3 ms·
It’s not FEMA’s job to reduce physical damage. That’s what building codes etc are for. FEMA’s job is to coordinate responses to save lives in the short term a
by Retric 6y ago
It’s not FEMA’s job to reduce physical damage. That’s what building codes etc are for. FEMA’s job is to coordinate responses to save lives in the short term and rebuild infrastructure in the long term. Hurricanes do a lot of damage, but rarely kill people in the US.
- coldcode 6y agoTell that to the people who died in New Orleans in Katrina due to ACOE's terrible levees.
- jjcon 6y agoJust because people have died in a natural disaster doesn’t make it FEMAs job to prevent building damage. Not sure what you’re getting at
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoI believe that coldcode is pushing back on Retric's statement that hurricanes rarely kill people in the US. But, OK, coldcode found a counterexample. That doesn't make "rarely" untrue, no matter how much we all remember the counterexample.
- thatcat 6y agoRarity is relative to the comparison, is it rare compared to terror deaths?
- jcranmer 6y agoHurricane Florence alone killed more people in the US than any terrorist attack since 9/11. All hurricane deaths in Trump's term alone (predominantly Florence, Harvey, Irma), excluding Maria, have killed more people than all terrorism attacks since 9/11 combined. Hurricane Maria killed more than 9/11.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Retric 6y agoIf you’re looking at the excess deaths after Maria then you need to do the same thing for 9/11. By one estimate 221 policemen died as a result of medical issues from 9/11 which don’t make the official figures based on initial deaths. Dust inhalation etc very much killed people only indirectly involved on 9/11. Thus, any kind of apples to apples comparison of either direct or direct + indirect deaths put 9/11 as a significantly more deadly event. PS: Also that extrapolation on death rates for Maria is extremely questionable as it’s been rising in Porto Rico for years. The increase from 2013 to 2014 is larger than the increase for 2016 to either 2017 or 2018. https://www.statista.com/statistics/580903/death-rate-in-puerto-rico/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/580903/death-rate-in-pue... You can assume the only thing bad that happened was a hurricane, but the data really doesn’t support that.
- jcranmer 6y agoYou've lost sight of your own argument in the weeds of specific numbers here. The broader point I'm making is this: hurricanes in the SE US and the Caribbean are, to a large degree "expected" disasters. As such they can be planned for, and damage can be minimized. And, I believe what you want to say is that they aren't all that "bad" anymore because of proper disaster preparation. I would agree that hurricanes shouldn't be all that devastating in effect. But the data shows, quite convincingly IMHO, that we aren't doing as good as we could be doing in actually preparing for them.
- Retric 6y agoMy point has nothing to do with what we should be doing just what FEMA should be doing. They have a very important but also very specific role. Other organizations are supposed to prevent levees from overtopping, keep buildings standing, etc. FEMA is there for redundancy so that such instances are mitigated after the fact. When it comes to hurricanes that equates to selecting evacuation routes and locations to shelter the storm etc. If needed they may help create such shelters, but that stuff really seems to be working well. What happens after the storm is largely a question of how well other organizations have done their job. Aka what percentage of homes are habitable translates into how many people FEMA needs to find shelter for. However, that last bit is a real question. Do we ramp up FEMA’s ability to build temerity houses or reduce the need for such temporary houses? I think it’s clear FEMA could do a much better job in disaster aftermath, but for hurricanes I think that’s largely solving the wrong problem.
- egypturnash 6y agoThere are new FEMA grant programs for 2020 that will disburse $660 million in funding for what the agency calls “pre-disaster mitigation,” focusing on resiliency against flooding and the relocation of vulnerable communities. Last year, however, approximately 75% of FEMA’s total preparedness grants went to the programs with counter-terrorism links, according to the GAO report. -the article at hand