5 ms·
The dividing line is digital versus non-digital content. That's why you can order physical goods from Amazon's app, but not digital content. It's not about enri
by gnicholas 6y ago
The dividing line is digital versus non-digital content. That's why you can order physical goods from Amazon's app, but not digital content. It's not about enriching the core app experience; if it were, you could buy a video from the Amazon app, which doesn't enrich the core app experience of that app (you watch videos in the Prime Video app, which is separate).
- mrtksn 6y ago> The dividing line is digital versus non-digital content Content that’s consumed on the device to be more precise. You can sell domains and hosting etc. using alternative payment methods. For example I use namecheap’s App to buy domains and I would use CC to do so.
- tsimionescu 6y agoSo are Instagram ads not 'digital content'?
- josephduffy 6y agoIt's a blurry line since the content isn't consumed in the app, but you can buy digital codes for games (such as Nintendo Switch games) in the Amazon app.
- ummonk 6y agoIn that case you’re purchasing something that enhances the prime video app. Just because you split the app into two parts - a viewing app and a purchasing app - doesn’t mean the criteria shouldn’t apply.
- ehsankia 6y agoI'm curious, are e-books charged 30% cut? What if you buy a book, but it also comes with a free ebook? There's just so many edge cases and weird exceptions. I really don't see how this models of theirs can scale.
- gnicholas 6y agoI think you could sell ebooks if you were willing to part with 30% of the revenue. Physical books that come with ebook access, or DVD/Blu-Ray that comes with digital access are treated as physical purchases, I believe. My guess would be that the rule is that there's no Apple cut if you're selling a physical thing and there's a digital attachment. But Apple probably reserves the right to disregard sham physical transactions, where the physical item is de minimis in value compared to the digital item.
- j2bax 6y agoYou can actually purchase digital content in the Prime Video app now (with your Amazon payment info). Hard to know exactly what Apple/Amazon's deal is on that. You used to have to go to the browser to purchase movies/shows. https://www.theverge.com/2020/4/1/21203294/amazon-prime-video-ios-in-app-purchases-iphone-ipad-apple-tv-change https://www.theverge.com/2020/4/1/21203294/amazon-prime-vide...
- im3w1l 6y agoThe real line is that Apple claims what they can. If Apple tried to claim 30% off furniture no one would shop for furniture on the phone. If they tried to claim 30% from ride sharing, people would get pissed off enough to switch to Android. So why not ads then? Well Apple doesn't have insight into the ad spending, and they are not a middle man to the cash transfer. They could try to force themselves into that position, say "if you want to have ads in your app, you have to use our SDK for that". But if they tried such a stunt, then Google and Facebook, would become very powerful very motivated enemies.
- rahilb 6y agoI can deposit into my pokerstars account, to upgrade my app experience to play with real money; I’m assuming Apple are not taking a cut as this would make the iOS app unprofitable for pokerstars. Interestingly they also allow you to deposit with Apple Pay (along with many other payment processors, which the user can choose).