord.bandcamp.com/album/virtuaverse-ost https://masterbootrecord.bandcamp.com/album/virtuaverse-ost
- canistr 6y agoIt's been replaced by whatever genre you would describe Black Mirror as. A reflection of the modern dystopia we live in within the context of the current year.
- toyg 6y agoI agree that Black Mirror is one of the few original attempts at doing proper scifi about the near future, that we’ve had in quite some time. I wish it were not so utterly depressing, my mental health can barely stomach a single episode every month or so. If that were a genre, I would call it “cybercynical”.
- cletus 6y agoA couple of things: 1. I wouldn't call The Matrix cyberpunk. That's the first time I heard that; and 2. I don't see cyberpunk as having died in the 1980s, so much as it was simply the zeitgeist of that era and there have been lots of those in sci-fi (and more generally). For example, if you look at sci-fi from the 1960s you have lots of material about mental powers (eg telepathy in Stranger and a Strange Land). Star Trek was a utopia that mirrored a rosy view of America. All of this in an era of personal freedom and society wrestling with the lingering injustices of slavery a century earlier I think is no accident. What happened in the 1980s was the rise of Japan and the loss of manufacturing jobs in America. This stoked fears that corporations would replace governments and we'd face a dystopian but technological future. I still see cyberpunk as interlinked with anti-Japanese xenophobia. So the issue with cyberpunk is that this xenophobia faded, the genre didn't really evolve (and probably peaked with Blade Runner) and apart from the Internet virtually nothing predicted in cyberpunk came to pass. We still have governments. We don't live in a dystopian future (mostly). There are enhanced humans with implants. But I wouldn't describe it as dying. We simply moved on.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- coolgeek 6y ago> I wouldn't call The Matrix cyberpunk Why do you say that? Also, cyberpunk broke into the mainstream (Blade Runner, Neuromancer) at a time of fascination with Japan. I say fascination because there was a spectrum - from philic to phobic. That attention was, of course, a result of their (at the time) massively increased economic strength, relative to that of the USA. That same spectrum of attention exists in the body of cyberpunk, in toto. There is not an anti-Japanese xenophobia that exists in the corpus either pervasively, or inherently.
- mancerayder 6y agoA friend said a line that I have been stealing: "The way things are going in the world, by the time Cyberpunk 2077 comes out it'll be redundant."
- tus88 6y agoNo it is not.
- bitwize 6y agoI've lost track of how many times cyberpunk has died and been resurrected with new cybernetic parts grafted onto its corpse.
- at_a_remove 6y ago"Everything about UNIX sounds silly. We're talking about an OS with commands like chown, awk, and grep here and where 'zombie children floating in the pipe' is a legitimate description of an error state." — Bruce Bethke — Headcrash
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- arthurjj 6y ago"A…depressingly mountainous amount of the self-identified cyberpunk fiction I see now is stuck firmly in the 1980s. It's not new, fresh, or original. It's paint-by-numbers Imitation Gibson. It's Blade Runner fan fic, or Akira fan fic, or worse, wannabe Shadowrun or Cyberpunk 2077 media tie-in fic" I read a large amount of new cyberpunk and this is depressingly accurate
- LoSboccacc 6y agofrom page 2: > Bruce: wannabe Shadowrun or Cyberpunk 2077 media tie-in fic. so yeah, basically an elitist point of view filled with "no true scotsman" kind of platitudes. that'd be like saying every fantasy sucks because it's just a lord of the ring tie in. > Bruce: I would dearly love to see a new form of SF emerge that reflects the baseline of now if only he was a writer. oh wait.
- m3kw9 6y agoCyberpunk 2077
- sarreph 6y agoNo, as per Betteridge's Law of Headlines[0]. [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headlines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headline...
- 627467 6y agoThis comment section is as rich as the article. Thank you hn'ers.
- toyg 6y agoCyberpunk is to the early internet generations what beat literature was to boomers.
- cyberpunk 6y agoNo need to panic guys, I'm still alive. And this Bruce guy hasn't even spoken to me -- so take his opinion with the appropriate amount of sodium chloride.
- diegoperini 6y agoMr Robot is the best cyberpunk story of the current generation.
- Animats 6y agoThe seminal "cyberpunk" novel is The Shockwave Rider by John Brunner, from 1975. He didn't use the term, but all the key themes are there.
- knolax 6y agoI'm gonna be honest, I only like cyberpunk for the aesthetics, not any of the themes. In 2020 most of the messaging behind the cyberpunk genre seems trite and obvious in hindsight (probably because of how accurate a lot of their social predictions were). I think most people agree that are into cyberpunk today are into it more for the neon signs than the social commentary.
- jackcosgrove 6y agoConsidering a teenager recently commandeered the Twitter accounts of a number of world leaders, and then used this awesome power to run a two-bit scam with electronic money, makes me think cyberpunk is indeed dead because it is now reality.
- justinclift 6y agoWith all the discussion so far, it's kind of strange no-one has pointed out modern "CyberPunk" bands like GUNSHIP. eg: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-nC5TBv3sfU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-nC5TBv3sfU - Tech Noir https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=60ruvzfXQoE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=60ruvzfXQoE - Dark All Day https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WQaH3lh-CA4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WQaH3lh-CA4 - Art3mis & Parzival. Pretty much a music clip for Ready Player One. They have tonnes more: https://www.youtube.com/user/GUNSHIPMUSIC/videos https://www.youtube.com/user/GUNSHIPMUSIC/videos Yeah, I'm a massive fan. :) If there's no GUNSHIP music in Cyberpunk 2077, something's definitely gone wrong. ;)