3 ms·
It's an odd title; most of the article talks about books that are not focused on Brutalism, but on a range of styles of which brutalism appears to make up a lim
by vidarh 6y ago
It's an odd title; most of the article talks about books that are not focused on Brutalism, but on a range of styles of which brutalism appears to make up a limited part.
E.g. it references "Imagine Moscow", but Stalin forcefully rejected Le Corbusier twice, and Moscow was never re-imagined in a brutalist manner in Moscow, but possibly in Brasilia (Le Corbusier's Ville Radieuse[1] was inspired by his plans for Moscow, and Brasilia was designed to incorporate aspects of Ville Radieuse). I'm sure there are interesting examples of brutalism in Moscow (though most of the brutalism in Russia are down to Khrushchyovka [2]), but they postdates the era the book is about, and the most prominent design ideas for Moscow at the time were not brutalist.
"Consumer Culture Landscapes in Socialist Yugoslavia" seems to focus on the work of Zivorad Jankovic, much of which isn't brutalist either.
Lastly it references "Soviet Metro Stations", but most of them are not brutalist at all - certainly not the most famous examples.
If it wasn't for numerous references to brutalism in the text, I'd have assumed this was an editor messing around, but I'm not convinced the author of this piece knows what brutalism is. The books might well be interesting, though, but when the article tries to shoehorn them into a box they don't appear to fit in, it makes it hard to tell. It'd be nice if the author tried harder to describe the books in more detail rather than try to invent his own narrative around it.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ville_Radieuse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ville_Radieuse
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khrushchyovka https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khrushchyovka