3 ms·
I really enjoy listening to people's anger ranting why its not really art, or why anyone could do that, etc. The irony is that Abstract expressionism was used
by brudgers 6y ago
I really enjoy listening to people's anger ranting why its not really art, or why anyone could do that, etc.
The irony is that Abstract expressionism was used for Cold War propaganda after Harry Truman made his that-ain’t-art criticism of the pictorial works that were the State Department’s Advancing American Art exhibit.
Pollock et al. were politically acceptable demonstrations of American freedom of expression because they are not critically engaged with social conditions. Being critical of America’s social disparities was what spelled the end of Advancing American Art as a Cold War instrument. It was too much free expression for the Truman administration.
Don’t misunderstand me, I appreciate Pollock et al. But it’s why it took an immigrant to produce Frank’s The Americans to follow on the artistic groundwork layed by the Pubic Works Administration in the depression years.
Pollock is safe because it doesn’t raise important questions about meat space. Rants about what is art are as far as it goes. It’s more tampon in a teacup than it is Maplethorpe’s X.
- monadic2 6y ago> But it’s why it took an immigrant to produce Frank’s The Americans to follow on the artistic groundwork layed by the Pubic Works Administration in the depression years. I never put this together before, thanks!
- wwarner 6y agoSo what do you make of jazz, hip hop or punk rock? Those are full of social criticism, and also seem to reinforce the idea of free expression under capitalism. And there are lots of visual artists and dancers and writers too. I'm looking at the VOA music stream [0] and it seems to be full of free speech of all kinds. It might be fair to say that Jackson Pollock is too apolitical {for our times,to be taken seriously,for you}, but I personally don't see the conspiracy you're laying out here. [0] https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCkGTvcz3OuuoOGWctHo5veA https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCkGTvcz3OuuoOGWctHo5veA
- monadic2 6y agoThis is willfully overlooking the many, many, many, many critiques of capitalism you can see under hip-hop and punk. Tupac was a card-carrying communist. Hopefully you're well aware of the relationship between the Dead Kennedys and capitalist society. I nearly die from the irony every time I see an F-150 with a "thin blue line" sticker blasting "Killing In The Name Of", which is unfortunately quite a lot where I live.
- whatshisface 6y ago"Establishment funding sources dry up when the artists they're supporting develop an anti-establishment message" is hardly a conspiracy theory. It might be true or false, but it's not a conspiracy theory, that's the wrong concept to associate with it.
- monoideism 6y agoIt definitely could be a conspiracy theory, if the allegation is that funders are conspiring together to exclude artists who are too political (and if the allegation is false). But it may be true, and not a conspiracy theory. I've no idea. I've never looked into the issue.
- jacobr1 6y agoNo, if the allegation is true, it still would be a conspiracy. The key factor is the secrecy, not the reality of the situation. If it is provably true, that moves it out of the realm of a theory to history, but it would be a conspiracy regardless. But if done openly per the OP, then we aren't talking about a conspiracy at all, just politics!
- brudgers 6y agoIronically, the House Committee on UnAmerican Activities investigated Advancing American Art exhibit looking for a leftist conspiracy. Or to put it another way there is no rationale for proposing a government conspiracy. It was ordinary government operations described in newspapers and magazines of the day and documented in the Congressional Record and the National Archives.