4 ms·
I'm baffled by people put off by the name. Is 'rapier' not a word used in US English? It's a type of sword. It's nothing to do with 'rape' if that's what you'r
by chrisseaton 6y ago
I'm baffled by people put off by the name.
Is 'rapier' not a word used in US English? It's a type of sword. It's nothing to do with 'rape' if that's what you're thinking. It's neither spelt nor pronounced anything like 'rape'. I can't see any possible confusion or connection at all but several people are making it in this thread.
- p1necone 6y agoI'm also confused. Perhaps it's more commonly used in EU/Australian/New Zealand English? But even then I don't think so - that type of sword is called that in US made video games too.
- nomadtwin 6y agoThere's more to the world then US. English is the common tech language that almost everyone on HN is capable reading but not always fluent or mothertongue. I don't think "rapier" is a common word for non-native speakers.
- Mirioron 6y agoIf they at all play fantasy games (video or otherwise) or read fantasy or historical novels then they've run across this word.
- nkozyra 6y agoIt's not commonly used. I'd imagine most people know it but for those that don't I could understand the confusion and concern. I know the word and its meaning and my initial reaction was negative because I thought "this has very little metaphorical value for a physics engine." You think of kinesis, movement, reactions. "Box" makes sense because it's a physical constraint with coming and interesting physics effects across its physics. Rapier is - to me - just an inanimate object. But imagine you don't know the word. It could be jarring. And unlike words evoked by a sibling reply (paper, rap, etc) it's not nearly as commonly known or used.
- geitir 6y agoSorry but it's even more insulting to expect someone to cater to a person's ignorance
- nkozyra 6y agoI'm certainly not asking anyone to change it just showing why for some people it might be off-putting.
- qchris 6y agoI think your use of 'jarring' is appropriate. There's nothing that's actually wrong with the word--it's type of sword, we're all fine. On the other hand, that may not be worth the risk, compared to other words in a similar vein: scimitar or falchion or something. Either way, this is a super cool project. You have to love it when someone puts their mind to it and produces something of this quality as open-source. I'm especially interested to see if this might kickstart some of the Rust efforts around GPGPU, which is currently so-so, since a cross-platform solution there seems like it would definitely be a benefit for this kind of project.
- cfcosta 6y agoLet me see if I understand. A french author should be careful about using this french word on its project because, if someone in the US mispronounce it, it sounds like something that's reprehensible? I hope I'm not misrepresenting your argument, but the way I understood it sounds very US-centered.
- nkozyra 6y agoAgain I'm neither admonishing nor prescribing anything. This sort of thing happens sometimes (see: Ford Pinto)
- forgot_account 6y ago>>>I know the word and its meaning and my initial reaction was negative because I thought "this has very little metaphorical value for a physics engine." You think of kinesis, movement, reactions.... Rapier is - to me - just an inanimate object. I looked at is as implying lightweight, nimble, and functional efficiency for small-scale uses, much like its namesake. I would assign much different metaphorical implications to something named "Zweihander" (Germanic two-handed sword) or an even more esoteric French polearm name such as "Bec de corbin" (a name probably only known to hoplophiles). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9qJBGlChcXU?t=546 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9qJBGlChcXU?t=546 https://myarmoury.com/othr_aa_bec.html https://myarmoury.com/othr_aa_bec.html
- jbay808 6y agoI wonder whether the division falls along the lines of people who have vs. have not played D&D.
- dllthomas 6y agoOn the one hand, I find myself surprised that a sizeable number of people seem to reach that association. On the other hand, as a native English speaker, I understand the word to be pronounced such that it isn't much of a stretch to put it between "rapey" and "rapiest". While neither of those is, I think, particularly well established as a word in "proper" English, they are understood and used in less formal contexts (if jocularly). I don't know where all of this leaves us.