7 ms·
I’m curious whether Apple’s conduct here would be illegal in Australia—I suspect it might be, and believe it should be. Credit card networks used to tell busin
by chrismorgan 6y ago
I’m curious whether Apple’s conduct here would be illegal in Australia—I suspect it might be, and believe it should be.
Credit card networks used to tell businesses “you’re not allowed to itemise or pass this fee on to your customers”; at some point (maybe 10–15 years ago? Can’t find a reference quickly) this was confirmed to be illegal in Australia: businesses are allowed to apply a surcharge to cover their transaction costs (and nothing more, though in practice I think many businesses just apply a flat rate like 1–2% which will be higher than their costs for some transactions), per https://www.accc.gov.au/consumers/prices-surcharges-receipts/credit-debit-prepaid-card-surcharges https://www.accc.gov.au/consumers/prices-surcharges-receipts....
The relevant legislation only applies to certain payment methods, so it would probably not be directly applicable to Apple’s 30% tax, though perhaps other legislation might protect your ability to at least itemise it (I don’t know); but given that the payment are probably ultimately coming from such payment networks, I wonder whether Apple could become subject to this rule to at least some extent, so that e.g. they had to let you split out the card transaction fees from the rest of their 30% cut and itemise and charge it. (And the purpose of doing that would be to begin pushing them to reduce their absurd 30% tax. Thinking of that, I wonder how many people have complained to ACCC about the 30% tax—it can’t be zero—and why they haven’t come down on Apple like a ton of bricks yet, because what they’re doing is basically the same as what credit card networks did, only 20–50× as greedy and infinitely more anticompetitive since no alternative is permitted on Apple’s platform, whereas credit cards had cash and cheques as alternatives.)
- PeterStuer 6y agoIt was the same over here in Belgium when electronic payment terminals were introduced in shops. The contracts stipulated that the extreme fees (up to 10% at start) could not be passed onto the customer, so all the shop owners could do was spread them over all sales (or swallow them) making everyone pay for this new platform whether you used it or not. Of course customers demanded the convenience of paying with cards, and since the bill could not be itemized, shopkeepers had a hard time explaining the ramifications to the customers.
- jagged-chisel 6y agoThe logic here concerns me. You just go up on your prices. Yes, for everyone. It’s not like they itemize “cost of chips from FritoLay, cost of shelf space for the three days the bag has been here, cost of electricity to keep the bag comfy for three days, cost of employees staffing the store for three days, the owner’s profit margin...” You can certainly “pass the costs on to the customer,” but what the card companies wanted to avoid was a line item resulting in a higher price for card users. These rules were legally stricken in my US state years ago. But businesses understand no one has a appetite for seeing that they’re paying more with plastic, so they just go up on prices. The only exception I’m aware of is gas stations who advertise their per gallon price ad cash only and the a smaller, more costly price for credit cards, on the same sign.
- StavrosK 6y agoNone of the costs you mentioned relate directly to a customer's choice at checkout in the way a credit card does. If the supermarket provided a "home delivery" service it would be absurd to expect them to amortize it over everyone who doesn't use home delivery so I could get it for "free".
- chrismorgan 6y agoYou say it’s absurd, but that’s exactly what happens. In Australia, the two biggest supermarkets, Woolworths and Coles, do provide free delivery if you buy more than $300 and $200 (respectively), with Woolworths’ delivery fee going down by $3 for every full $50 you spend after $50. So yes, they’ve masked the fact that everyone’s subsidising delivery by only offering it to you when you’ve bought a whole lot of stuff from them, but if you’re buying online at the same prices as you’d get in-store (I confess this is the weak spot in my argument, I don’t actually know for sure that prices are the same, I’ve never bought from a supermarket online), everyone is subsidising the deliveries, even if the threshold has made it a smaller subsidy. Edit: on reflection, I guess it’s also possible that the fees from the small deliveries are sufficient to fully subsidise the bigger deliveries, and that regular shoppers aren’t subsidising anything. But this wouldn’t hold for any businesses that offer unconditional “free shipping” while also allowing you to pick up or buy in-store. Edit: it is also possible that it may not need a subsidy at all. You view delivery as the luxury, but remember that stores cost money too. There's a reason some stores have gone online-only or online-primarily.
- RandoHolmes 6y agoI agree that it's irrelevant information. You can argue that maybe it's unfair to FB, but you know what's even more unfair? Consumers being caught in the middle of a fight between Apple and FB. Consumers being manipulated so big tech corp A can try and force a behavior change by big tech corp B by pissing off its customers. At the end of the day it's a phone that you call people on. Let the people who have purchased that phone be.
- summitsummit 6y ago> At the end of the day it's a phone that you call people on. this is certainly no longer the case
- RandoHolmes 6y agoYou don't use your phone for phone calls? That seems like a strange use for a phone...
- metiscus 6y agoI think you are missing the point. Yes a smartphone is a phone but it has become integrated into people's lives as much more than that.
- RandoHolmes 6y agoSo your argument is that because people really really really like their smartphones, FB should be able to tell everyone that Apple is charging them money? Non-Sequitur if I've ever seen one.
- ashwoods 6y agoI think the point is that even though it is called a phone, it is actually a portable super computer, and in many cases the only one people have. We can’t pretend it is only a device we use to call other people, it is the gateway to our digital lives. From banking, access to government services, to connecting to our loved ones and leisure.
- donavanm 6y ago> in practice I think many businesses just apply a flat rate like 1–2% which will be higher than their costs for some transactions Have you ever seen an itemized transaction cost of 5¢ + 1-2% of total? Living in Sydney I never have. Literally every time it’s a written note on the till or verbally after they ring you up; “$5 minimum on card” or “50¢ charge” is always the pattern. The rapid and endemic noncompliance, and fleecing of consumers, seems to be what happens when you have “deregulation” and literally no enforcement of behaviors.
- chrismorgan 6y agoI’ve seen fixed amount (e.g. 50¢) and fixed percentage rates (e.g. 0.8% for Visa/Mastercard, 2.5% for Amex). I haven’t ever seen actual cost-based calculations offline, but I suspect I may have online, just once or so. What I was quoting was the letter of the law, which is, I suspect, regularly violated. As a society we just let it slide, because we understand roughly what’s being done and why, and know that the differences are slight. But if it was presented as a percentage and was over 2% for Visa/Mastercard, I imagine some would start asking questions, because that’s more than one would expect.
- username90 6y agoI am pretty sure it is illegal according to EU law as well. For example, the 30% fees almost surely breaks this law which was made to break up abusive rent seeking like credit card taxes and now app store taxes: > Any abuse by one or more undertakings of a dominant position ... directly or indirectly imposing unfair purchase or selling prices or other unfair trading conditions; https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:12008E102&from=ES https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CEL...
- inopinatus 6y agoI’m modestly familiar with the principles at stake since I run a two-sided Australian marketplace. Essentially it is unlawful to display a price that excludes hidden mandatory extras or is otherwise greater than the actual price a consumer will pay, and also unlawful to surcharge for card transactions above either your blended cost of doing so or actual cost on a per-transaction basis (the controls are scoped particularly to Visa and Mastercard, Amex has a bit more latitude). The ACCC loves prosecuting these cases and has scored many judgments against major brands on that basis. However, there is no requirement to itemise your price components, including those that are effectively surcharges for a given channel (as opposed to card scheme), nor is it illegal to simply be expensive, or to have market power, so Apple may well within those rules believe it can coerce merchants on its platform. The wheels are more likely to come off in other areas of the ACL, particularly those related to misuse of market power, unfair contract terms, and unconscionable conduct intended to mislead the consumer or distort a marketplace. These are rather more subjective and harder to prosecute since no absolute test applies; if anything it is Apple’s sheer scale and documented arrogance that might bring them into play.