4 ms·
Did they really not have anything except a wealth test previously? Nothing for people working in the industry etc?
by LatteLazy 6y ago
Did they really not have anything except a wealth test previously? Nothing for people working in the industry etc?
- sbuccini 6y agoNope!
- LatteLazy 6y agoI'm a brit, I looked into our equivalent regime a while back and I was amazed you could be considered sophisticated based solely on income/assets.
- vmception 6y ago'Murica! Although US is not a great place when you don't have enough income or assets, it would be just as foreign to us that you wouldn't be considered sophisticated from income/assets! "What do you mean an actual class system with a 1,000 year family history, crazy talk!" But back to investment choice, we don't agree that "sophisticated" can only be from wealth. We want choice, the option to take risks.
- vmception 6y agoIt was a "self-certified" wealth test People working in the industry know that self-certified means lie through your teeth all day every day with a straight face. People working in the industry know that you can create illiquid investments, trade one unit of it and say you own the rest at the same price, and viola you are a multimillionaire. I did it with crypto assets 6 years ago using Counterparty. People working in the industry know that you just need a lawyer or CPA to sign off on that. The prohibition is on the companies selling securities, not on the investor, so the company just needs a way to cover their ass (CYA) and there is no consequence for the investor. "Self-certification" is a code word for lying, or stretching the truth, just checking the box.
- LatteLazy 6y agoThanks, that makes more sense!
- ninetax 6y ago> People working in the industry know that you just need a lawyer or CPA to sign off on that. In your experience how willing are CPAs or lawyers to do that for you? In theory they're putting their credentials on the line for you, so I imagine it's either hard to find ones that will do that or very expensive to the point where it eats into the investment return with the amounts of capital being invested below the accredited investor limit.
- vmception 6y agolol maybe 10 years ago and briefly. There have been a SaaS services for this the whole decade, and that’s only because the issuer exemptions were expanded to even need a lawyer because an investor saying “yeah Im accredited” wasn't good enough for some securities issuance exemptions. You don't lie to the lawyer (or most lawyers), you show assets. Assets which so happen to have a value and are totally illiquid. You trade a single unit of something you create for $1 and you happen to have 2,000,000 more units. You’re accredited by any standard. No different than your portfolio of houses in a place nobody wants to live in, which still happen to have appraisals totaling over $1mm. If that doesnt feel “right” to you then you might be confusing who actually has the consequence here and might have been unproductively conditioned to “follow the letter of the law” compared to the consequences and implementation of the law. Again its a prohibition on the securities issuer which they pass on to the investor. Its not a prohibition from the government on the investor or the lawyer. And the securities issuer simply has to go through the motions. Check, check and check. And the investor has to pony up the cash. If they don’t have the $25K or $100K minimum anyway then get out. The government’s role in this is just a redundant deterrent.
- ninetax 6y agoI understand who has the consequences here. My curiosity is about that conversation with the lawyer when you say "I traded a single unit of something I created for $1 and I happen to have 2,000,000 more units." where something is cryptocurrency (what else could it be?). Would most lawyers go "Yep, just another routine accredited investor check, $200 please." Or would most say "I'm being asked to affirm this person has $1m in assets and in the off chance that somehow this is checked by someone I could be penalized because I didn't do my diligence to make sure this isn't just funny money".