3 ms·
> Inflation happens when people decide to spend and the supply isn't there to support it This is what happens in case of “market equilibrium in perfect competi
by littlestymaar 6y ago
> Inflation happens when people decide to spend and the supply isn't there to support it
This is what happens in case of “market equilibrium in perfect competiton”, not IRL because supply is almost unlimited in practice for the US for manufactured goods (because most things are imported, and paid in USD).
In practice, inflation happens when retailers decide to raise their prices! It can either be because they must do it (because international currency price variation for instance, or oil market price) or because they see an opportunity to make profits by doing so.
- WalterBright 6y agoOr because their expenses rise.
- littlestymaar 6y agoYes, that's what I meant when I said “because they must do”.
- skybrian 6y agoIt should be obvious to anyone paying attention during the early days of the pandemic that supply is not unlimited in the short run. Many supply chains are optimized for efficiency assuming that demand will follow projections. If consumers change behavior all at once, it causes immediate shortages. Imports aren't magic. You will at least have to wait for cargo ships to cross the ocean (unless air freight makes sense). For mask manufacturing there were lots of other bottlenecks. Of course in the longer run (months or years), things are different, but it still takes time to ramp up, and how long it will take isn't something you can answer in the abstract, using armchair reasoning.
- littlestymaar 6y agoAll you say is true, but you are talking about an extreme event in the order of magnitude of a war. But inflation has happened all the time in history and isn't caused by such events. If you look at two hundred years of US history, you won't explain inflation back shortage of supply.
- skybrian 6y agoInflation is an average across many prices. Individual prices do often go up and down all the time due to changes in supply, in lots of different markets. An everyday example is that fruit is cheaper in season. Also, oil prices are certainly affected by changes in the supply of oil, for example when OPEC gets it together to agree to cut supply, or when the cartel fails and they start selling more oil again. History is complicated with lots of different effects, but saying that supply has nothing to do with price changes means you aren't paying attention.
- littlestymaar 6y ago> in everyday example is that fruit is cheaper in season You know that inflation is seasonally adjusted right? > Also, oil prices are certainly affected by changes in the supply of oil […] but saying that supply has nothing to do with price changes Ok fair, my sentence was a bit unclear, but I was reacting to this: > Inflation happens when people decide to spend and the supply isn't there to support it So what I meant when I said ”you won't explain inflation with [there was a typo here btw] shortage of supply” was more precisely: “inflation is almost never caused by fixed supply + increasing demand” (which was the initial point I was responding to)
- skybrian 6y agoOkay. When I said that inflation happens when people want to spend and supply isn't there to support it, that could also be due to a collapse in supply, and high inflation does seem to be associated with that, for example in Venezuela and in countries suffering under trade sanctions. But I'm not sure I want to defend any particular theory of what usually causes inflation. My main point was that inflation (rising average prices) doesn't seem to be inevitable with increased money supply, as simple theories will have it. I don't know if you want to continue talking, but I'm curious about something: you seem to be pretty certain you know what has usually caused inflation in US history, but you haven't said what what you think about that?