4 ms·
You write: "having the sufficient amount of flaggings suggests that hackers do not find this interesting". I think you have misread the dynamics. To start, mos
by eesmith 6y ago
You write: "having the sufficient amount of flaggings suggests that hackers do not find this interesting".
I think you have misread the dynamics. To start, most people don't flag something just because it's not interesting. I don't - do you?
The piece describes coordinated harassment against the author, by software developers.
How many people does it take to flag something on HN? How many people are involved in that coordinated harassment. Can you therefore conclude that the flagging is not part of that broader coordinated harassment? I ... don't think so.
This coordinated harassment is part of a larger subculture of harassment against women in tech. As an example, 13 years ago Kathy Sierra withdrew from online life due to harassment. Quoting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kathy_Sierra#Harassment_and_withdrawal_from_online_life https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kathy_Sierra#Harassment_and_wi... 'Scoble said "[W]henever I post a video of a female technologist there invariably are snide remarks about body parts and other things that simply wouldn't happen if the interviewee were a man."'.
As the piece points out, silence - and flagging is an attempt to silence - is one of many tactics used by harassers.
Given the context, you might therefore ask why "hackers do not find this interesting". Is it because a non-trivial number of hackers are sexist, and empathize with the harassment against women in tech, so flag in order to silence?
Or is it because hackers are tired of reading about how sexist the tech field is and want HN as their safe space? Or they feel powerless to change things so flagging is a way of sticking their head in the sand?
Or, really, you should rephrase the question entirely. Don't interpret flagging as a signal for interesting/not interesting, but see it as signal for "should not be on HN" - of which 'not interesting' is only a (small, IMO) part of it.
- waihtis 6y agoYou're completely right - I misworded the "interesting" part, when I did in fact mean "on-topic." However, I don't think it changes my ultimate point. All the same, an (assumedly) big enough populace decided this was not on topic. You make a number of good points, which I won't argue with, except this one: > Given the context, you might therefore ask why "hackers do not find this interesting". Is it because a non-trivial number of hackers are sexist, and empathize with the harassment against women in tech, so flag in order to silence? I you're forgetting a very significant populace of "I have a millions issues I could worry about at any given point and just cannot provide meaningful resources to worry about this specific one."
- eesmith 6y agoI don't flag topics just because I can't provide meaningful resources to it. Do you? Flagging may prevent others who might have those resources from contributing, yes? So flagging is not a neutral personal expression but a public negative expression, yes? I still believe the interesting question is why did a big enough population decided this was not on topic enough to flag it, rather than ignore it.
- waihtis 6y agoWell, I'm drifting way into the sea of armchair psychology here, but a part of "I don't have resources to care" also translates often to "I don't want to see anything related to this." Especially on the web, which tends to be fast-paced system 1 / reptile-brain media for many. Scroll, click, skim read, back, (not interesting topic - flag), f5, repeat.
- krapp 6y agoThere's an option to hide stories - it also hides comments for those stories on the new comments page. That's the appropriate action to take for stories one simply doesn't want to see, if one cannot muster the intestinal fortitude to simply ignore them and move on.