3 ms·
The notion of spending $1000/year just to keep a company in existence seems crazy to me. According to my accountant, if you can't spend $1,000 a year to keep a
by reaperducer 6y ago
The notion of spending $1000/year just to keep a company in existence seems crazy to me.
According to my accountant, if you can't spend $1,000 a year to keep a company in existence, then it's not a business. It's a hobby.
She says there's some minimum level of commercial engagement required in my jurisdiction before the tax authorities get antsy and start wondering if your company is just a way to dodge personal taxes by shifting money around. I never looked into it, so I'm not entirely sure what she's talking about. That's what I have her for.
That said, the total of the yearly government burden on my small company is less than the $1,000 you quote. "The USA" is a big place with lots of different taxes. It's part of the philosophy of competition that keeps the place moving.
- jjoonathan 6y agoOf course an accountant would give a condescending non-answer like that. The clients who give her the most money for the least trouble are the ones for whom that's true. We shouldn't let them or her speak for new businesses, though. People trying to get into business have the clearest view of the problems they face. For an organically grown start-at-the-bottom business, $1000/year to declare a company is bad (it's much less outside of California, but still). The constant threat of the IRS deciding you aren't serious-business enough and sending you a bill for 30% of your revenue in the last 5 years is bad. Not profit, revenue. The fact that "serious business" is defined about as well as my memetic language would imply is doubly bad. We should fix this.
- URSpider94 6y agoIf you want to run your business as as start-at-the-bottom business, then run it as a sole proprietorship. Then the incremental annual costs outside of some initial start-up costs are near zero. You'll probably still have to apply for a business license in the place where your office resides, which might very well be your house.
- jjoonathan 6y agoThat's probably fine for a software business where capex and COGS are peanuts. Unfortunately for me, that's not how my sector works. I repair and resell lab equipment while I do R&D towards making my own. I have five-figure revenue, capex, and COGS. I also have a day job because the side business doesn't support me yet. Here's the rub: because of my capex and COGS, paying tax on profits is very different from paying tax on revenue. I get to pay tax on profits if I'm a business, but I have to pay tax on revenue if I'm a hobby (to put it crudely). If the IRS decides I am retroactively a hobby, my entire business goes from "growing steadily, maybe my day job soon" to "life lesson wipeout." So how do I make sure I'm a business not a hobby? The rules aren't much better than "I'll know one when I see one." They're a joke. A bad joke that keeps me up at night and stunts my business growth because I want to make sure my liquid assets could absorb the IRS dropping a bomb on the whole thing. Tax ambiguity shouldn't be this kind of threat. My accountant isn't concerned, but he's also not on the hook, so I don't take much comfort in that.
- URSpider94 6y agoWelcome to the world of administrative law, nothing is black and white. This is true for a ton of government domains, but tax is the one people interact with most. Do not be terrified of the hobby vs. business designation. If you take some reasonable, intentional steps, you'll be safe. To be specific: do you segregate the materials for your business separate from your personal property? Do you maintain books for your business? Do you have a separate bank account for your business? Do you regularly operate your business to attempt to make a profit, e.g. selling things for more than you pay for them? If so, it's highly, highly unlikely that the IRS will retroactively characterize your business as a hobby. If you're really worried, get an accountant or tax lawyer to review your practices and give you an "opinion letter" stating that you're operating it as a business. If the IRS ever audits you, you can submit this to show that you were acting in good faith. Also, what you wrote implies that you might not be aware of this, but you can deduct all of the costs of operating your business vs. your profits, even if it's just a "hobby". The only difference tax-wise between a business and a hobby at this scale is that you can't deduct hobby expenses that exceed hobby revenue, e.g. a hobby can't generate tax losses, while a business can. If you think you'd be stuck paying taxes on the entire profits of your business without deducting your cost of goods sold and expenses, you've been poorly advised.
- stu2b50 6y agoOP's running a C Corp. Organically grown startups should start as a sole proprietorship or an LLC.
- jjoonathan 6y agoLLCs don't have to pay the California franchise tax? Are you sure about that? https://www.ftb.ca.gov/forms/2020/2020-3522.pdf https://www.ftb.ca.gov/forms/2020/2020-3522.pdf
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- renewiltord 6y agoAccording to my car salesman, if you can't spend $50k on a car, it isn't a car, it's a bicycle.