4 ms·
My issue with Brutalism is that it seems to evoke a sense of helplessness of the individual against the sheer size of the State. No wonder it was so popular in
by airstrike 6y ago
My issue with Brutalism is that it seems to evoke a sense of helplessness of the individual against the sheer size of the State. No wonder it was so popular in totalitarian regimes.
I often think of Brasilia, the capital of Brazil. A city literally built in the middle of nowhere and with virtually no sidewalks, making it incredibly costly for individuals to reach it and organize themselves to protest against the government. Its streets literally have no name⁰. Imagine living on SHS W2 or SEN L1!
I was raised to love Oscar Niemeyer, but nowadays I can't help wishing he chose to lend his beautiful creativity to something other than architecture.
__________
0. https://www.quora.com/How-do-people-living-in-Brasilia-refer-to-their-city-streets https://www.quora.com/How-do-people-living-in-Brasilia-refer...
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoWhy not? Imagine those addresses belonged to Logan V and Caprica VI :-)
- walrus01 6y agoHaving seen both Brasilia and Islamabad, two contemporary master planned cities, I prefer the latter. Islamabad is just chaotic enough and weird enough, and every sector is unique... G9 is not like F7 and so on.
- forinti 6y agoThe first time I visited Brasilia I saw a cleaning lady changing her uniform under a bridge. This describes perfectly the Brazilian state: big, distant, not prepared to deal in practical day to day issues (like having a place to change clothes or a sidewalk to walk on). The architecture underlines this mentality quite well.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gtpedrosa 6y agoBenjamim Moser wrote a whole book no the matter, called "Autoimperialismo". It litterally goes on how Brasilia's architecture is designed to convey the superiority of the state over the people. In fact there is no space for people. No sidewalks. Nothing is "reachable" by a pedestrian. And yet, it is the seat of the three powers.
- puranjay 6y agoI see brutalism as a response to WW2. If your civilization had just gone through the worst war in history, you'd feel a lot more comfortable in a fortress-like building than in a glass skyscraper.
- airstrike 6y agoI see your point, but that's a false dichotomy. Brutalism isn't the only alternative to glass buildings. https://trip101.com/article/famous-buildings-in-vienna https://trip101.com/article/famous-buildings-in-vienna Most of these look pretty safe to me and objectively prettier than cubes of exposed concrete
- Nasrudith 6y agoThat would be an ironically counterproductive response given that said war proved fixed fortresses damn near useless. The Magniot Line became synonymous with useless security theater by Blitzkrieg fortifications were proven pretty useless as they decide to attack someplace else with mobile forces, they fail to provide significant time and logistics and medicine protect against attrition of the sieges of old.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- fatbird 6y agoThe problem wasn't the Maginot Line, it was the assumption that the modern mobile forces that the French understood were coming, wouldn't be able to pass through the Ardennes. It's not that the French didn't foresee bypassing the line, it's that they mistakenly though it couldn't be bypassed. This wasn't unreasonable, either: The German forces slipped through along a single road unopposed. Even a token French force could have blocked them long enough to bottle them up and destroy them there. What the French were blind to was the gamble the Germans were willing to take. Where German forces tried to pierce the Maginot Line, they were crushed. It worked exactly as designed. As usual, the lesson that History tends to recall is incorrect.
- eternalban 6y ago> My issue with Brutalism is that it seems to evoke a sense of helplessness of the individual against the sheer size of the State. No wonder it was so popular in totalitarian regimes. Empire State Plaza, Albany, NY: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/ff/EmpirePlaza17.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/ff/EmpirePl... ~ I would not want to live there either, just like I probably wouldn't enjoy living in an equally sublime Tadao Ando house. But in my opinion, Brasilia, regardless of its failure, is a sublimely beautiful work of architecture. I for one am glad it was built. I'm fairly certain it will serve [at some point in the future] as a 'blueprint' for a vocabulary of elements of architecture, in the same way that Vitruvius and classical orders played the muse for a resurgent European architecture.
- monadic2 6y agoFWIW brutalism was quite popular here in the US too. I think the design and living considerations of these structures outstrip American development in virtually every regard: https://designyoutrust.com/2018/01/bublik-circular-apartment-building-moscow-pinnacle-brutalism/ https://designyoutrust.com/2018/01/bublik-circular-apartment...
- shuntress 6y ago>My issue with Brutalism is that it seems to evoke a sense of helplessness of the individual against the sheer size of the State I would not attribute that specifically to Brutalism. I tend to find that style more likely to evoke a sense of modesty. The lack of ornamental or ostentatious features tends to make Brutalist designs feel, to me, more egalitarian.
- airstrike 6y agoIt's an interesting take. From my perspective, however, what you call egalitarian I call an oppression of individual expression.
- heavenlyblue 6y agoYou could also call red colour white but the books on history will continue calling it white.
- thethethethe 6y ago> My issue with Brutalism is that it seems to evoke a sense of helplessness of the individual against the sheer size of the State. No wonder it was so popular in totalitarian regimes. You have this backwards. Brutalism was popular in the Soviet Union because it is austere, symbolizing equality and utilitarianism. Back in the early days, brutalism was actually seen as progressive. It’s association with totalitarianism is a result of western propaganda and the failures of the soviet bureaucracy. > I often think of Brasilia, the capital of Brazil. A city literally built in the middle of nowhere and with virtually no sidewalks, making it incredibly costly for individuals to reach it and organize themselves to protest against the government. Its streets literally have no name⁰. Imagine living on SHS W2 or SEN L1! Basically none of this is related to brutalism. What you are describing is a failed attempt at new urbansim. Brasilia is divided into "superblocks", which are essentially self-contained communities with all required services in the center. This design was similar to soviet urban planning at the time, though the superblocks were much bigger (and less successful) in Brasilia. This design ultimately resulted in large boulevards and car centric transportation, defeating its initial goals
- vidarh 6y agoBrutalism became popular because it was cheaper and had gained popularity in the West. Stalin rejected brutalism firmly. Brutalism first gained traction in the Eastern block after it had gained popularity in the West. He rejected the austerity, and he rejected examples of it such as proposed by Le Corbusier twice: both when Le Corbusier proposed an austere Palace of the Soviets, and secondly when Le Corbusier wanted to raze large parts of Moscow for a redesign along similar principles as what Brasilia adopted. The austerity in Soviet design came under Khruschev as a cost-cutting measure to increase the housing stock, primarily, and while you certainly find more monumental buildings built in a brutalist style, that was the same thing: It was an end to the excesses of Stalinist architecture in favour of signaling a focus on saving money, and an actually desperate need to cut costs. You're right that brutalism was seen as progressive, but initially that was the case in the west. Le Corbusier actually accused Stalin of betraying the revolution when his proposals were rejected - he saw his proposals as revolutionary, but Stalin wanted a much more traditional style. Stalinist architecture is anchored in the French Empire style, which you also find echoes of in parts of the US Federal style [1]. See e.g. Moscow State University as a prime example [2]. It has columns, and all kinds of architectural flourishes that you expect on more monumental Empire or Federal style buildings, and no sign of brutalism. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_architecture#/media/File:SC_State_House_at_evening.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_architecture#/media/Fi... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stalinist_architecture#/media/File:%D0%9C%D0%93%D0%A3._%D0%92%D0%B8%D0%B4_%D0%BD%D0%B0_%D0%B3%D0%BB%D0%B0%D0%B2%D0%BD%D0%BE%D0%B5_%D0%B7%D0%B4%D0%B0%D0%BD%D0%B8%D0%B5..jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stalinist_architecture#/media/...
- Joker_vD 6y agoIt's quite ironic since Brutalism emerged during the 1950s in Great Britain. Not in the USSR. The Wikipedia page on it https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brutalist_architecture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brutalist_architecture has 9 pictures in the main body of the article and 17 in the Gallery section, and none of them are from the USSR.
- anthk 6y agoSpain had that too. And half of Europe.
- k__ 6y agoI once heard there are no street names in Japan, they would just number the buildings consecutively as they were built.
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 6y agoJapan has an IPv4-like block system: a typical address is Prefecture City District 1-2-3-45, with 1-2-3 representing increasingly small divisions and the (optional) 4th element representing the apartment number. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_addressing_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_addressing_system