3 ms·
Would be interesting if our justice system spent as much effort on white collar crime, insider trading, financial misengineering, price fixing, etc.
by mensetmanusman 6y ago
Would be interesting if our justice system spent as much effort on white collar crime, insider trading, financial misengineering, price fixing, etc.
- mc32 6y agoIsn’t this an example of “white collar” crime albeit perhaps a low level one?
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoKind of - technically - but realistically no. The government is treating it more akin to theft than copyright infringement. If an artist steals another's work and makes some money off of it, the federal government isn't going to step in and help. It'd be up to the artist (or copyright holder) to sue for damages. Assuming the case is clear, the artist would get money from the offender. The offender rarely goes to jail. If the offender instead stole the art from the artist's home, then they might get criminal charges.
- unishark 6y agoI don't get what you mean when you say "technically no", since you pretty much made the case for the point. The govt is accusing them of fraud (a kind of theft) in how they acquired the movies initially. This is indeed a white collar crime.
- libertine 6y agoThis isn't done for financial gain (or at least it didn't use to be done for financial gain). It's basically a game. In my youth I was drawn to it and tried to be a racer to gain access to top sites. The rush was basically to be one of the first to have your hands on something, even if it was just to prove that you could. Like just get it to show off that you had it before any tracker had it - kids stuff. For these guys it used to be about releasing before any other group (that wouldn't be nuked, for example, if a crack didn't work). Nowadays if they are using bribery for access, or are being paid to dump it on sites, then yeah, I guess it would fit in financial gain, therefore white colar crime.
- Hitton 6y agoThere is no motivation for that. White collar criminals, especially the big ones are generally well connected, have powerful acquaintances, often know dirt on other people and mostly steal from either little fish and government (if they steal from corporations, there is often fault on the side of the corp. too and no one wants it to be very public so stocks dont fall even more) and their crimes usually benefit other rich/powerful people (often stockholders), it would be rather inconvenient to air such dirty laundry. On the other hand pirates have no noteworthy connections whatsoever and mostly damage big corporations who have money to lobby for their punishment.
- smabie 6y agoWhat kind of people are you talking about?