4 ms·
The font is certainly interesting conceptually, and doesn't look bad (though is largely indistinguishable from its "Garamond" source at normal sizes). And whil
by crazygringo 6y ago
The font is certainly interesting conceptually, and doesn't look bad (though is largely indistinguishable from its "Garamond" source at normal sizes).
And while I've read the whole thing and understand why the author considers this to be a "Brutalist" philosophy, I respectfully disagree. This is merely vectors adhering to a grid, which has nothing to do with the "exposing raw materials" philosophy that is the core of Brutalism. [1]
To me, early pixel-based terminal fonts feel like the digital typography version of Brutalism -- not even attempting curves or calligraphy at all, but embracing the raw material of pixels for exactly what they are.
If the author wants to bring a similar Brutalist raw-materials approach to modern vector-based typography I'd find that interesting as well -- but that would seem to have been done a long time ago, with typography based solely on primitive geometric shapes, of which classic typefaces from the 20th century would seem most suitable (Futura [2], Avant Garde [3]).
In the end, Signifier is a cool concept typeface. But I unfortunately think the author fails at connecting it to Brutalism in any meaningful way, despite their attempt.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brutalist_architecture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brutalist_architecture
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Futura_(typeface) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Futura_(typeface)
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ITC_Avant_Garde https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ITC_Avant_Garde
- armandososa 6y agoI don't think the point is "vectors adhering to a grid", quite the contrary it looks to me that the author is exposing the raw materials of a font which are, essentially, bezier curves expressed as ones and zeroes. I think the image that better conveys that idea is this: https://d14810e2jnirzn.cloudfront.net/media/documents/Signifier-Sharpness-Blunt-Heldane-a.svg https://d14810e2jnirzn.cloudfront.net/media/documents/Signif... The non-signifier fonts have some extra points in their bezier curves, which are bits in disk, traveling on the network, stored in memory and processed by the rendering engine that are going to be completely wasted when rendered at 16pts. That's quite profound for me. And I'm not an authority in Brutalism, but looks like the author was faithful to what he thinks brutalism is concerned with (from the article): > Brutalism is not concerned with the material as such but rather the quality of the material, that is with the question: what can it do?
- jiggawatts 6y agoThat link is broken.
- Semiapies 6y agoBrutalism has been hot the last year or two, so people like to emptily invoke it for their own designs.
- HelloNurse 6y agoI understand Brutalist architecture to be characterized by the avoidance of arbitrary ornaments added to the actual structure of the building, which should be embraced and valued rather than hidden and considered too plain. In the case of a digital font, there are only a bunch of splines, without separate "layers" of structure and ornaments. The difference between loose rounded curves and sharp quantized curves is therefore the same as the difference between buildings with different room shapes, not the difference between more or less Brutalist styles. Even if not meaningfully Brutalist, this font makes sense (the reasons to prefer quantized shapes are particularly valid) and looks surprisingly good, and that's what should matter.
- FoundersGrotesk 6y agoI agree — it’s been a buzzword in the graphic design industry for at least 10 years now. During Signifier’s 15 year development I've seen many trends surface and disappear! And during the a year we spent working on the marketing concept and approach for Signifier, I struggled with even mentioning the term “Brutalism”. In the end, I decided it was OK, because it was true to my process, research and thinking. We work very hard to ensure concept, execution and communication are as solid as they possibly can be. I would never emptily invoke anything.
- FoundersGrotesk 6y agoI take your points about bitmap fonts for early pixel displays. They were determined by the coarse raster of the screen. But screens have evolved, and manually bitmapping every px size for every physical screen resolution would be a fool's errand. The early bitmap fonts embraced the the raw material of the pixel, but their underlying form and structure were determined by (at least) 500 years of typographic history and evolution. These days, the “raw material” of digital fonts is not bitmaps but curves. Of course, they're all rasterized one way or another for print or screens! I am comfortable that I’ve brought a Brutalist ethic to Signifier. I think you’re conflating geometric primitivism with a material sensibility. The designers of Futura (and other geometric typefaces) were not concerned with the material of their production, rather the aesthetic sensibilities of the era. The history of vectors and splines for drawing shapes is not predicated on making primitives per se, (rects, circles, triangles etc,) but articulating complex, subtle curves. The broader history of letterforms is skewed heavily towards articulating subtle curves rather than primitive shapes, so the actual style of Signifier’s letterforms are aligned towards the shapes, proportions and rhythm of early typefaces rather than 20th century models. And yes — Signiifer is largely indistinguishable from “Garamond” at small sizes is largely the point! There’s even a bit in the design info about it. Thank you for making that observation.