3 ms·
Why do astronomers own the skies? I don't remember when they got title to that property.
by pfdietz 6y ago
Why do astronomers own the skies? I don't remember when they got title to that property.
- altacc 6y agoConversely, why do the the satellite owners own the sky? Space is a shared resource. One use shouldn't infringe on another.
- pfdietz 6y agoSatellite owners don't own the skies, in the sense astronomers are trying to argue they do.
- knolax 6y agoAstronomers don't "own" the skies, the rest of humanity simply considers the benefits of astronomy to be higher than some satellite internet vanity project.
- pfdietz 6y agoWe can judge the value humanity places on astronomy by looking at how much money is allocated for it. I suspect it will come out less valuable, to humanity, than the service Starlink will provide.
- q3k 6y ago> We can judge the value humanity places on astronomy by looking at how much money is allocated for it. That is a very naive viewpoint.
- pfdietz 6y agoYes, I am sure astronomers believe in their hearts that whey they are doing is supremely important and valuable. But astronomers should also understand selection bias. Astronomers are inherently biased to believe highly of the value of what they are doing, or they would not be astronomers.
- knolax 6y agoElon Musk and some investors don't represent humanity. Hell I doubt even SpaceX values Starlink all that much, most employees I know say that it exists mostly as a filler payload during launches.
- badwolf 6y agoThe fact that they are doing tens of dedicated launches solely for Starlink says otherwise. Starlink is looking to be a multi-billion dollar business by itself.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoWhose whole point was a sustainable funding source for SpaceX R&D. In this sense, it's fair for SpaceX employees to consider it "filler payload", given that they have their sights set on Mars. And everyone else, astronomers included, will benefit from drastically cheaper access to space.
- gizmondo 6y agoA bit preposterous to speak on behalf of "the rest of humanity", don't you think?
- rimliu 6y agoI don't remember the sky being awarded to America either.
- tssva 6y agoI don't remember America claiming it was. The relevant international treaties are being followed. Also not all these companies are American. OneWeb is a UK company soon to be owned by the UK government and an Indian conglomerate. The satellites it launches are built in cooperation with Airbus, a European company.
- Turing_Machine 6y agoOther countries can, and do, put satellites up all the time.