3 ms·
The circumstances that enabled Certificate Transparency to succeed were pretty narrow, but people seem to keep proposing more of these X Transparency systems so
by tialaramex 6y ago
The circumstances that enabled Certificate Transparency to succeed were pretty narrow, but people seem to keep proposing more of these X Transparency systems so maybe I should actually properly write down why I think that's largely futile, not because I expect it will stop anyone but because at least then I can just paste the link.
For now, let me highlight a really big consideration:
- Most of the effectiveness of CT logs stems from the logging mandate not the cryptography. The publicly trusted CAs proactively log either everything they issue or all but some relatively small controlled subset of issued certificates which purposefully fall outside the mandate.
Will your X transparency be mandatory? Who will enforce that? Won't it be more practical to reject systems that try to mandate X transparency than to implement it?