3 ms·
> I thought this was an uncontroversial fact everyone knew... Well, obviously not. > ...but a two-second search on drug-related crime would answer your questi
by gridlockd 6y ago
> I thought this was an uncontroversial fact everyone knew...
Well, obviously not.
> ...but a two-second search on drug-related crime would answer your question, with many links...
So, a minority of offenders claim they did their deed "because of drugs" and if drug legalization were to happen and we suppose that 100% of these candidates now stay on the good side of the law, we can expect, at the very best, a 30% reduction in crime.
That doesn't answer the question about career criminals. Let's say drugs are free, that's great, no more crime for drug money. What else do people want to buy with money they can't earn legally? What about status symbols like jewellery or sneakers? Don't you need these to be free too? But then how could they be status symbols?
I have no doubts that drug legalization will reduce some amount of crime that is tangentially related to drug use or trade. However, there's no clear correlation between drug prohibition and crime, some countries with very strict prohibition (Japan, Korea) are low on crime, others are high in crime (Phillipines).
I reiterate, if you have a bunch of gangsters and take away their most lucrative and (arguably) most benign stream of income, they need to move on to other venues. I'd rather have them sell weed and coke and maybe get into the occasional turf war, rather than having them double down on robberies and home invasions.
> Drug legalization is not about ending all crime, and nobody is saying it would, so I'm not sure why you keep saying this.
I'm not saying this.
> I'm not even sure what you're arguing here, but it seems to be that you think the drug trade only negatively affects drug users...
Read it again, maybe you'll figure it out. Drug trade mostly affects drug dealers, users and their peers.
Certainly you must recognize that there's a tradeoff here - legalization of all drugs would be a big experiment with lots of unknowns.