3 ms·
> For example, the recent standardisation of DNS-over-HTTPS (DoH) pitted advocates for dissidents and protestors against network operators who use DNS for centr
by xg15 6y ago
> For example, the recent standardisation of DNS-over-HTTPS (DoH) pitted advocates for dissidents and protestors against network operators who use DNS for centralised network management, and child safety advocates who promote DNS-based filtering solutions. If the IETF were to only decide upon technical merit, how would it balance these interests?
I neither like DoH nor in general arguments of the form "X is not political, we only decide on merits".
However, in this case, I really wonder if the IETF's contribution is political: DoH on it's own is highly so, but to my understanding, the politics are in the decision to design an encrypted, centralized and block-proof alternative to DNS with preselected servers and automatically deploy it to millions of users. But those points belong the initial requirements and the deployment process - not so much the technical details of implementation.
That DoH is a standard makes some difference, but not very much. I think we'd have roughly the same problems (though maybe with less publicity and discussion) if this was some properietary Chrome thing that was fully developed inside Google.
Or to put it differently, assuming it was already decided that something like DoH should be built, is there still political power in the follow-up discussions about how it should be built?
- ignoramous 6y ago> ...and child safety advocates who promote DNS-based filtering solutions. DoH doesn't prevent filtering. Sure, it doesn't respect OS or Network-enforced settings, but that's kind of the whole point of its existence. > ...DNS for centralised network management. DoT (and DNSCrypt?) would arguably be the better alternatives in these cases. So, use-cases are absolutely being addressed in DNS' case at the very least. > I really wonder if the IETF's contribution is political: DoH on it's own is highly so... I think DoH and ESNI are exactly the kind of response expected from a tech firm like Mozilla: Fight for its users and invest in the right technology that helps keep the Internet global despite the many efforts to dismantle it, not just by governments but by big tech in equal measure. In fact it is big tech that sells "cyber security" solutions to these governments in the first place: A trillion dollar market opportunity [0]. Look no further than ITU to see how anti-user, pro-corporate, pro-government politically-influenced technology standards can be [1]. Things might take a steep dive given Google's [2] and Facebook's [3] recent inroads in the Communications industry. This pro-user political engagement from Mozilla et al is more than welcome, in my opinion. [0] https://foundationcapital.com/cybersecurity-the-next-trillion-dollar-market/ https://foundationcapital.com/cybersecurity-the-next-trillio... [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23416269 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23416269 [2] https://www.opennetworking.org/ https://www.opennetworking.org/ [3] https://telecominfraproject.com/ https://telecominfraproject.com/