9 ms·
> Piracy destroys jobs, opportunity and initiative. So what? Let them be destroyed. I'd rather sacrifice some jobs than watch gigantic media conglomerates tak
by matheusmoreira 6y ago
> Piracy destroys jobs, opportunity and initiative.
So what? Let them be destroyed.
I'd rather sacrifice some jobs than watch gigantic media conglomerates take over the computing industry and destroy our computing freedom with their DRM. There is no other way for them to enforce copyright in the 21st century so that's exactly what they'll try to do. They won't rest until every computer available to the public is locked down like a video game console. That will of course spell the end of playful hacking as Hacker News knows it. Not only that, this sort of control over what software our machines may or may not run will be a stepping stone towards greater governmental control over key technologies such as effective free software encryption, paving the way for total population surveillance. Non-essential jobs are nothing compared to these important issues.
The copyright industry wants to sell what's essentially huge numbers to the public. That's how ridiculous copyright is. It's the 21st century, the age of information. Instead of worrying about job destruction, better to abolish it straight up so that people will be forced to figure out a new business model.
- f00zz 6y agoEh, artists have bills to pay. I try to buy e-books to support my favorite sci-fi authors, but it feels a bit silly that downloading the epub from libgen is literally less hassle than buying it on Google Play.
- rbanffy 6y agoAnd this is one of the key selling points of piracy - having the product you want easily available while the other options (physical disk, download) may not be available in your region.
- johnchristopher 6y agoYeah, no. When I was a teen and wanted pirated games I had to put a lot of time into it (downloading/getting the CD's) then hunt for working cracks and then later deal with the consequences of installing cracks. My time was free but as an adult now I could never justify spending evenings to make pirated games work. Today's piracy is way more easier than piracy 15 or 25 years ago. The key selling point of piracy is that it's free.
- airstrike 6y ago> but as an adult now I could never justify spending evenings to make pirated games work. Side note: I agree entirely but I do miss those evenings! Even legit games were such a chore to install that when they finally worked, you were swept by a wave of pure joy. Looking at you, Little Big Adventure 2! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Big_Adventure_2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Big_Adventure_2
- johnchristopher 6y agoThat's one thing that was bugging me. I used to wonder why I missed playing video games and at the same time very few games were entertaining to me anymore. I think it's because what I am missing is the evening of care-free tinkering, of having good time with friends, of having a wide horizon ; I am missing that mood and ambiance, not the gaming part, I miss how I was looking at the world.
- airstrike 6y agoCouldn't have said it better – I feel as if I wrote the very comment I'm replying to. My solution has been to play old classics that transport me back to those times and those are so much more enjoyable than most new titles.
- rusk 6y ago> Today's piracy is way more easier than piracy 15 or 25 years ago. Not exactly... you still need specialist equipment to do it ... even something like the analogue hole is too inconvenient for the typical user. Even for me it’s just not worth the hassle. Downloading is easy enough for video and music but you still have to find the dodgy sites (in my jurisdiction thus requires some ducking and diving). In some way it’s easier in some ways it’s harder. It’s an arms race and has been ever thus.
- Karunamon 6y agoI've probably spent more total time in the rigamarole surrounding legitimately purchased games (DRM incompatibilities and performance issues, activation servers being down, make and account and log in and click through our EULA, etc) than I have with issues surrounding cracked games. Cracking games from a user standpoint is usually a process of downloading a torrent, waiting a bit, then replacing a handful of files in the install directory the first time, and then you're usually not bothered again. Some include an installer that handles this for you.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y agoIt was the insight that "Piracy is a service problem" that led Valve to create Steam.
- matheusmoreira 6y ago> Eh, artists have bills to pay. So? That doesn't change anything. The needs of creators cannot override our need for computing freedom. Enabling creators to pay their bills by charging money for data will have serious consequences for society in the long term. If they have bills to pay, they can find something else to do. Ideally, they should get paid for the act of creating rather than the final result. > it feels a bit silly that downloading the epub from libgen is literally less hassle than buying it on Google Play. "Piracy" is actually the superior service. It's how everything should work. The copyright industry simply cannot compete and will never be able to compete. The only way they can win is by making the competition illegal.
- scarface74 6y agoAre you at all involved with software development? How do you feel about people breaking the GPL?
- tauwauwau 6y agoI'm not arguing in favor of piracy, but isn't GPL anti copyright (copyleft)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jasonlotito 6y agoFair question. =) No, it's not. "Copyleft licenses exist within the legal structure of copyrights. Despite what the name implies, copyleft isn't about abolishing copyrights. Rather, copyleft licenses are a subset of copyright licenses, and the goal is to restore freedom to users." https://www.makeuseof.com/tag/copyleft-copyright-key-concepts/ https://www.makeuseof.com/tag/copyleft-copyright-key-concept...
- tauwauwau 6y agoYou are right, thanks for clarifying. I asked that question as the GP made the case that breaking GPL is equivalent to pirating (breaking any other copyright). But GPL ensures a resource is always shareable and anyone who tries to break it would be limiting shareability of the resource, essentially it would be opposite of piracy.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y ago> Eh, artists have bills to pay Indeed, and we should support those who create the works we enjoy, but consider that the model of buying individual works from a publisher is rooted in the obsolete requirement to create a physical good upon which the work is distributed. Given that we now live in an age where the cost of distribution is effectively $0, perhaps we need to find a new model for compensating creative works. Personally, I'm a big fan of things like Patreon, which let me support people who's work I enjoy more-or-less directly and allows creators to keep their creations free for all to enjoy.
- LexGray 6y agoIf the stated goal is that artists only deserve what I want to pay and there is too much graft and payment friction with conglomerates shouldn’t an ethical fan/pirate site always link to the artists Patreon?
- viraptor 6y agoThe fun thing is that's pretty much how the classical composers worked in the past, just with a single/few rich patrons per artist rather than a number of people chipping in.
- f00zz 6y agoI prefer to pay once for the finished product, as opposed to paying regularly through something like Patreon. Maybe I'm cheap. Also, in the case of literature I'm not paying just the author. Editors and proofreaders make all the difference: http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2013/03/why-i-dont-self-publish.html http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2013/03/why-i-do...
- philipov 6y agoCopyright law has a place, but as it currently stands, it doesn't protect independent artists sufficiently, while giving large media firms disproportionate power. This ultimately hurts small content producers a lot more than it helps them, because they have to compete with companies much larger than them that can afford to use their economies of scale to bully independent artists into submission. The fact that it's so much hassle to buy something just goes to show that Google has no incentive to compete on product, where the product is the marketplace itself. Piracy is an indication that the market has failed to produce a satisfactory distribution mechanism, and allowing large corporations to use legal action to shelter themselves from having to improve their offering hurts both consumers and small businesses. "Piracy is a service problem." - Gabe Newell
- matheusmoreira 6y ago> Copyright law has a place Yes, in a pre-computer and pre-internet society. It has no place in the 21st century. > allowing large corporations to use legal action to shelter themselves from having to improve their offering hurts both consumers and small businesses You know what sucks? Wanting to buy something, being willing to pay for it and finding out that what I want is not available to me. Because of copyright. Every day I log into Netflix and search for something I want to watch, Netflix autocompletes the movie's name and yet it doesn't actually show up in the results. It's there, just not available to me. I lost count of the number of lesser known works I wanted to view but couldn't because they aren't popular and therefore not profitable. I don't even try to find them anymore. Somehow, copyright stops the service from offering the content to me. I suppose I'm part of some irrelevant market segment they don't care about. So it's not just a service problem.
- s1artibartfast 6y ago>You know what sucks? Wanting to buy something, being willing to pay for it and finding out that what I want is not available to me. Because of copyright. This seems to me to be a very strange mindset. Someone else has created content you want, is not offered for sale to you, so you it is in your right to seal it? What makes this OK and where does it end?
- a1369209993 6y agoThat's a fair point, but the problem is that buying it on Google Play (or rather, providing money to the actual person who created it) is too difficult, not that downloading the epub from libgen is too easy.
- EGreg 6y agoWe wouldnt have this conversation if UBI paid for all basic needs. Hey everyone, I would like to have the government enforce my idea of ownership, and come after them for copying something. Because without owning everhthing why would scientists, open source developers and wikipedians and creative commons people and folk musicians ever produce anything?
- jandrese 6y agoFor example, on a recommendation I decided to read Gateway by Frederick Pohl. I like ebooks because it lets me read without keeping the light on and disturbing my wife. First stop was Overdrive, no dice but that's not uncommon. Their selection is pretty slim. Next was Hoopla, but also struck out. So I tried the Kindle Store. I found reviews about people reading it, but no copies for sale. B&Ns store had the same problem. Not available on Google Play. So I went to the wider internet but came up completely dry on legitimate purchase options. WTF. This novel won a Hugo why is it so damn hard to find? Why did the ebook version disappear from all legitimate vendors? Is there some dark secret that they're trying to hide? Of course if I were willing to torrent it I'd have a perfect copy that I could read anywhere in less than 5 minutes.
- 52-6F-62 6y agoI think in the pursuit of fairness, it's easy to say that when you only stand to gain and your livelihood is not the one at risk.
- shajznnckfke 6y agoUh, arresting Kim Dotcom has absolutely nothing to do with the ethics of DRM. If anything, successful prosecution of illegal file-sharing operations reduces the economic incentives to put DRM in place.
- creato 6y agoExactly. If you dislike DRM, you should be cheering operations like this. I'd much rather see piracy fought by pursuing egregious offenders, and not crippling consumer hardware or suing randos using napster for $5k a pop.
- abakker 6y agoYou'd rather sacrifice someone else's jobs for your ideals? What a fair, well considered trade. The freedom you see to seem to be looking for here is freedom from consequences, not actual freedom. As always with the products other people are making, you have the choice to not buy them. That is actual freedom. Be careful making other's choices for them, it is closer to the governmental overreach you are against.
- russler23 6y agoWe’ve sacrificed a lot of jobs for ideals across human history, and I’m totally okay with that.
- matheusmoreira 6y ago> As always with the products other people are making, you have the choice to not buy them. That's how it works in the material world. Data works differently. Data is infinite. You can have as much as you want. Why would anyone buy copies when making new ones is as easy as copy and paste? Only the original copy must be paid for. So there is in fact a third choice to buying or not buying data: obtain a copy from someone who already has it. Copyright law is all about getting rid of that choice. It's all about making sure that creators monopolize the means to make copies. Copyright is about the right to make copies. Making copies of data is a fundamental computer operation. We can find this ability in functions such as memcpy, in programs such as cp and HTTP servers. Making copies is trivial. Anyone who owns a computer can do it. Without compromising our freedom to run these programs, copyright law is unenforceable. So it's not just ideals. In order to actually enforce copyright law, computers must be made to answer to the copyright industry instead of users. As a computer user and programmer, that's not the future I want.
- thinkloop 6y ago> Only the original copy must be paid for. We are only paying for the original copy, but distributing that payment over many people and over time so it doesn't hurt as much - which single person is going to pay $10K or $1M or $50M for a song or movie?
- ryandrake 6y agoSomething tells me that if the fictional Star Trek "replicator" would suddenly be invented today, with the ability to copy any physical item, we'd see a similar story. Imagine, the removal of goods scarcity. Feed everyone on earth. Everyone could have anything they want just constructed out of thin air for them! It would be a utopia. But the same people would make the same argument against that utopia: "What about jobs? You can't just copy someone's hard work without paying for it!" They'd get the government to ban replicators and criminalize their use. Or, they'd only allow certain, licensed companies to use replicators, maintaining an artificial scarcity so that things could still be sold. We'd toss away world-changing technology in order to maintain the status quo where people had to work and pay for scarce goods.
- matheusmoreira 6y agoFunny, I just mentioned Star Trek replicators in another post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24286410 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24286410
- stallmanite 6y agoI think you’re right but I’d love to see them try to argue that pro-scarcity point to its conclusion. Why would we need jobs if the point of jobs is to get money and the point of money is to get scarce goods. The replicator would make the whole system obsolete unless the pro-scarcity side straight up admits they just want inequality for its own sake.
- austincheney 6y ago> So what? Let them be destroyed. I say the same thing about software jobs, as a software developer myself. Developers should be licensed professionals like any other professional industry. Developers not competent enough to meet a minimal baseline required by licensing should have their jobs destroyed. I would rather some jobs be destroyed than gigantic software companies writing incompetent privacy violating software. I detest DRM, but at least DRM is honest about what it is.
- weare138 6y agoSo what? Let them be destroyed. I'd rather sacrifice some jobs than watch gigantic media conglomerates take over the computing industry and destroy our computing freedom with their DRM. Honestly I've never come across a study that says piracy even has a significant impact on the media industry, in fact some studies found the opposite. People that like something they pirated, which is not many people really, will usually go buy it.
- wittyreference 6y agoI find those studies to be ... I'm not sure what the word is. Laboratory artifacts? When a small portion of super-enthused users are doing the bulk of the pirating, piracy is going to manifest different effects than if it's massively widespread with a minimum barrier to entry. It's not uncommon for there to eventually be a post in one of these threads to the effect of "there shouldn't be IP at all." I imagine as you move along the spectrum from the current state of torrenting, towards "no IP at all," the effects of piracy on media purchases are going to veer further and further from what current studies show.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- shard 6y agoPiracy extends beyond movies and music. It also affects games, which arguably is one driving force behind IAP, loot boxes, and pay-to-win, and I for one do not feel it is a good trend. To extend it further, IP also includes source code, which many of us base our livings off here in this forum, and accepting the theft of this IP would be devastating for our industry.