3 ms·
TikTok is not software. It is a service that uses software. It is therefore not directly comparable with F/OSS projects. I don't much care who contributes to
by sandworm101 6y ago
TikTok is not software. It is a service that uses software. It is therefore not directly comparable with F/OSS projects.
I don't much care who contributes to an open source project. Let them inject their malware if they want to. Because it is OPEN source such efforts will be discovered and the bad actors brought to task. And F/OSS principals extend beyond the code. Because it is open, any user is free to walk away from suspect code. Fork the project. Create your own code. Use the version created by someone you do trust. If I suspect that the particular flavor of linux on my desktop has been infiltrated by bad actors, absolutely nothing is stopping me from switching to any of a hundred other distros. That freedom is the real power, the real safeguard against wrongdoers, not vetting who or who isn't allowed to contribute.
- Barrin92 6y ago> Because it is OPEN source such efforts will be discovered and the bad actors brought to task as the article points out this isn't realistic because nobody actually has the resources or time to audit every piece of software this rigorously, let alone read or understand the entire codebase. A ton of open-source code is maintained by one or two or at best a handful of people and we'd be none the wiser if they'd put malicious code into the software until its to late, and as the article points out the permissiveness of open-source software makes it impossible to know for sure who contributed, after all the point of open-source is to let everyone contribute. So as a system of trust open-source is no solution. The economics of it make it impossible to audit every bit of code, and the code could come from anywhere regardless even of what a Github profile says.