5 ms·
I own a LG smart TV. Wary of those and other problems I never connected it to the net. I bought it because it cost only 50 Euros more than the dumb model and th
by pmontra 6y ago
I own a LG smart TV. Wary of those and other problems I never connected it to the net. I bought it because it cost only 50 Euros more than the dumb model and the display looked much better, which should be the main point of a TV.
If I really want to do smart things with my TV I attach something I control to one of its HDMI ports (phone, tablet, laptop, Raspberry.)
I'm not thrilled about the idea of TV sets with an embedded 5G SIM that I can't disable. Worse if they'll only work if online.
Edit: example of 5G and TV https://5g.co.uk/guides/5g-tv/ https://5g.co.uk/guides/5g-tv/
- narrowtux 6y agoI'm not holding my breath about the TV use-case of 5G. The ISPs will just make it too expensive to allow you to watch as much TV as you like.
- gruturo 6y agoThe embedded 5G won't be for movies, but for ads, telemetry and forced updates.
- TheRealDunkirk 6y agoWell, it looks like enough of us either can't figure out how to attach the TV to the internet, or just don't bother (like me) to the point that -- like with ad blockers -- TV manufacturers are routing around the problem. That they would subsidize a 5G cell connection in order to get direct access to your TV should be seriously concerning. But it won't be, and cries to Congress to block this sort of thing will be met with a big infusion of campaign contributions, and we'll just all have to live with it.
- toss1 6y agoOk, so if they are going to force upon us a subsidized 5G connection, what can we do to to hijack that connection & redirect it to some more useful - to the user - application? (Also good to know that the big telcos will be rolling out 5G universally so all those 5G-connected TVs will work in every rural location, even those with coverage from only obscure CLECs /sarc )
- lozenge 6y agoThe number of users who don't set up WiFi for their TV is not enough to warrant this.
- silon42 6y agoI did the same with my Samsungs... no internet/network. But in the new one, I can't even use it in a private LAN (for DLNA, ...)... without connecting online. Doesn't bother me too much (HDMI from PC is superior anyway), but it would be interesting to have a solution for occasional uses (like streaming from laptop, maybe phone).
- mark-r 6y agoMy TV has a PC on one HDMI input, and a Chromecast on another.
- dreamcompiler 6y agoAny TV that won't work offline I'd consider defective and I'd send it back.
- silon42 6y agoIt works, until I attempt to use "network" when it asks me to register online. Haven't done it, if it was mandatory it would go back as non-functional... Not sure what problems occur if you do it once but then disconnect from internet.
- orisho 6y agoYou can give it a shot and then do a factory reset if anything stops working.
- Fnoord 6y agoI needed an all-in-one solution for streaming (Netflix, Prime, Spotify, Jellyfin, ...) so I went with an Nvidia Shield Pro on the HDMI port. Any smart TV is a dumb TV for me. I'll make it "smart" myself, the old fashioned way, as you described. One downside of HDMI is max 60 FPS, so its limited for gaming and OKish for interactive (such as navigation through menu or simple browsing) yet should be adequate for any viewing.
- Retr0spectrum 6y ago60fps is not a limitation of HDMI. I have an LG OLED that has HDMI 2.1, which can do 4k120fps (at least). Unfortunately current-gen GPUs only support HDMI 2.0, so I am limited to 1440p120fps or 4k60fps for the time being.
- Fnoord 6y agoOK, it was a limitation of HDMI, and most devices still use that old HDMI standard, so practically it still is a limitation until the new HDMI versions are more common. On my monitors, I use DP whenever I can.
- mumblerino 6y agoNo it’s not. HDMI can do it, it’s the device that you pick that decided it won’t, by picking an older standard.
- Fnoord 6y agoApparently HDMI 2.1 which specification is from November 2017 can do it. My TV itself is even older than that, and a dumb TV doesn't need to be upgraded often. That's part of the purpose of a dumb TV; longevity. My MBPs from 2015 also don't support it, and Apple only recently released a decent replacement for these MBPs (given the keyboard issues in previous). My old monitor from ~2014, a BenQ, also does not support it. While I recently replaced it, it still works perfectly fine (it doesn't have FreeSync though), and achieves 144 Hz over DP.
- pbronez 6y agoYeah I made this same call. My LG Smart TV has advertisements in the menus and doesn’t have a particularly wide range of apps. So I got an Apple TV and disconnected the internet from the TV. Much better experience overall.
- mumblerino 6y agoWhat can you even do with an Apple TV without internet? Did you jailbreak it?
- kop316 6y agoI think they meant to say the TV is disconnected from the internet, but the Apple TV is connected.
- alex_anglin 6y agoYou can stream to it over Airplay.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gertrunde 6y agoThe part that surprises me the most with "Smart TVs", is how bad the non-smart functionality can be. It's like the 'smarter' the TV is, the slower the TV guide is.
- dreamcompiler 6y agoThere will be websites that describe how to disable 5G in TVs. In some cases this will be as easy as putting strips of metal tape on the back of the case. In others you'll have to open the case to remove the 5G module or antenna.
- Johnny555 6y agoI own a LG smart TV. Wary of those and other problems I never connected it to the net I own an LG TV and stopped installing updates for the same reason - each update seemed to make it slower. But the nags get increasingly urgent and my wife eventually installed it. So now I disconnected it entirely from the network and use a Roku for smart features.
- downrightmike 6y agoBurn out the 5g sim or chip