17 ms·
I would've just sent the DMCA notice. It's not a "whole process", it's a couple lines of text you copy/paste, put in the URL of your site and the copy, change t
by dangrossman 16y ago
I would've just sent the DMCA notice. It's not a "whole process", it's a couple lines of text you copy/paste, put in the URL of your site and the copy, change the date, and email to the host. It'll take you a few seconds to modify and send out. Most web hosts have a specific mailbox for DMCA notices on their contact page or in their AUP.
Subject: DMCA Notice of Copyright Infringement
The copyrighted work at issue is the text that appears on: [URL(s)]
The URLs where our copyrighted material is located include: [URL(s)]
You can reach me at [email] for further information or clarification. My phone number is [phone] and my mailing address is [physical address].
I have a good faith belief that use of the copyrighted materials described above as allegedly infringing is not authorized by the copyright owner, its agent, or the law.
I swear, under penalty of perjury, that the information in the notification is accurate and that I am the copyright owner or am authorized to act on behalf of the owner of an exclusive right that is allegedly infringed.
[your name]
[today's date]
Never once have I had a DMCA notice not result in the material taken down within 24 hours, even when the host was outside the US. None of them want to potentially be a party to a copyright infringement suit, however unlikely it may be that you'd take it to court and drag the host into it.
- cstross 16y agoNever once have I had a DMCA notice not result in the material taken down within 24 hours I have! The culprit -- whose copyright agent [edit]appears not to[/edit] respond to DMCA takedown notices unless they come on law firm letterhead -- is none other than Amazon.com. (I've caught scumbags selling books of mine online as ebooks via the Kindle store. Amazon don't listen unless you carry a big stick. My solution was to grab the nearest big stick, in this case SFWA's Griefcom process, but something like that's not really an option for most self-published authors.) (In contrast, Apple -- same situation, only in the iBook store -- were the very model of efficiency and helpfulness.)
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- jedsmith 16y ago> The culprit -- whose copyright agent doesn't respond to DMCA takedown notices unless they come on law firm letterhead -- is none other than Amazon.com. That's illegal. There are well-defined bullet points that make a valid DMCA complaint that must be acted upon, and I doubt Amazon would open themselves up to liability based on "big sticks". They'd lose safe harbor for not complying, which is extremely bad news for EC2 and any Internet hosting provider.
- dangrossman 16y agoIt's not illegal, you just can't claim the benefits of the limited liability section if you don't register a copyright agent and respond to DMCA notices.
- jedsmith 16y agoThe DMCA is a law. Not following the rules of OCILLA is not acting according to law, which is identified by the word illegal. Illegal has nothing to do with criminality.
- dangrossman 16y agoSorry, but no. The DMCA simply says "A service provider shall not be liable...if the conditions set forth...are met". It does not compel ISPs to make those conditions true. They're not "not acting according to law" by not actively creating the circumstances in which the DMCA provides the limitation of liability. http://www.copyright.gov/legislation/hr2281.pdf http://www.copyright.gov/legislation/hr2281.pdf
- cstross 16y agoLegal or not, it's what they're doing. And it's not just me: http://nielsenhayden.com/makinglight/archives/012933.html http://nielsenhayden.com/makinglight/archives/012933.html
- jedsmith 16y agoIf someone were to pursue it further and remind Amazon that not following OCILLA means being liable for every single copyright infringement that they host, whether on EC2, S3 (looking forward to that one!), or the Kindle store, they might change their tune.
- DarkShikari 16y agoI deal with companies ripping off GPL software. Not a single company -- or the webhosts they use -- have ever responded to a DMCA request.
- pingswept 16y agoDo you mean that the infringers have ignored the takedown request, or do you mean they have all silently complied?
- DarkShikari 16y agoIgnored, completely.
- jbk 16y agoAnd I do have exactly the same experience. In almost every language, a research for "vlc" gives you either adwords for scams, adware, software+toolbars, software+homepage-changer or websites in the first page of Google results (using rings to get higher). Most of the time, they don't offer the source, modify something and do not offer the source, or abuse trademarks. Since Google refuses to remove them from index, or from adwords, the only way is to DMCA them. I have literally sent hundreds of DMCA. It almost never works.