3 ms·
like the most anti-free-market law I've ever heard of Do you know why the SEC created these rules? If you understand the history it makes a lot of sense.
by refurb 6y ago
like the most anti-free-market law I've ever heard of
Do you know why the SEC created these rules? If you understand the history it makes a lot of sense.
- chrisco255 6y agoThe world is quite a different place in 2020 than in 1933. We have access to unlimited digital forms of risk to speculate on as it is. It used to be seen as necessary to have taxi licenses in order to have trusted drivers who wouldn't scam out-of-towners. It turns out you can replace all that regulation with an online review system plus mobile GPS and payment app (Uber / Lyft). Similar innovations are being held back in securities because of red tape.
- refurb 6y agoThe existence of other risks isn't a strong argument for introducing more risks. It's easy for HN to say "this makes no sense", but I guarantee you if the rules changed we'd see some article in the NYTimes where some retiree lost their entire life savings in a private investment including quotes like "no one told me it was that risky".
- tathougies 6y agoNo it doesn't really. People should be allowed to fail. The response when someone loses all their money due to a business failing should be to have a social safety net, not to prevent them from ever having been able to invest their money in the first place.
- refurb 6y agoWait what? You're arguing we should have a social safety net so when some blue collar worker loses 100% of their retirement savings because they invested in a scam start-up, they're covered?
- tathougies 6y agoYes. That's right. Part of living in a free market state is allowing the market to choose. Part of living in a civilized country is ensuring that there are safety nets available to those who the market fails to support. The market operates efficiently when every entity involved can have net worth of any amount, including negative. Unfortunately, human life requires a particular amount of wealth to survive. You cannot have a pure free market system without there being some left out. The purpose of government is to protect rights to life, liberty, and property. That means providing some support when someone's wealth is so low that they cannot sustain their life. This should be implemented in such a way as to affect the market least. Milton Friedman's negative income tax would be one possibility, but there are others as well. In any case, the market should be free to operate as if the person could reasonably be expected to have nothing.