2 ms·
The important difference is that credit card details are a shared "secret". You can't use your credit card number and CVV with Amazon without giving those numbe
by tialaramex 6y ago
The important difference is that credit card details are a shared "secret". You can't use your credit card number and CVV with Amazon without giving those numbers to Amazon, which is the exact same thing a crook would try to trick you into doing.
Whereas the whole point of a public key system is that nobody needs your private key. So we don't need to provide individuals and businesses with a way to give their private key to somebody else. The only reason you'd give your private key to somebody else is because you want them to seamlessly impersonate you forever, so there's no need to make it any easier than, for example, giving your kidney to somebody else.
Concrete example: A WebAuthn/ U2F "Security Key" offers no way to get the Private Keys out. If you want to "steal" the credentials used to get into my GitHub your best bet is to somehow trick me into physically packaging up the USB authenticator itself and sending that to you by FedEx or something. Or maybe you could try putting a knife to my throat or something?