2 ms·
I was in Belarus earlier this year. The thing to understand about how that country works is that there are only two interdependent groups of people that hold we
by jillesvangurp 6y ago
I was in Belarus earlier this year. The thing to understand about how that country works is that there are only two interdependent groups of people that hold wealth: 1) the ruling elite that acquires their riches through nepotism, corruption, etc. Belarus is basically a kleptocracy. 2) the booming IT sector, which is now the primary export product of Belarus and employs a lot of people working in the vast outsourcing industry that serves big western companies. People doing that work earn pretty good salaries by Belarusian standards. There are hundreds of thousands of them and the sector tends to hover up anyone with relevant college degrees as there's little else to do. E.g. dentists or doctors earn comparatively little compared to that.
The problem the regime has is that anyone with a clue and IT skills is monetizing those skills in that sector as government jobs, including those in its vast security forces, don't pay a lot. So, they don't necessarily have a lot of in house competence implementing any kind of sophisticated blocking strategies. Anyone capable of implementing that could quadruple their salaries by jumping ship. The state telco company gets most of its revenues from the IT sector as well. So they don't have any incentive to shut down their core business. I'm guessing it's mostly Russia that helps them with the technical parts of that. Of course Russia and Putin are currently mildly annoyed with Lukashenko and are looking to grow their influence in Belarus a bit by letting him flail desperately for a while. So, they are a bit hands off right now and not in a mood to help him out.
The second problem is that group #1 is basically tapping into the wealth generated by group #2. So shutting down the internet is a spectacularly bad idea for #2 for obvious reasons and therefore not a popular notion for #1 either. The people who would be at all capable of effecting such a change are mostly working in the IT sector already and the elite in group #1 kind of needs them to keep on doing their thing so the money keeps flowing. Besides, rich people need their internet fix and Lukashenko is considered a bit of an old relic by both groups. A convenient stooge at best.
Hence internet shutdowns tend to be short lived, ineffective, and largely symbolic. Telegram is important for both groups and completely outside of the control of Belarusian authorities. It's the same reason the Russians have failed to shut that down. They can't do it without cutting off the IT sector and the financial gains coming from that sector and none of the billionaires that make up the elite like it when their shiny iphones stop working.
- Hitton 6y agoThanks, that was much more informative and better explanation of situation in Belarus than I have read anywhere else. Also shorter. I wonder if that is related to the fact that you are not trying to show ads together with that.
- raducu 6y agoI'm sure the IT sector employees wouldn't vote for Lukashenko anyway; if they can block the internet for the rest of the population, all is well. Oh wait, they can fake election results, kill anybody they please and are backed by Russia. I guess all is well regardless if they can block the internet or not.