5 ms·
One example that complicates things is the Floatplane [1] application, where each channel costs a certain fee per month. The app doesn't do anything other than
by jeroenhd 6y ago
One example that complicates things is the Floatplane [1] application, where each channel costs a certain fee per month. The app doesn't do anything other than play videos from the subscribed videos. Because they wouldn't increase their price 30% to reflect the additional Apple fees, every single feature that even mentions the presence of a website that you can pay for a subscription at (including help pages!) have so far had to be removed [2].
The "core app experience" of Floatplane is "you get to watch videos in high quality" and "you get to chat during live streams". Their app is an amalgamation of Patreon and the Youtube video player, both of which are on the App Store already.
I don't know why buying video access would be so different from making ads show up. Both are purely digital services. There's probably some vague notion of "consumption" that determines if the fee is mandatory or not, but the rules are as vague as they are arbitrary when you get down to that level.
It's clear that the actual rule is "we can make a deal if you're big enough". Apps like Uber have gotten warnings for pulling stunts that smaller developers would get their dev account banned for. Adding 30% on top of Facebook would kill the feature on iOS and subsequently kill iPhone presence among marketeers.
[1]: https://www.floatplane.com/ https://www.floatplane.com/
[2]: https://youtu.be/Rs4hTm6B9QQ?t=368 https://youtu.be/Rs4hTm6B9QQ?t=368
- gruez 6y agoIsn't there an exception for "reader" and streaming aps?
- jeroenhd 6y agoI don't think so? I believe Netflix removed the option to sign up from iOS, so I don't think there's an exemption from the fees there.
- tsimionescu 6y agoThere is an exemption for another rule - only streaming apps are allowed to offer no functionality until you pay outside the app. If you install the Netflix app, you'll be hit with a login screen and no way to proceed until you go online, create an account, and pay. However, if you were to make a game that had the same UI, it would be refused access to the store - apps must have some level of functionality without requiring a purchase outside the app, except if they are in the 'reader' category.
- Keyframe 6y agoI wonder how they would interpret something like Geforce Now on an ios then?
- kllrnohj 6y agoThere's a reason none of the game streaming services are currently on iOS: https://9to5mac.com/2020/03/25/app-store-game-streaming-rules/ https://9to5mac.com/2020/03/25/app-store-game-streaming-rule... & https://www.theverge.com/2020/8/5/21356274/microsoft-xcloud-ios-apple-iphone-ipad-testing-ends-apple-app-store-policies https://www.theverge.com/2020/8/5/21356274/microsoft-xcloud-... The policy as is exists to allow Apple Arcade to fit the rules, and basically nobody else.
- adoxyz 6y agoApple doesn't allow Game Streaming apps on their platform for some odd reason so things like GeForce Now, xCloud, Stadia, are all barred because...no real reason that's not hypocritical.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- JohnTHaller 6y agoIn another anti-competitive move, Apple has banned all game streaming service (with the phony-sounding reason of 'we have to review all the games' when they don't review movies from streaming apps) while they prep their own game streaming service.
- jessaustin 6y agoHaha that's truly brazen. One hopes a court of law will have an opportunity to consider this maneuver...
- zimpenfish 6y ago> with the phony-sounding reason of 'we have to review all the games' when they don't review movies from streaming apps How many headlines have you seen about parents getting a huge credit card bill from their kids going wild in a video streaming app? The games market is predatory enough on iOS with reviews without being able to push down whatever unreviewed pay-to-win, lootbox, "hit the lever!" garbage people like Epic, EA, and Ubisoft churn out. I shudder to think what it'd be like with the floodgates opened.
- ummonk 6y agoYou’re not buying an ad for yourself to view. You’re making a purchase to a service that just happens to show ads to others. In contrast from what you’re describing floatplane purchases are for subscriptions that will show up directly in the app.
- hbosch 6y agoOr, you can look at this post on Daring Fireball about how "premium streaming" apps are allowed to bypass this IAP restriction: https://daringfireball.net/2020/04/amazon_apple_prime_video https://daringfireball.net/2020/04/amazon_apple_prime_video Quote: "Apple has an established program for premium subscription video entertainment providers to offer a variety of customer benefits — including integration with the Apple TV app, AirPlay 2 support, tvOS apps, universal search, Siri support and, where applicable, single or zero sign-on. On qualifying premium video entertainment apps such as Prime Video, Altice One and Canal+, customers have the option to buy or rent movies and TV shows using the payment method tied to their existing video subscription."
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jeroenhd 6y agoThat doesn't clarify anything. What's a "premium" streaming app? Why doesn't (or didn't) Spotify, who publicly opposes the 30% cut, qualify? No official source qualifies and the article you linked just guesses based on screenshots. It also tells you that Apple does take the 30% cut if you trick the user into not realizing there's an Apple tax. The video I linked (I know, it's long) discusses limitations as decreed by Apple itself. There's another video on that channel with even more in-depth information from Apple. There's no offer to make a deal and become a "premium service". I'm sure these guys would love to get their app available on more platforms, providing more value than they already can with just smartphone apps.
- thawaway1837 6y agoPremium = Too large to be bullied by Apple
- stefan_ 6y agoOr you know, the other pillar of anti-competitive business practices, if Apple still needs their goodwill in some other vertical of theirs.
- dmix 6y agoI'm confused by one thing, are the guys in the [2] video publishers in the Floatplane app or the creators of the app itself?
- jeroenhd 6y agoThe guy on the left (Linus Sebastian) is the CEO of both Floatplane (the app) and Linus Media Group (known on the internet from their Linus Tech Tips tech enthusiast videos). The guy on the right is the Floatplane team lead. Linus Media Group made an alternative to Youtube to not put all of their eggs in one basket, that's what eventually became Floatplane. There's more creators on there, basically all in the tech Youtube space, but they do extensively use their own streaming platform of course.
- judge2020 6y agoTechnically and legally no since Flotplane doesn't make videos. Floatplane 'rents' office space from Linus Tech Tips, so many employees were previously at LTT and thus they work closely together, but they're different companies and LTT is just a creator on the app.
- strogonoff 6y agoSpeaking of Floatplane, can anyone get it to show up in results on DuckDuckGo? I can’t, and that includes directly searching for “floatplane.com”. It’s as if it has been blacklisted.
- Darkphibre 6y agohttps://duckduckgo.com/?q=site%3A+%22floatplane.com%22&t=h_&ia=web https://duckduckgo.com/?q=site%3A+%22floatplane.com%22&t=h_&... That shows they've indexed three results from the domain. Maybe they rejected ddg trawlers?
- strogonoff 6y agoYes, I only get secondary results like their status page with no links to site itself.