3 ms·
This is a bit tangential, but I wanted to mention how the (GPL'ed) ardour project decided to view github. We got burned by the SourceForge apocalypse back in t
by PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago
This is a bit tangential, but I wanted to mention how the (GPL'ed) ardour project decided to view github.
We got burned by the SourceForge apocalypse back in the mid-2000's, which led to me (the BDFL) declaring that the project would never use a 3rd party host for our source code repository ever again. Granting a 3rd party the level of control that SF had (and then abused) is a non-starter for us. This means that github was never an option for us.
.... as the canonical repository.
However, we recognized the value of the tools that github offered, particularly allowing random 3rd party developers to create patches in quite effective ways. Some of the their other tools are useful, too.
So, we self-host a gitlab instance at ardour.org, and that acts as our canonical repository, but we use hooks to push all commits to the github version automatically. Random 3rd parties can use any and all of the github toolset with our code (as can we), but we have no reliance on github in any important way. We don't even have much reliance on gitlab either - it exists only to provide access roles and account management on top of the bare git server. We don't use any of gitlab's "features" either.
After about 5 years, this continues to work well for us.