13 ms·
mrandish's point is that the amount of effort spent on Dotcom by authorities was disproportionate to the size and importance of the crime, and abusive of the le
by toyg 6y ago
mrandish's point is that the amount of effort spent on Dotcom by authorities was disproportionate to the size and importance of the crime, and abusive of the legal system. This might well be true at the same time as the fact that Dotcom was a criminal.
I would tend to agree with mrandish, for the simple fact that they don't do that sort of raid even for people who owe the taxman several multiples of the profits Dotcom allegedly/apparently made.
- Y_Y 6y agoYou're absolutely right that these two things can be true at once. I commend you for your level-headed evaluation and I wish there were more comments like yours.
- xhkkffbf 6y agoLet me say as an artist who has watched his hard work being openly pirated, I disagree. Piracy destroys jobs, opportunity and initiative. If these cretins want to distribute art for free, they can get off their butts and make their own. No one is stopping them. The world needs more voices, but piracy encourages these loafers to do nothing.
- thatcat 6y agoWhy do you think you’re entitled to a certain business model?
- lowdose 6y agoNetflix pirates their own shows to generate extra attention.
- matheusmoreira 6y ago> Piracy destroys jobs, opportunity and initiative. So what? Let them be destroyed. I'd rather sacrifice some jobs than watch gigantic media conglomerates take over the computing industry and destroy our computing freedom with their DRM. There is no other way for them to enforce copyright in the 21st century so that's exactly what they'll try to do. They won't rest until every computer available to the public is locked down like a video game console. That will of course spell the end of playful hacking as Hacker News knows it. Not only that, this sort of control over what software our machines may or may not run will be a stepping stone towards greater governmental control over key technologies such as effective free software encryption, paving the way for total population surveillance. Non-essential jobs are nothing compared to these important issues. The copyright industry wants to sell what's essentially huge numbers to the public. That's how ridiculous copyright is. It's the 21st century, the age of information. Instead of worrying about job destruction, better to abolish it straight up so that people will be forced to figure out a new business model.
- f00zz 6y agoEh, artists have bills to pay. I try to buy e-books to support my favorite sci-fi authors, but it feels a bit silly that downloading the epub from libgen is literally less hassle than buying it on Google Play.
- rbanffy 6y agoAnd this is one of the key selling points of piracy - having the product you want easily available while the other options (physical disk, download) may not be available in your region.
- johnchristopher 6y agoYeah, no. When I was a teen and wanted pirated games I had to put a lot of time into it (downloading/getting the CD's) then hunt for working cracks and then later deal with the consequences of installing cracks. My time was free but as an adult now I could never justify spending evenings to make pirated games work. Today's piracy is way more easier than piracy 15 or 25 years ago. The key selling point of piracy is that it's free.
- airstrike 6y ago> but as an adult now I could never justify spending evenings to make pirated games work. Side note: I agree entirely but I do miss those evenings! Even legit games were such a chore to install that when they finally worked, you were swept by a wave of pure joy. Looking at you, Little Big Adventure 2! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Big_Adventure_2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Big_Adventure_2
- johnchristopher 6y agoThat's one thing that was bugging me. I used to wonder why I missed playing video games and at the same time very few games were entertaining to me anymore. I think it's because what I am missing is the evening of care-free tinkering, of having good time with friends, of having a wide horizon ; I am missing that mood and ambiance, not the gaming part, I miss how I was looking at the world.
- intotheabyss 6y agoAnyone pirating content was never going to pay for it in the first place, so you haven't really lost anything. If anything, having your shit pirated gives you more exposure, so I'd say it's a net positive overall.
- Taylor_OD 6y agoThat's not really true. I pirated when I was young and couldn't afford things and later when I could afford things I'd purchase from those same creators. Al la the first hit is free.
- senko 6y agoYou agree with the parent. When you were young, you wouldn't have bought it even if you didn't pirate it. However, since you pirated it, you felt happy (or even morally obliged) to purchase from same creators, later, when you had the means. Ie. in that case, the piracy increased exposure and indirectly increased sales.
- breakfastduck 6y agoI'm not sure this is true on a grand scale. It's been widely recognized that the majority of piracy is committed by people who would not spend the money on the item anyway, or in cases where it is actually difficult to buy the item. There's a reason cheap & easy access to media (streaming) has reduced piracy. People are willing to pay for something if it has value, is offered at a reasonable price and is easy to purchase and own.
- tzs 6y ago> It's been widely recognized that the majority of piracy is committed by people who would not spend the money on the item anyway What about other items? E.g., someone who pirates a graphics editing program that costs several hundred dollars indeed might not have purchased it if piracy had not been available, so arguably that piracy did not cost that software maker a sale. But if piracy had not been an option, would they have just given up on doing their graphics editing? Or would they have looked around for something else instead? Maybe they would have bought Pixelmator Pro, for example, which is under $30, and can do a lot of things that people pirate the more expensive programs for.
- violetgarden 6y agoGood points! You start looking for a competitor. Personally, I don’t like the argument “they weren’t going to buy it anyways.” So you get to enjoy the software or movie, and it’s no harm done because you weren’t going to buy it anyways? I think a lot of times this is a cop out excuse. In my mind, and just as your graphics example points out somebody somewhere lost an opportunity or a sale. Not saying there aren’t cases where pirating is justified, but I often get the feeling a lot of people are holding on to excuses that don’t apply specifically to justify their 6 TB Plex library.
- breakfastduck 6y agoThese a good points, and I must admit I hadn't considered the 'looking for alternatives' idea. Anecdotally though, I think over the long term piracy can be balanced out. I pirated a load of games and software when I was younger with no disposable income which I have now purchased - I could argue the point I'd never have gotten into some hobbies if I hadn't had the piracy option, and they never would have got the purchase later down the line. Totally get where you're coming from though, I don't think it's as black and white as maybe I had previously thought.
- rbanffy 6y ago> Piracy destroys jobs, opportunity and initiative. It's hard to find an accurate value for lost sales. In the case of this group, they published content that wasn't commercially available.
- sanbor 6y ago> Piracy destroys jobs, opportunity and initiative It does for some people. But also creates jobs, opportunity and initiative. In my personal case when I was 12 years old in Argentina I was able to access Encarta and Visual Basic 5 thanks to piracy. This let me to get into programming and get better education. If not for piracy, many people would not be able to afford Windows, Photoshop, and other software. In rich countries software might cost 0.5%, 1%, or 2% of your income, while in developing countries costs 20% or 30% of your salary (and you're already very tight with your income). Also, despite all the piracy of Microsoft products, Bill Gates ended up being the richest person in the world. Just bringing other points of view to this complex topic.
- mikecoles 6y agoYou're a thief. I'm not able to access a luxury car. I should go steal one so I can make some money as an Uber Lux contractor, according to you.
- sugarpile 6y agoMind linking that art? I’ve got some 10gb/s boxes I’d love to seed it on.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- onedognight 6y agoDo you remember when Dotcom was pushing Russian propaganda? He (along with Assange) said he had evidence that it was Seth Rich and not the GRU that gave the emails to Wikileaks. Of course, he never released that evidence. This is part of a counterintelligence investigation. Why were Dotcom, Assange, Bannon, Manafort, etc carrying water for the GRU? I don’t know, but having an unrelated tax/copyright/fraud charge might get them to talk, or it might not.
- toyg 6y agoDotcom's troubles pre-date anything involving him with Wikileaks. He relocated to Hong Kong in 2003 (and again to New Zealand in 2009) precisely to shield himself from European and American prosecution, as he was starting Megaupload. He's been in the crosshair of copyright police ever since. Trying to "shake him down" by using charges he was clearly expecting for a decade, would be a pretty silly strategy. As for anything he says or does, it should all be taken with a massive grain of salt. The facts, even before Mega, show him a lier, a narcissist, and a huge self-promoter. He's fundamentally just a scoundrel with no real ideological background beyond "anything that makes me money should not be illegal". Taking his word at face value is chasing shadows.
- jessaustin 6y agoThis seems like a "conspiracy theory".
- onedognight 6y agoWhich part? Dotcom claimed personal knowledge that Seth Rich gave the hacked emails to Wikileaks? Here he’s saying it [1]. That Assange did the same? Here he is alluding to it[2]. Mueller and the recent Senate Intelligence Committee Report said Seth Rich has nothing to do with it[3]. Or do you think the Seth Rich conspiracy didn’t come from the Russian state? Here’s a story pointing out that it came from the Russian SVR[4]. So now we are left with the question, why would Dotcom claim personal knowledge of a Russian State created conspiracy theory that provided cover for the Assange and the GRU? He sounds like a person of interest to me. [1] https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=VFQgID8pZVw https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=VFQgID8pZVw [2] https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Kp7FkLBRpKg https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Kp7FkLBRpKg [3] https://www.thedailybeast.com/mueller-report-julian-assange-smeared-seth-rich-to-cover-for-russians https://www.thedailybeast.com/mueller-report-julian-assange-... [4] https://www.npr.org/2019/07/11/740608323/the-origins-of-the-seth-rich-conspiracy-theory https://www.npr.org/2019/07/11/740608323/the-origins-of-the-...